Mewbie 1442 the second -- Game over

[jmo16mla]

you promise youre not fake claiming just because you think buck is scum?

[Buckwild]

He's lying. Has to be. This is an interesting move, but don't buy it JM. Not sure why he would lie though. VOTE: AA

[jmo16mla]

why the vote on AA?

[Mindgamer]

you promise youre not fake claiming just because you think buck is scum?

Of course.
I was actually 50/50 between ArcAngel9 and Buckwild. I'm really glad Buckwild fell for it.

[Buckwild]

actually not sure. I thought that you had cleared Mind earlier. Did you not?

[Mindgamer]

I thought that you had cleared Mind earlier. Did you not?

Isn't this something you're supposed to check for yourself? Why do you trust Jmo so much?

[Malakittens]

3.03

With 5 alive it's 3 votes to lynch.

Voting for:

*Mindgamer -
*Brian Skies - Jmo16mla [1]
*jmo16mla - Brian Skies [1]
*ArcAngel9 - Buckwild [1]
*Buckwild - ArcAngel9, Mindgamer [2] [L-1]

Not voting: [0]

Day 3 ends in (expired on 2013-12-19 16:31:00)

[Buckwild]

VOTE: Mindgamer

[jmo16mla]

This is me not voting MG.

[jmo16mla]

VOTE: Mindgamer

why the change?

[Mindgamer]

Brian Skies has shown PLENTY activity on site today. Just not in this game. Meanwhile, 24 hours go by without a post from anyone. Jmo, what kind of 'discussion' are you waiting for exactly? I think I'm going back to this:

[jmo16mla]

You want me to hammer buck?

[jmo16mla]

Meaning, I'm giving you the chance to retract your claim because if buck is town because you lied, I won't be happy.

[Mindgamer]

Meaning, I'm giving you the chance to retract your claim because if buck is town because you lied, I won't be happy.

I retract. I'm actually Town F*cking Annoyed At Jmo.

Brian has been online all day but never hammered.
Buck is just random voting in his last few posts.
In what world is Buck town?

Seriously, what's the fixation with me playing against my win condition?

[jmo16mla]

VOTE: buckwild
Brian gets it tomorrow.

[Mindgamer]

Brian gets it tomorrow.

[Brian Skies]

- Jmo is very active and contributing well, Brian is nowhere to be seen.

I tend to be inactive at times. My activity level isn't alignment indicative. I have finals coming up. I'm also in multiple games, so I was catching up in other places so I don't fall behind.

I was also waiting for the massclaim to finish. But it appears AA is nowhere to be seen.

- I played with Jmo tracker before and he plays exactly the same here.

If he did it as town, then he can replicate it as scum, and he's doing it right here.

- Jmo was the first to claim a PR and his Tracker claim fits with my Bulletproof role.

He only needs one mislynch and he got lucky with his claim. The tracker is a very safe role to fakeclaim because the probability of there being a second power role is 5/6, and no matter which one exists in the game, he's safe.

Tell me why JK is the safer fakeclaim, because I'm not seeing it.

- Brian has odd choices for his Jailkeeps, especially Night 2.

I've already explained my choices. Take it or leave it.

- Jmo breadcrumbs in the exact same way he breadcrumbed Tracker in the game I played with him.

See above.


One thing you need to realize is that your logic was flawed and I let it slide because I wanted to see if Jmo's partner would slip and he did. The logic was in Jmo's favor and he let it slide because he's fucking scum and he needs the towncred to win this game.

If there's anything you want to discuss, let me know. Otherwise, if you're serious about your claim, we can just hammer Buck.

[Brian Skies]

He only needs one mislynch and he got lucky with his claim. The tracker is a very safe role to fakeclaim because the probability of there being a second power role is 4/6, and no matter which one exists in the game, he's safe.

Fixed.

[jmo16mla]

1. Why is it needed that AA claims? mindgamer is confirmed town so why exactly would it matter?

2. its extremely difficult to replicate town play as scum.

