Open 534 - Killing at the Frat (Day 5)

[Sound of Silence]

bubba, I think by distancing they mean that by attacking each other we are scum making it look like we aren't on the same side

Who is "they"? Has more than one player made that argument?

North-east England dialect.

Is that why you are voting for me?

I thought I was missing something.

And that's not why we are voting you.

[BoroPhil]

who's we? are you speaking for more than one player?

[BoroPhil]

and also, you might want to put some reasons alongside your vote. this is generally helpful.

[Sound of Silence]

7. Sound of Silence (fferylit+GuyinFreezer)

EspeciallyTheLies

Wake88

This is a hydra account. fferyllt and GiF both log in to this account to post, and we (mostly) reach consensus on our reads and votes. When talking about a vote, "we" is the correct pronoun.

You've been talking to fferyllt today.

[Sound of Silence]

posturing really.

What's your read of dry-fit? In fact, what are your reads in general? I checked your iso for a reads list, and didn't see one.

I see you are townreading dry-fit. You feel that his post was posturing?

[Sound of Silence]

Town

Marcrell
Dry-Fit
startfromtheheart
Nachomamma8
notscience
Neonizer

Lean Town

Sakura Hana
bubbajack

Null

Mario4
Ms Marangal

Scum

Regina
Borophil

<-- you are here

Jester

Sound of Silence

[BoroPhil]

yeah, I was joking with you.

I meant I was posturing when I said we should end the day now and just lynch bubbjack. This was the question I failed to answer at 259 which he flagged up.

[BoroPhil]

You should feel really bad about your reads then. Unless you are scum ofc.

Why is regina scum?

and I can't see what notscience has done at all to make you think they are town.

in fact that's a pretty hideous list of reads. Jester sounds apt.

[Sound of Silence]

@Mod: please replace Regina with Marquis~

I don't remember Sakura AtE.

Maybe ISO a few people showing up on a lot of scumlists and see if you agree?

Pretty sure the significant one there would be me. Which isn't exactly right though I'm surprised I haven't been outright lynched yet.

You're getting a short window here to do something useful, btw.

[BoroPhil]

in fact have a big OMGUS

UNVOTE:
VOTE: startfromtheheart

I noticed you didn't try to rebute it. Do you not have an answer to the points?

what exactly needs rebutting? what was contradictory about what I said?

I mean you didn't say anything about how he analyzed your posts. You just called the vote lazy and stupid. That can technically be counted as rebutting it, but without much besides calling it lazy and stupid it isn't much of one.

this is what he said:

First one asks us to end the day ASAP (paraphrase) by lynching bubba

Second is a vote ns, third asks us if we agree that those who make the most noise d1 are town

and that was his reasoning for voting me. are these good reasons to you?

lynching bubba? I think that's a good idea. why doesn't he tell me why it isn't if it's bad.
voting notscience. again, I think that's a good idea. why doesn't he tell me why it isn't if it's bad
are those who make most noise d1 town? valid question. if not, why not.

what's not to like about those 3 posts?

[BoroPhil]

you have encouraged me to make a bit more effort here anyway SoS, so thanks for that. this was drifting along somewhat.

[Sound of Silence]

You should feel really bad about your reads then. Unless you are scum ofc.

Why is regina scum?

Being useless, placing caseless and opportunistic votes, complete lack of responsiveness to questions that were asked throughout the entire game until Bert and I followed Nacho's vote last night.

and I can't see what notscience has done at all to make you think they are town.

Partly a meta read. GiF and I both are in complete agreement on this read atm. But, to be fair we were in complete agreement that notsci was town on day 1 of the cash cabd game, too.

in fact that's a pretty hideous list of reads.

GiF, what do you think? Should we sig this?

Jester sounds apt.

GiF reads us as jester. It must be true!

[BoroPhil]

Regina's vote for bubba at #100 was fine. Bubba's response to being questioned was to throw out a few smileys. scumcity.

[BoroPhil]

well wtf happened here

Quoting someone who smells werewolfy.

Loads of pages not enouhg substance.

Don't like mara atm which is weird to say

I like ETLs replace out because before that I have sneaky suspicion him and NS were scum.

Now I think Hi two townies.

and what makes you so sure neonizer is town?

they don't seem to have done a lot, and the bottom of this is bizarre.

before ETL replaced out, ETL/NS were scum.

now they are both town.

what?

