NY 167: COMPLETELY NORMAL Mafia (GAME OVER)

[MC Maraca]

Remember what mattp did in walking dead, tippy? We need to do that I think.

[MC Maraca]

I've already kinda crumbed at my target form last night and they've waved back. I won't explain it more than that but I'm pretty comfy with them.

[MC Maraca]

Townblock (mostly in order):

Angry Frat BROs
Cephrir
TheIrishPope
sangres
Toomai

Sort Pile:

yessiree
Hermy
JacobSavage
PeregrineV
RadiantCowbells
Guyett


This is kinda where I'm at right now, in light of recent events.

[MC Maraca]

Angry Frat BROs

- Town play, tippy's read is a factor here too. I've been scum with both heads of this hydra (New York 165) and lost to scum-Bro before (touhou mini theme), and this is totally not their scumplay at all. Additionally, AP (aka Arcanine/Arbok Master <3 ) was one of my mafia teachers of sorts; and he's gone back to the OLD town playbook from pokegym. Brings back memories.

Cephrir

- In light of some... "recent events", I think my ability to find cephrir as scum has improved, so I'm preeeeety confadent in my townread here.

TheIrishPope

- Take this one to the bank and cash it, folks.

sangres

- Taking back my promise to waffle. Her total lack of trying to shape my initial reads (like she did as scum in chef mafia) isn't there. Neither is the feigned paranoia angle.

Toomai

- Meta read. MOstly from simimlarity of his play here to the Harry Potter mini theme. I'd like him to elaborate on his tippy scumread, though, because I heavily disagree with it.

[Angry Frat BROs]

The protective role should claim.
1. If no protective role claims, we lynch Maraca.
2. If a protective role claims, we have two confirmed Town and scum have to decide who to kill.
a. If they try to kill Maraca, protective role has a chance to protect them, which WIFOMs the shit out of Mafia.
b. If they try to kill the protective role, Maraca gets another night.

Plus Maraca already knows who it is, so he can call out whoever fakeclaims.

No.

Round before LyLo is when the claim should happen.

[sangres]

Townblock (mostly in order):

Angry Frat BROs
Cephrir
TheIrishPope
sangres
Toomai

Sort Pile:

yessiree
Hermy
JacobSavage
PeregrineV
RadiantCowbells
Guyett


This is kinda where I'm at right now, in light of recent events.

Why is yessirree in your sort pile?

[TheIrishPope]

Oh ok well I got the plan thought out but the timing was off.
Umm.
So why is Hermy not dead yet?

[TheIrishPope]

Townblock (mostly in order):

Angry Frat BROs
Cephrir
TheIrishPope
sangres
Toomai

Sort Pile:

yessiree
Hermy
JacobSavage
PeregrineV
RadiantCowbells
Guyett


This is kinda where I'm at right now, in light of recent events.

Why is yessirree in your sort pile?

What are you implying?

[MC Maraca]

yessiree

- If I was putting another player into my town block, this would be it. He's showing some pretty good thought processes and logical openings.

Hermy

- I don't know what to make of her anymore. Part of me says she's lynchbait; but then I go back and look at her scumgames where she pulls and sometimes gets away with the same shit. http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=51&t=31923 http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=83&t=31754

JacobSavage

- even for a known lurker the utter lack of ~anything~ here is giving me PTSD from his SK play in 165.

PeregrineV

- I expect more from this slot. I will admit I'm bad at finding peregrine-scum (I meta-towned him incorrectly in paradox prime) I also want to know where he was going with the fake bulletproof thing.

RadiantCowbells

- I'm leaving this to my other townreads to sort because every time I read the stupid dripping from this slot, I want to just go fly to flordia and bribe GM for a vig shot.

Guyett

- Sangres has a major scumread here; I still have some questions asked here that went unanswered.

[MC Maraca]

Why is yessirree in your sort pile?

The rest of my townreads are stronger, and I put the divider there. As I noted, he's the one I'd bump up the quickest. I'd love some outside input, if you have something to add?

[sangres]

Townblock (mostly in order):

Angry Frat BROs
Cephrir
TheIrishPope
sangres
Toomai

Sort Pile:

yessiree
Hermy
JacobSavage
PeregrineV
RadiantCowbells
Guyett


This is kinda where I'm at right now, in light of recent events.

Why is yessirree in your sort pile?

What are you implying?

That I'm a little surprised he's not in the other pile.

Do you disagree?

[MC Maraca]

Ceph, where are your reads at? You indicated several townreads today, do you have anything to add or subtract from my list?

[sangres]

Why is yessirree in your sort pile?

The rest of my townreads are stronger, and I put the divider there. As I noted, he's the one I'd bump up the quickest. I'd love some outside input, if you have something to add?

It's my first game with him. I've thought that his game has a town-looking assertiveness and don't-care-what-you think feel that I also associate more with town than scum.

[MC Maraca]

I think that's part of my problem, and probably the main reason I'm not townbinning him. No scum meta to baseline him off of.

[TheIrishPope]

Yessiree has done nothing to make me think he's Town.

[sangres]

Yessiree has done nothing to make me think he's Town.

Has he done stuff to make you think he's scum?

[TheIrishPope]

No, which is why I asked you why he would be in a townlist.

[sangres]

I just scanned his ISO, but I'm going to have to reread the thread in detail to find some of the stuff I'm remembering. I remember him posting things that I thought "yeah I see why he thinks that", especially late day 1 and early day 2.

It's after 2 am for me. I'll have to wait until tomorrow to go back through that part of the thread.

[TheIrishPope]

Having the same thought process means you're the same alignment?

[MC Maraca]

HAY BITCHES

I agree with the town-list of my other half and would put Hermy and Yessiree there as well.

VOTE: Guyett

don't mind this, at all. I like this I think

[MC Maraca]

and RC is being RC

but then, it'll mean Pere/Guyett/Jacob left as the scum team and well...

[sangres]

Having the same thought process means you're the same alignment?

The stuff I'm thinking about was not stuff I agreed with. But, I could see how it could come from a town thought process.

[RadiantCowbells]

I've been scum with Broseidon and played scum against his town game.

This is him being scum, not town.

[Guyett]

I've been scum with Broseidon and played scum against his town game.

This is him being scum, not town.

RC I'm with you on AFB being scum, who else is there do you think?

[Toomai]

Toomai

- Meta read. MOstly from simimlarity of his play here to the Harry Potter mini theme. I'd like him to elaborate on his tippy scumread, though, because I heavily disagree with it.

The simple explanation for the disconnect is that you have him as town based on meta alone, whereas I have no meta knowledge and no real time to acquire some, so I see all his short posts and relative lack of intelligent insights and decide he's scum.

• 82: Junk list.
• 97: Needless buddying.
• 244: Way to filler.
• 1135: "Claim [at L-8]"
• 1365: Helps get the RC crazywagon going
• 1458: "Hammer without a claim"
• 1508 and so on: "Oh hey he claimed something large, better backtrack"
• 2298: "Hey let's out our protective role with 12 players to go"
• His avatar's Yoshi colour has changed from green to red. Q.E.D.