Mini 1501: We're On A Boat! (END?! results inside)

[fferyllt]

I'm still alive

Ffery upon reread, my read of Spyrex changed, although his whole neighborhood bit today leaves a bad taste in my mouth

Which part? The part where I asked if checking the neighborhood would be a waste of my time and then it was a waste of my time?

----

Ok, for whatever reason this game we're having a real cloud of lazy, and it needs to stop. I'm even getting hit by it and part of that is in rereading I saw... nothing.

I would love for every person in their next post to either vote for NS or explain to me why he's a bad vote - and, by that, I mean why he's town. If you've got another super awesome case on someone, lets do it. Lets quit belaboring and cause some action.

I think notsci is town. I've played two very recent games where he was town and scum. He's changing his approach to mafia, and some of the changes have taken place during this game and appear to have been fueled by how some other games that were ongoing at the same time resolved. But, it still strikes me as town-notsci. You have data I don't have. But I feel like I have experiential meta to evaluate that even people who followed those games don't have to the same degree.

I haven't voted CDB yet mostly because I wanted to get your thoughts about him, SK and maybe Grimgroove.

Grimgroove, aside from replacing YYR, mostly strikes me as likely town based on his posts.

[SpyreX]

I still think CDB is town. Its not something really quantifiable but he makes... sense. I can follow his play from a town point a lot more than others.

SK, I thought was town but with the houdini act after a dead scum I get nervous.

Grimgroove is a lot more town than his predecessor. The stream of consciousness is a pretty ballsy scum entrance there.

So, of them, I'd maaybe vote SK but I'd rather vote CTD OR Plum before any of them. And thats still low tier to NS.

[fferyllt]

I've only played one game with CDB. It was an ongoing until yesterday.

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... er_sort=Go

He was a lot more aggressive in that game, and was instrumental in getting some bandwagons started and later dismantled.

He worried the scum team enough that we killed him instead of the outed doctor on night 1.

[SpyreX]

I'm not a huge meta guy so thats not going to be a sell for me.

[Plum]

ChannelDelibird, Plum, Peabody, and Spyrex were all prodded.

Prodding is my raison d'etre

I got errors all last night trying to connect to the site. I tried.

I would love for every person in their next post to either vote for NS or explain to me why he's a bad vote - and, by that, I mean why he's town. If you've got another super awesome case on someone, lets do it. Lets quit belaboring and cause some action.

Far from sure he's Town, but pretty sure CDB is a better vote.

[fferyllt]

Ok.

I"m somewhere in the middle on the meta-dependence scale, but experiential meta is gold.

I am reading some old and cold games for comparison purposes. Maybe the game I linked is anomalous.

[Grimgroove]

I would love for every person in their next post to either vote for NS or explain to me why he's a bad vote - and, by that, I mean why he's town.

I think notscience is town. Its not something really quantifiable but he makes... sense. I can follow his play from a town point a lot more than others.

[Grimgroove]

My case on CDB: check my ISO starting from post 1061

My case on SleepyKrew: 939 (still unaddressed by SleepyKrew)

Brian Skies also made a good case in 937 and Peabody's ISO is also full of good arguments to lynch SleepyKrew.

[ChannelDelibird]

Ack, sorry, Football Manager stole my weekend. Post coming when I've digested the new Arcade Fire album. Priorities.

[Grimgroove]

I have found out what the blinking-pattern in SpyreX' avatar is.

This is how boring this game has become through all your prod dodges.

[fferyllt]

I've read through an assortment of recent CDB games and I'm not seeing anything that changes how I feel about his play in this one.

VOTE: CDB

Links and shit on request.

[notscience]

VOTE: CDB

CHOO CHOO

[Grimgroove]

^ L-1

notscience, stop looking scummy, your antics will possibly halt this wagon on scum. Thank you for your understanding.

[notscience]

Wait what

Rofl

UNVOTE:

Didn't realize that was L-1

[pitoli]

Only the man who isn’t rowing has time to rock the boat.
~ Jean-Paul Sartre

VOTE COUNT 2.3

notscience (2):

SpyreX, CrashTextDummie

ChannelDelibird (4):

Garmr, Grimgroove, Plum, fferyllt

SleepyKrew (1):

Peabody

Plum (1):

ChannelDelibird

Not Voting:

SleepyKrew, notscience

With 10 alive, it takes 6 votes to lynch.

Time until deadline: (expired on 2013-11-03 00:00:00)

Mod Notes

:

[Peabody]

Notscience is pinging as town to me. Sorry, Spyrex, but it's mostly meta reasons. I can expand if you want, but if you request it, it'll be a wall-post.

I'm not liking SK's coasting the entire day. If we lynch CDB without hearing from SK at all, I'll be disappointed. I really want to hear SK's answer to GG's question at the end of the day yesterday.

[fferyllt]

If we lynch CDB without hearing from SK at all, I'll be disappointed. I really want to hear SK's answer to GG's question at the end of the day yesterday.

Agree.

[pitoli]

Searching for a replacement for SleepyKrew. Definitely should have gotten on this sooner but SK kept promising me things ;____;

[Garmr]

My town list overflow my scum reads and nulls is that a good or bad thing.

[notscience]

My town list overflow my scum reads and nulls is that a good or bad thing.

Maybe you should elaborate on this more so we know what you're tryign to ask

[CrashTextDummie]

I just can't get back into this game. Hopefully, an SK replacement can breathe new life into it.

I'm still not okay with a CDB lynch.

notscience, stop looking scummy, your antics will possibly halt this wagon on scum. Thank you for your understanding.

I didn't really see this as scummy antics. Antics, sure, but more the "let's make something happen" kind. The "whoops, didn't mean to put him at L-1" take-back is more problematic to me. I don't really understand why you'd object to your #1 suspect being put at L-1.

unvote, vote: Plum

[notscience]

I didn't really see this as scummy antics. Antics, sure, but more the "let's make something happen" kind. The "whoops, didn't mean to put him at L-1" take-back is more problematic to me. I don't really understand why you'd object to your #1 suspect being put at L-1.

I never said he was my number 1 scumspect. I sheeped Ffery.

Nice try.

[Plum]

CTD - por que?

[SpyreX]

I dont know what it is about this game, but there's still not any bite. I don't like the CDB Wagon, at all.

[Garmr]

My town list overflow my scum reads and nulls is that a good or bad thing.

Maybe you should elaborate on this more so we know what you're tryign to ask

It means that CDB and SK are my only scum reads.

You and peabody are bumped up to null GG stays a null

The rest are town reads. I never had so many reads in a game ever the most it think before this was 2-3.