[BoroPhil]

and as for bubba, did you manage to read the first few pages?

[Sound of Silence]

REGINA's ~reasons~

oh i dunno mostly cuz i forgot i was voting the guy i'm voting

You're voting Wake and he has a scum role pm and needs to die

Nacho isn't even voting anyone.

Just went to check. MM is correct. Which would explain how Nacho "forgot who he was voting". the question is why is notscience pushing Wake? And saying that Nacho is voting him when he's not.

@Boro: You want to give reasons besides just saying it's "interesting?" -_-

I don't quite like this post at all

UNVOTE:
VOTE: bubbajack8

Everyone's just talking about how people usually play

but I'm not about that yo.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Wake

I like thinking of him as scum. It makes sense. The argument is less confusing, at least.

This vote was not counted, as Wake is no longer in the game

I like notscience a lot. He's very pretty. ETL is also very pretty but I think she's either scum or wrong. I'm not sure.

Basically, he's been trolling and has put down votes and reads for reasons that would be all but impossible to hold him accountable for.

[Sound of Silence]

and as for bubba, did you manage to read the first few pages?

I read every page in a frenzy of catch-up last night. I could mostly follow bubba's reasoning. GiF has played with bubba and has a light town meta read to go along with our impressions from this game.

[Sound of Silence]

well wtf happened here

Quoting someone who smells werewolfy.

Loads of pages not enouhg substance.

Don't like mara atm which is weird to say

I like ETLs replace out because before that I have sneaky suspicion him and NS were scum.

Now I think Hi two townies.

and what makes you so sure neonizer is town?

I'm townreading him because his pricklyness about being townread comes off very town, especially given his time on-site.

they don't seem to have done a lot, and the bottom of this is bizarre.

before ETL replaced out, ETL/NS were scum.

now they are both town.

what?

The way people replace out - the trajectory of frustration, anger and what they're reacting to leading up to the replace-out - can be very revealing of their alignment. And probably the most revealing thing about NS for anyone who wasn't townreading him already was his reaction to our replace-in to a slot he'd scum-read through two prior occupants.

[notscience]

bert's town
sos is town
#easymode

Why is SoS town Nacho

I really really really really really think they're scum

[Sakura Hana]

I really really really really really think they're scum

Well keep thinking that, but they are town.

[Neonizer]

well wtf happened here

Quoting someone who smells werewolfy.

Loads of pages not enouhg substance.

Don't like mara atm which is weird to say

I like ETLs replace out because before that I have sneaky suspicion him and NS were scum.

Now I think Hi two townies.

and what makes you so sure neonizer is town?

they don't seem to have done a lot, and the bottom of this is bizarre.

before ETL replaced out, ETL/NS were scum.

now they are both town.

what?

basically I thought it was scum theatre. ETL replacing out and raging while doing it, means it was not

[BROseidon]

The bros chill out as they drink their delicious keystone. As they chill, they realize that there are still killers among them, and that they need to find the OTP brothers among them.

Vote Count 1.10:

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch

Dry-Fit – Marcrell
bubbajack8 – Marquis
BoroPhil – Sound of Silence
startfromtheheart – Neonizer, BoroPhil, Sakura Hana
Sound of Silence – notscience, Mario4
Nachomamma8 – Ms Marangal
notscience – bubbajack8,
Marquis – Dry-Fit, Nachomamma8, startfromtheheart

Not voting:

Deadline is in (expired on 2013-11-07 11:29:24)

REGINA+ is replaced by Marquis.

[Marcrell]

You should feel really bad about your reads then. Unless you are scum ofc.

I really really really really really think they're scum

Well keep thinking that, but they are town.

Can you guys please stop just stating someone is either scum or town without citing anything. At least say something or link to a post where either you or someone else gave reasons for the point you're defending.

[Ms Marangal]

UNVOTE:

[Sakura Hana]

You should feel really bad about your reads then. Unless you are scum ofc.

I really really really really really think they're scum

Well keep thinking that, but they are town.

Can you guys please stop just stating someone is either scum or town without citing anything. At least say something or link to a post where either you or someone else gave reasons for the point you're defending.

I already stated that my reasons lie within ETL's AtE and replace out.