Woah this thread really has exploded in the last 24 hours. I'll try and make this as summarized as possible (and likely fail):
1) I really like TvKs answer to my question in
Post 449, explains his earlier comment about everyone seeming town.
2) I'm not seeing peoples scum reads on Kid A's read on Street in
Post 453, the "want to vote before I forget" "will explain assuming I still like this vote" both read as genuine scumhunitng and while I disagree with his explanation (That's something I state as town, heck something I've stated this game I think and something I've seen them state before so it's not a scum tell in the slightest) in
Post 461 I can follow the train of thought.
3A) Don't like TSB's scum reads on Herself, SG and TvK in
Post 463, I'm fairly certain the first two are wrong and think the third is too, really the only things I agree with there are his town reads. The reasoning behind the scum read on Herself in
Post 503 dreadful, A) The entire "Distancing, interaction scum read" between them and SG is insanely weak and based on SG being scum which I alone think is wrong. B) The idea that "Only scum play the emotion card" is flat out wrong, AtE is actually something that is more player-style based than alignment-based. There are exceptions but generally it's not a solid tell and with Mollie I know for a fact that she's used AtE in the past as town so that's not a scum tell in the slightest. C) The idea of "X has all different reads to me therefore I think X is scum" is wrong, people read posts and situations differently, if anything scum are often the ones mimicking the general consensus reads and not branching out for their own ones but looking at this specific situation I had a town-read on Kid A and SG there as well, really the only read they had that was "weird" was TSO and apparently that was highly meta-based.
3B) The reasoning behind the scum read on SG in
Post 513 is even weaker in that A) It again relies on Herself being scum which I don't think is the case B) Constant vote-changing isn't a scum-tell, scum are generally afraid of moving their votes since they'll get called out for it and moving their votes turns players "against them" so they prevent doing it whenever possible C) The vote on Street read insanely genuine and was understandable in that she was suspicious of them refraining from outing content (The Banksy meta) which is town based paranoia and D) I had a scum read on Milked too and considered voting him as well, it's not just "lurking" it's his initial post coming across as creating a preemptive defence that has more scum motivation.
3C) I skimmed the rest of TSB vs Herselfs posts and I need to take a break and get back to studying for my last final soon so I'll have to call for a rain check and read his posts in more detail later*. Leaning towards him being scum though which is shitty since it would mean my Orestes read was wrong.
4) Oh god at Wake being here. At least the dumb Quad gimmick posts will stop. I do read his line of questioning towards ICE in
Post 473 and
Post 479 as townish though. As does the "interrogation" of SG in
Post 491 but I need to go back and re-read
Post 489 later because there's just so much in it to deal with right now but initial impression of it was that the entire summary and thoughts came across as very natural*.
5) SG, you're going to have to explain your town read on Fitz for me.
6) I don't like Milkeds
Post 530 at all, the entire "What's the case on Orestes and Fitz" bit while sticking them in "In between" reads as insanely scummy given that a great deal of the the entire threads conversation have revolved around the cases on those two. Don't like his read on me either, the "Scum-reads on lurkers vs Wanting lurkers to be replaced is contradictory" makes no sense whatsoever, especially if he's claiming to have read the thread, taken a break to think about it all and then got back to it; The reads on the lurkers are severely weaker than on active players, replacements allow more content, more content allows stronger reads. The scum read on Kid A also looks like a "Push the weaker player" one rather than a genuine scum read.
So a real summary since I failed at making the above short:
Town (S->W):
Street, ICE, Herself, SG, TvK, Wake88, LolWagons, Kid A.
Null/Need more reading into:
Garmr (Hoping his reads list is up soon), TSB (Want to go through his and Herselfs interaction later).
Scum (S->W):
HavingFitz, Milked.
I'd be fully up for either a Fitz or Milked lynch at the moment.
). 
