A uPick of Ice & Fire - Day 12 - #REKT?

[kanyeknowsbest]

wow gosh our doctor must be very good at this then to get so many successful shtos off. he must have a stack of confirmed town : )

[kanyeknowsbest]

wonder why he didnt protect agar tho. huh

[kanyeknowsbest]

She had the seal of approval as of my last disappearance; I will want to check again though.

Re - Benmage:
Benmage has a strong scumgame.
I see a lot of hard to fake posts but no hard evidence for Benmage town. His bestest towntells are missing.
Benmage-scum makes things make more sense to me.

Benmage, if you're town in this game then tell me why.

i dont hate this read btw

[Eddard Stark]

Day 7, Vc 11

Alfred Borden (2) -

Benmage, Shadoweh

elleheathen (1) -

Nautilius

Titus (1) -

kanyeknowsbest

The Alchemist (6) -

ooba, Cephrir, SafetyDance, Titus, Messiah Complex, elleheathen

Benmage (1) -

Alfred Borden

kanyeknowsbest (2) -

Tierce, Garruk Relentless

Not voting (2)

:The Alchemist, Tammy

With 15 alive it takes 8 votes to lynch

• Deadline Date: 5th of December 20:15 EST
  
• Deadline Countdown: (expired on 2013-12-08 19:30:00)
  
• Titus is V/la (or will be!)

[Nautilius]

N1: Tierce bulletproof? (I don't think this was the case)
N3: ???
N4: Titus
N5: ???

[Nautilius]

What I'm trying to figure out today is Llamarble for lynching?

And obv we have a protective role outside of SpyreX because of Quadz macho status.
I'm not sure I would have protected AGar because I didn't think he was likely to die and he seemed scummy. Dumb? Yes. But I could see someone else thinking the same way.

[Nautilius]

Llamarble, is Alchemist for lynching*

[kanyeknowsbest]

i think tierce eating the bullet n1 is a reasonable assumption.

and i think that when you then look at them killing mollie n2, a n3 doctor protection is very unlikely.

[Nautilius]

if tierce was shot N1, then Garruk isn't scum
in which case wtf is the scumteam

[Tammy]

I think that Nacho is writing off Titus as town too easily and I think that marble is writing off elleheathen as town too easily.

I also think that Marble is wrong about Benmage. Marble does Benmage!scum appeal to me over your vote on him? I'm not sure he does.

I'd also be surprised if Alchemist is group scum. Not sure why he didn't give out his coin; if he's scum he's third party, but that doesn't exactly feel right either. I still feel like if Alchemist was scum he'd kill me.

[Nautilius]

and i think that when you then look at them killing mollie n2, a n3 doctor protection is very unlikely.

Why? All shots won't be unlikely shots.

[Garruk Relentless]

if tierce was shot N1, then Garruk isn't scum
in which case wtf is the scumteam

Well I'm fucking not scum, Nacho, and I legit don't know how to prove this to you anymore than I have(well, no, I still have one trick).

[Tammy]

I mean unless we've got a roleblocker who's doing a bang up job. And our only outed roleblocker that is confirmed town is Agar.

[Garruk Relentless]

if tierce was shot N1, then Garruk isn't scum
in which case wtf is the scumteam

Well I'm fucking not scum, Nacho, and I legit don't know how to prove this to you anymore than I have(well, no, I still have one trick).

I've been dealing with this shit from day one and I'm at wit's end.

[Nautilius]

if tierce was shot N1, then Garruk isn't scum
in which case wtf is the scumteam

Well I'm fucking not scum, Nacho, and I legit don't know how to prove this to you anymore than I have(well, no, I still have one trick).

oh idk you could do something for once?

[Garruk Relentless]

Didn't SafetyDance roleblock quadz n3? Or do I still have the order messed up.

[Tammy]

I'm not going to fight Alchemist's lynch too hard because I feel like this is going to be an argument every single day, and I think if he cared about whether or not he got lynched he would come around some more, but I really don't expect him to flip scum.

He did promise me a Titus read though.

[Tammy]

SafetyDance roleblocked Nacho night two and tracked Quadz on night three.

[kanyeknowsbest]

Didn't SafetyDance roleblock quadz n3? Or do I still have the order messed up.

n2 he roleblocked nacho and n3 he tracked quadz

[Nautilius]

if tierce was shot N1, then Garruk isn't scum
in which case wtf is the scumteam

Well I'm fucking not scum, Nacho, and I legit don't know how to prove this to you anymore than I have(well, no, I still have one trick).

I've been dealing with this shit from day one and I'm at wit's end.

What have you done this game that is moderately town? Motivate Tierce?

[Alfred Borden]

P:edit wow

I want the Alchemist voters to talk more about his actions and what they think happened there.

Is the Alchemist scum who had an extra kill ability and decided to give it to town despite having a couple good targets?
In particular Tierce claimed to have Awesome Planz for the shot, so the notion that some kind of "none of our names are out there" logic was in effect is pretty eh.
Or you can take the Tierce / Alchemist put on a show angle, which would be better if Tierce weren't Certifiable Town.

Some kind of "I think this is what happened in scumland that led to the above" from Elle, SD, Ceph / the others would be good.

[Nautilius]

aka I see why kanye is bothered with me scumreading him because he has done plenty of things this game and has been my bro. but you, Garruk? do you really think that you've been doing things that should put you in the strong town pile?

[Nautilius]

Llamarble, who do you think the scumteam is?

[Tammy]

And I know roles before alignments but I'm having a problem with me, SD, Titus, and Elle all being town.

[Tammy]

oh and Agar.

Just feels wrong.