Dr Who: The Last Great Time War GAME OVER!!

[DrippingGoofball]

DGB's playing like redscum. That's what happened.

Explain that. Explain how I'm playing like "red scum" as opposed to, say, "SK."

You're full of it.

[DrippingGoofball]

Scum shouldn't quickhammer because only a mislynch benefits scum here.

Presumably the SK and the red scum don't know each other. Therefore, any lynch, to either SK or red scum, is a delicious mislynch.

So your statement is complete rubbish.

[DrippingGoofball]

The fact that titus is SK hunting so hard makes him the SK, it's classic, and the kind of thing I would do.

Yeah Titus has got to be scum.

[Titus]

Usually you are right. However in this istance, lynching one scum means he final scum is in a 2 v 1.

A town lynch means the high likihood of 1 v 1 v 1, which is more beneficial to the scums.

[DrippingGoofball]

The fact that titus is SK hunting so hard makes him the SK, it's classic, and the kind of thing I would do.

It's the selective hunting for one of the remaining factions that points to Titus as scum. Titus would do this as SK, or red scum, BUT NOT AS TOWN.

[DrippingGoofball]

Usually you are right. However in this istance, lynching one scum means he final scum is in a 2 v 1.

A town lynch means the high likihood of 1 v 1 v 1, which is more beneficial to the scums.

I'm glad to see that someone is keeping track of the scum's long-term odds!

[DrippingGoofball]

Connections and not connections with titus. I'm very tired, I probably won't be able to explain it. I haven't really been very good at this game in the last few months. Kind of royally fucked up everything, in general. Can't really explain things anymore.

Call it gut I guess.

Please unvote Candillan. I don't think I'll vote Candillan today - but Shiidaji could come and quicklynch as the second scum on the wagon.

[Titus]

I have hunted both. I suggested the lynch pool exclude td and shii therefore leaving three goon options. Because I gambited, you are selective hunting. Hah!

Dgb is caught scum failing and tryin to force a mislynch. Pah. Everyone should know the consequences of a mislynch before voting. The fact that was news to you DGB is a slip as you don't know the obvious.

Wrap this up. Candi, DGB scums.

[Titus]

DGB's playing like redscum. That's what happened.

Explain that. Explain how I'm playing like "red scum" as opposed to, say, "SK."

You're full of it.

1) IAI's gambit

2) Refusal to lynch Candi or argue why he's town despite sort of lylo.

3) Your voting history.

[DrippingGoofball]

You're really in a hurry to "wrap this up" aren't you?

[DrippingGoofball]

1) IAI's gambit >>>

that was the correct play, would you want DV muddying up the waters today?

2) Refusal to lynch Candi or argue why he's town despite sort of lylo. >>>

That's because I am TOWN.

3) Your voting history. >>>

You can't just say that.

[Titus]

You refuse to argue Candi town because you're town. That makes no sense.

I wasn't questioning your vote on DV in 1. I was saying IAI's gambit bought you time. See yesterday's arguments on you being redscum.

Why cn't I say your vote history supports dgb redscum?

[DrippingGoofball]

Usually you are right. However in this istance, lynching one scum means he final scum is in a 2 v 1.

A town lynch means the high likihood of 1 v 1 v 1, which is more beneficial to the scums.

Actually you're wrong.

We're 5 players.

We lynch scum correctly

:
one NK. Tomorrow we're

2 townies v 1 scum, whichever one we didn't kill the previous day.

We mislynch

:
Go into night 2 townies, 1 SK, 1 mafia.
> No x-kill: two dead townies, 1 SK v 1 mafia , assuming BP-SK, that means

auto-win for the SK.

> 1 X-kill, SK successful targeting mafia, mafia targets townie: (1 dead mafia) 1 townie v 1 SK endgame,

auto-win for the SK.

> 1 X-kill, mafia successful targeting SK, but fails assuming BP-SK, SK kills townie: 1 townie v 1 SK v 1 mafia endgame

66% chance of mafia+SK win?

.
> 2 X-kill, mafia successful targeting SK, but fails assuming BP-SK, SK kills mafia:

2 townies v 1 SK

UNLIKELY SCENARIOS:
> 2 X-kill, both work:

2 townies, town auto-win

> 1 X-kill, mafia successful targeting SK, SK dies, SK kills townie:

2 townie vs 1 mafia endgame

[DrippingGoofball]

You refuse to argue Candi town because you're town

I told you I believe his explanations, and I liked his reactions.

[DrippingGoofball]

Why cn't I say your vote history supports dgb redscum?

You can't just say that. You have to explain it.

I can say YOUR vote history supports you being scum if I feel like it.

It's easy to pull accusations out of one's ass if one doesn't have to support them with evidence.

[DrippingGoofball]

Assuming that both red scum and SK have made their end game calculations properly (and it's a big assumption), the red scum would be quite highly motivated to find the SK today.

The SK doesn't give a rat's tutu who gets lynched today. A town lynch would favor the SK.

So SK

favors

town lynch, and red scum

desperately needs

SK lynch.

[DrippingGoofball]

My current working hypothesis is this:

Titus is red scum, believes Candillan to be the SK, is desperate to lynch Candillan.
SK is hiding in the lurkmass: Shiidaji or TD.

[DrippingGoofball]

My working hypothesis doesn't conflict with this, which is nice:

DGB = town
Candillan = NOT-SK
TD = cleared non-red for what it's worth
Shiidaji = cleared non-red for what it's worth
Titus = SK-hunting hard.

That leaves red scum in

Titus

/Candillan > TD/Shiidaji

And SK in

TD/Shiidaji

> Titus

[DrippingGoofball]

THIS is what we need to do today. We need to lynch scum correctly.

I don't think Titus cares, seeing how he's leaving his vote in the second position making his target vulnerable to a scum LOLhammer.

We lynch scum correctly

:
one NK. Tomorrow we're

2 townies v 1 scum, whichever one we didn't kill the previous day.

[DrippingGoofball]

We also don't care if we lynch SK or red scum. Both will work equally well.

[Titus]

DGB, if I was hypothetically convinced that Candi was redscum, I would push for a lynch on anyone but him. I have already said scum benefit from a mislynch here. Both scum are equally positioned and want a mislynch. I don't.


You are unwilling to argue Candi town but unwilling to vote him. Classic scum.

[DrippingGoofball]

Don't take any notice of him. He's just having one of his funny turns.

Oversoul was Romanna II, Vanilla Town Exterminated Night 6

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch

(expired on 2013-11-01 11:23:03)

till Day 6 Deadline

Note - with players below 10 the deadline has been reduced

Single kill, Oct 10-14 are the dates for night.

[DrippingGoofball]

You are unwilling to argue Candi town but unwilling to vote him. Classic scum.

I said he's NOT-SK.

[DrippingGoofball]

I don't see Candillan desperate to lynch the SK today.

[DrippingGoofball]

Shiidaji was posting around the site during that night, she would have sent a NK if she had one.