NY 165: A Large Normal (Game Over!)

[DOMO]

Also I laughed way too much at the image PV decided to use for Serene's death.

Yes, me too.

[kuribo]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=31325

I was reading along in this game. TSO made a post saying "hey remember that time that kuribo as town fake claimed masons with a town bulletproof and then got him lynched?" and we, the mafia, had narrowed down the potential SK slots down to only Serene or THe Savage slot. I ran my replace out post INCLUDING THE SHADI COMMENT by the backup mod, DV, before posting it. So those of you that called me a cheater can go eat shit and die.

you're not a cheater, but ironically, you unvoting us for that reason and then flipping mafia would have confirmed us as town---

the only "outside information" you could have gotten as scum would be that we're not the SK (you'd already know if we were scum with you)


hence, "i replace out, knowing someone else's alignment, unvote: serene" and then flipping scum... directly confirms us as town


but we died that night, so

[ActionDan]

I know I read that claim and was like LOL I KNOW WHO IM LYNCHING.

re: that's why. I looked at this game the day BS was lynched.

[BROseidon]

we were of the opinion as recently as half an hour before crab's flip that you OR AP were scum with him, but probably not both, so I can't really know where it would have went after AP's flip

The issue was that, at a certain point, you'd have realized that one of myself/PA/Shadi were scum, and of that group you probably would have latched onto me because PA didn't make sense as scum, and me being alive at that point would have been really strange as town given how strongly I was getting townread after day 2.

That ProHawk kill worked wonders

[BROseidon]

Also that was really shitty of TSO to post holy fucking shit.

[kuribo]

PA was so obviously town that we actually considered the COP to be scum over P_A

[AngryPidgeon]

TSO made a post saying "hey remember that time that kuribo as town fake claimed masons with a town bulletproof and then got him lynched?"

Wow, how fucking stupid.

[kuribo]

as i pointed out in the Serene hydra QT, what was really funny was when someone asked if any of us would fakeclaim masons with our scumbuddy


Every single person in Serene has done that at one time or another

(DGB and I claimed masons together in the first Gay Mafia, Fate famously won a game doing it)

[AngryPidgeon]

Ya PA was really town this game.

She only survived so long because we had a mountain of all-but-conftown PRs and Sks to wade through.

And Serene had to die over her because they wanted me.

Im glad we went with BRO's intuition on the kill - I was ready to kill Ankamius.

[BROseidon]

PA was so obviously town that we actually considered the COP to be scum over P_A

Trying to push Ank as someone who bussed a scumpartner was not ever really off the table.

pedit: Yeah, the Ank kill there would have probably lost us the game >.>

[DOMO]

I tell you what though, if I've learned anything in the last six months, it's that BRO is always scum and should be PL'ed on day fucking one.

BRO, my apologies are due to you for comments I made to my brief hydra partner on day one... I said to him you were our "weakest link" and that's why I was happy to bus you so early. I can say with all honesty though that I'm very pleased to be made to look stupid there.

[Cabd]

Actually, unvoting is a thing that just kinda is standard for me to do whenever replacing out. Like I said, entire post including unvote was ran by mod team first.


(And BRO i don't mean you, I mean peeps from the dead QT)

[AngryPidgeon]

I tracked orcinus on day 1 because I thought he did a BSG-harkback crumb that I'd be the only player to pick up.

What did you think you saw?

[Cabd]

But BRO is town and if he isn't I will scummy nom him a thousand times over. I will fly to wherever he is and I will grovel at his feet because that would be a higher plane of existence than what my life otherwise would ever be

[DOMO]

Is BRO always scum?

[Cabd]

But BRO is town and if he isn't I will scummy nom him a thousand times over. I will fly to wherever he is and I will grovel at his feet because that would be a higher plane of existence than what my life otherwise would ever be

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 0#p5385270

[AngryPidgeon]

hence, "i replace out, knowing someone else's alignment, unvote: serene" and then flipping scum... directly confirms us as town

Not really.

Unvoting your current vote when you replace out is a courteous thing to do regardless of anything.

[BROseidon]

I tell you what though, if I've learned anything in the last six months, it's that BRO is always scum and should be PL'ed on day fucking one.

BRO, my apologies are due to you for comments I made to my brief hydra partner on day one... I said to him you were our "weakest link" and that's why I was happy to bus you so early. I can say with all honesty though that I'm very pleased to be made to look stupid there.

I have 15 completed games, of which 3 are scumgames.

I'm scum roughly 20% of the time, seems right.

In all fairness, this game started before Xenoblade ended, which I still can't believe I pulled off.

[kuribo]

Trying to push Ank as someone who bussed a scumpartner was not ever really off the table.

pedit: Yeah, the Ank kill there would have probably lost us the game >.>

the Ank scumread was pretty much Fate and I deciding that claiming X-shot cop and then faking a guilty on your own buddy while clearing one and clearing a townie sounded like some shit we would have pulled

[kuribo]

Unvoting your current vote when you replace out is a courteous thing to do regardless of anything.

Alot of people don't though.

And besides, DGB and I were both in Antihero Mafia with TSO, we already knew what crabd meant when he replaced out an hour or so after that happened.

[AngryPidgeon]

I cant believe you guys thought Rift was town.

She was acting like me from StateFarm mafia, it was super obvs town. I guess Im scum so Im biased, but killing Ffery was like #1 on my Evil to-do list.

[AngryPidgeon]

Errrrrrrr and by town I mean scum. Dat scum slip.

[kuribo]

it was just the fact that she stayed alive so long when everyone read her as town

[kuribo]

also pigeon, congratulations on being one of the elite few that can say I posted for them a selfie of me calling them scum

[AngryPidgeon]

hahaha, I forgot you had. I was loosely planning on doing one myself just to be a snarky scumbutt