Newbie 1425 Part Deux -- Game Over

[Nobody Special]

Votecount 3.03

(unchanged)

Malakittens - 1 - RayFrost

Not Voting: ObsessedWithCats, Malakittens, ArcAngel9, Smudger

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

Deadline: (expired on 2013-11-23 06:14:05)

[Smudger]

AA what do you think we could reasonably achieve over the time we have? While your motive for your request
makes sense it also allows for more doubt to enter into people's thoughts, actually it could be counter productive? However notwithstanding your reasoning the thread is so slow how much more information can be gained do you think?

[Nobody Special]

ObsessedWithCats has been prodded.

[ObsessedWithCats]

Smudger has a good point ArcAngel - we all seem reasonably decided on who we think looks scummiest. We're not voting because we don't want to rush, but nothing else is happening because there doesn't seem much else to happen. If you want more discussion you're going to have to do something to initiate it.

VOTE: Malakittens

That's L - 1

[Smudger]

Oh interesting .....

VOTE: ObsessedwithCats

[ObsessedWithCats]

What have I said now?

[RayFrost]

I swear to god.

If mala isn't lynched I will be done with this game in heart and mind. The most I can see cats being accused of at the moment is a lack of activity and individual initiative.

Guess what the majority of players alive this game have? A lack of activity and individual initiative. See: Mala's indecision on who to vote and unwillingness to be clear, arc's indecision and hesitancy to even form a solid stance on things to work from, smudger only barely taking a clear stance on things.

Also note mala's lack of posting, arc's lack of posting, the fact cats had to be prodded to post, etc, etc.

[Smudger]

Cats, you put Mala at L1 what is your reasoning? Ray stop with the indignant hurt routine, you and Cats remain on my sus list.

[ObsessedWithCats]

I've told you Mala is my best suspect, we're not gonna get a lynch by not voting for anyone and sitting there with Mala at L - 2 was clearly neither generating discussion nor producing information.

[RayFrost]

Cats, you put Mala at L1 what is your reasoning? Ray stop with the indignant hurt routine, you and Cats remain on my sus list.

I'm not hurt, nor am I acting like I am. This game isn't personal to me. I don't get hurt feelings.

I

am

indignant. You are disagreeing with me, this is reason enough for offense. Not only that, your logic for voting him is "you are willing to take a stand, put your vote where your mouth is, and put someone on l-1!"

L-1 votes haven't been a scumtell in non-lylo since forever. Taking a stand is pro-town. L-1 is not an issue unless one of you / mala / arc votes on it.

If mala does it, then she's playing against her win condition.

If arc does it, are you going to blame cats for the l-1 vote or arc for actually lynching?

If you do it, then you wanted the lynch anyway, so being mad at cats for putting his vote where his mouth is makes no sense.

[Smudger]

I disagree Ray, If Cats is scum then his vote post and it contents could be viewed in another way when you take it into context with the discussion beforehand and the reference made to it by Cats. By agreeing with me concerning my comment to AA on stalling the game while we "chew over our options", strikes me as suspicious. On the face of first read it seems a fairly innocuous statement, but I think you can maybe see what I mean when I say it could actually be geared to end the day quickly for other reasons. Thus my stubbornness in this regard. Had another player whom I am not suspicious of, made the same comment I would not have given it a second glance to be honest.

[Malakittens]

Smudger:

Walk me through why you keep changing your read on me.

[Smudger]

I have not changed my read it remains the same. But I find Cats post suspicious for the reasons stated.

[Nobody Special]

ArcAngel9 has been prodded.

[Nobody Special]

Hmmm. That seems to be AA9's fourth prod.

Searching for a replacement.

[Smudger]

I have read back through everything and thought it through and will say
that I intend to Hammer,

[RayFrost]

What made you come to that decision

[Malakittens]

My god.

I'm done with him flipping his reads every other day.

I had a town read on Rach, but Smudger you're not helping it at all.

Right now I think you are

okay

with any lynch, am I right?

[Smudger]

my reads do not flip every day and I certainly have not changed my mind in any regard. Yes I was torn between Cats and Mala, That is why I went away and re read the ISOs, this has in my mind confirmed my course of action. Mala what now only strengthens that is your response. Ray I will lynch Mala for the same reasons I first voted for Mala as they still apply,

Mala do you have anything to add before the hammer?

[Malakittens]

No, what I'm saying. You are susp of all three of us; cats, me and ray, but you don't really seem to care who gets lynched. Ray is sitting here Ate'ing yet you're totally eating it up. AA is barely even present and cats is doing the bare minimum and just putting a vote on me because there's no where else to put the vote atm. If he puts it somewhere else it might jepodarize a chance of winning.

Why can't you wait til AA's replacement comes in?

[Smudger]

I can wait although I don't see why, but just to highlight, did I say when I was going to hammer? The thing is your response now and earlier do not strike me as town tbh. Yes you Ray and Cats are on my sus list. Do you think it wise just to focus on one person? I think not. Of the 3 you are currently the scummiest and the next lynch. I am also bemused by your lack of defence or attempts to point out why such a person is more deserving of the lynch.

[ArcAngel9]

i cant post till monday..so lets move this game forward from monday

[RayFrost]

You're being replaced.

[Nobody Special]

Bitmap replaces ArcAngel9 effective immediately.

[Bitmap]

I'll read this soon.