3. false. You claimed JK and gave terrible reasons for JKing me.

4. already left it.

5.Whos my partner? the odds arent in my favor.

Youre saying that day two i was setting myself up for todays claim by saying that buck didnt go anywhere? oh.

BTW, just to show that you arent reading, buck has been hammered.

[Malakittens]

3.04

With 5 alive it's 3 votes to lynch.

Voting for:

*Mindgamer - Buckwild [1]
*Brian Skies -
*jmo16mla - Brian Skies [1]
*ArcAngel9 -
*Buckwild - ArcAngel9, Mindgamer Jmo16mla [3] [LYNCH]

Not voting: [0]

Day 3 ends in (expired on 2013-12-19 16:31:00)

Buckwild was lynched. He was a

Mafia Goon.

night night guys.

(expired on 2013-12-11 01:09:00)

[Malakittens]

ArcAngel9 died. She was a Vanilla Townie

4.00

With 3 alive it's 2 votes to lynch.

Voting for:

*Mindgamer -
*Brian Skies -
*jmo16mla -

Not voting: [3] Brian Skies, Mindgamer, Jmo16mla

Day 4 ends in (expired on 2013-12-25 03:12:00)

[Mindgamer]

Buckwild flipping vanilla goon gives even more reason to believe Brian is scum. Let's look at this:

In Brian's scenario, we are in the Jailkeeper/BP/Roleblocker setup. Since scum have a Roleblocker, they know we're in either Jailkeeper/BP/Roleblocker or Cop/Doc/Roleblocker setup. After Night 2, four vanilla's died so scum knew out of the four townies still alive two were PR. At that point Jmo, presumably the roleblocker, fakeclaimed Tracker. He would get counterclaimed by either Jailkeeper or Cop. If it weren't for VT fakeclaim shenanigans, we would normally lynch between power roles. If Jmo were to lose at this PR vs fake PR exchange, scum would auto lose. Cop/Doc with two unclears is auto win for town and Jailkeeper with two unclears (and a clear BP) is autowin for town.
It would make sense for Buckwild to fakeclaim Tracker since his lynch would still give Jmo the ability to roleblock Jailkeeper/Cop. Then he could still try to get ArcAngel9 lynched. Jmo fakeclaiming instead of Buckwild lowers scum's win chances significantly. It doesn't make sense.

I am going to give you both a final stand before I decide on a hammer. I will warn though that Brian needs something amazing to change my mind.

[jmo16mla]

I wanted to get here first so that we could tie for the shortest day in a newbie:( now we can only get second.

VOTE: brian

he went to arc.

I just wanted to say though, I'm finding myself to be rather bad ass that I hit scum night one and night two.

I mean, I think I covered everything about Brian.

He didn't leave a bread crumb.

He had horrible reasons to JK me night one and night two.

This is why we win. I've been Brians prime suspect all game correct? He even jailed me night one and night two because I was

so suspicious

.. Well I would expect that he would have jailed me night three right? I mean, whats stopping someone from jailing their prime suspect on night three with one scum left? Correct. nothing.

The fact of the matter is, he isnt the Jk because he would have jailed me last night and we wouldn't have had a kill. Mindgamer is confirmed town, so obviously he didn't kill anyone. So who's left to submit the kill if I'm jailkept and mindgamer is confirmed? oh thats right. GG

[jmo16mla]

Disregard the big print.

*The Mafia Roleblocker is allowed to both submit the nightkill and perform his Roleblocker action. In addition, the Roleblocker is stated to resolve before the Jailkeeper.

This means that I

could

block him and make the kill.

[Mindgamer]

I don't care about a meaningless record like 'shortest day in a Newbie' and it's not going to make me hurry up. Don't expect this game to break any records.
Every single post of yours is making me think you're town which is exactly why I want to hear from Brian. I fear confirmation bias.