A uPick of Ice & Fire - Day 12 - #REKT?

[Magua]

Your opinions are bizarrely fully formed considering you just entered?

I am describing every single game I've ever been in in with Benmage to date. I have plenty of time to form this opinion.

By the way, how do you feel about your predecessor's claim of one-shot double watcher, modified tree stump?

My predecessor should consider cutting back on the mushrooms.

[Magua]

So, Benmage, which route are we going to take today?

1) "I'm a ninja tracker, and don't show up on tracker reports!"

-or-

2) "Lol guys Garruk is obv scum I was just trying to generate discussion!"

[Garruk Relentless]

We already have a claimed ninja, btw, Magua, in The Alchemist.

[Benmage]

Magua, Ceph did not track me last night.

That was an earlier night. I claimed I wasn't a standard tracker. That was his issue.

We can all go back to obvCAUGHTscumGarruk

[ooba]

That was anti-climatic

Vote: Garruk

[Cephrir]

No, you can tell us why you would claim simply "tracker" when you apparently didn't do anything for six nights

Incidentally, a claim that is very convenient seeing as you didn't know which night I tracked you

[Garruk Relentless]

That was anti-climatic

Vote: Garruk

Do you not find Benmage even in the slightest sketchy?

[Cephrir]

Your resistance to fullclaim pretty much guarantees that you're lying IMO.

Really ooba?

[Magua]

@Garruk:

Theories as to why that was the only kill N4 then?

@Benmage:

If it's all the same to you, I'd vastly prefer Cephrir confirm this because that's not my reading of 5474. PEdit: Oh, nevermind.

Kind of disappointed that Cephrir didn't claim he tracked Benmage last Night and try to push on him, though.

[Eddard Stark]

Day 8, Vc 9

Alfred Borden (1) -

Shadoweh

Garruk Relentless (4) -

Benmage, Titus, Messiah Complex, ooba

Benmage (2) -

Garruk Relentless, Cephrir

Cephrir (2) -

Tierce, The Alchemist

Not voting (4)

: Alfred Borden, Magua, Nautilius, SafetyDance

With 13 alive it takes 7 votes to lynch

• Deadline Date: 16th of December 20:35 EST
  
• Deadline Countdown: (expired on 2013-12-16 20:35:00)
  
• Titus is V/la

[Cephrir]

Good point, Magua. Wish I thought of that.

[Garruk Relentless]

@Garruk:

Theories as to why that was the only kill N4 then?

That night, specifically, Titus had a mass-redirect/roleblock thing that redirected every action in the game at her. Since our kill was a strongman, it ignored that. On the whole, though, we are missing a ton of kills.

[ooba]

That was anti-climatic

Vote: Garruk

Do you not find Benmage even in the slightest sketchy?

I do but the only scenario in which I see Benmage fake-claiming\lying is scum vs opposite scum.

Town's not going to pull that stunt so soon after yesterday.

I cant see the motivation for a lone scum team member going for a 1 vs 1 right now.

[Benmage]

Ceph I claimed this pretty quickly after my original statement...

Im not a standard tracker if it helps.

[Benmage]

My resistance to full claim is because it only benefits scum...

As there is no logical reason for this to be scumplay.

So there's no point in a full claim. Duh.

[Benmage]

And for Ceph/All

If i claimed I did no previous actions. He could have tracked me any night.

Everyone clearly has power. So again, the only continual logic would be me being scum holding onto my powers... Which seems to me atleast an odd strategy for scum.

[Benmage]

^Err.. whereas town reason for withholding is to increase success rate. obv.

[Shadoweh]

I've been trying to encourage Garruk to post song lyrics but so far he's been resistant, either he really thinks somehow he's not dying or he's not scum here. Or maybe he's retaining hope, like Benmage will go 'oh i was kidding, i did not in fact

poison

track you, you can go on playing like you matter today'

Since you asked so nicely I'm going to throw my hat on Alfred + ellemagua + dunno

[Magua]

Kindly explain how "refusal to post song lyrics" => "town"

Unrelatedly, assuming your list there is a scumlist, I note you have neither Benmage nor Garruk on it.

[Benmage]

Magua, for personal desire. Can you claim what Faraday shared with you inregards to your predecessor. If it helps, I've been reading your slot town for a while.

Also, you can hammer vote Garruk, as there's a mini-theory of mine that scum could gain something via hammers. *Beginning with SpryeX requesting hammers. Continued by other obvscum Alfred hammer twice including a quickhammer.

[Magua]

Magua, for personal desire. Can you claim what Faraday shared with you inregards to your predecessor. If it helps, I've been reading your slot town for a while.

See no benefit in doing this at this time.

Also: may vote Garruk. Not voting him now. I want way more people to tell me what I should be doing first.

[Benmage]

Magua, for personal desire. Can you claim what Faraday shared with you inregards to your predecessor. If it helps, I've been reading your slot town for a while.

See no benefit in doing this at this time.

Also: may vote Garruk. Not voting him now. I want way more people to tell me what I should be doing first.

Your predecessor full claimed in thread, hence my open request.

(incomingfun,staytuned)

[Benmage]

Benmage: Benmage, you're a scary genius.
Benmage: No Benmage, you're a scary genius.
Benmage: Yeah that is true.
Benmage: Mmmhmmm.

So time for our crazy firechat session with Benmage!

The topic: HAMMER CHARGERS

So as I previously theorized scum could gain something via hammers. Well what if that *gain* is a NK!
-We all have powers. So scum team is A) Decently sized. B) With power. So to balance... Faraday thought of a creative night kill mechanism????
-No kill N1, why? Cause PnJ hammered.
-Kill N2? YEP... why? Cause SpyreX hammered.
-D3.. Tierce hammer, no charge.
-D4.. Goat on a Raft, no charge.
-D5 Alfred hammer. Incoming charge theory, no kill.
-D6 Alfred (although still a wrong VC with Alfred missing at end)
-N6 Kill.. Yep charge used
-D7 Titus hammer, so town, no charge.. but scum still have a charge.
-N7 You know it. Charge used NK.

And that concludes todays fireside chat with me.

[Benmage]

^Magua this is why I want you to hammer.. even if its crazy.

Let someone like Alfred vote next.

[Garruk Relentless]

I've been trying to encourage Garruk to post song lyrics but so far he's been resistant, either he really thinks somehow he's not dying or he's not scum here. Or maybe he's retaining hope, like Benmage will go 'oh i was kidding, i did not in fact

poison

track you, you can go on playing like you matter today'