NY 167: COMPLETELY NORMAL Mafia (GAME OVER)

[Guyett]

lol good call XD

I'm pretty happy with my reads this game, especially come D3

[Toomai]

Wait what? The site goes down and by the time it's back up the scum have quit?

Spoiler: Reaction

I respect you for walking away from what you believe to be an unwinnable situation, but I still don't like it.

[RadiantCowbells]

Yoshi~!

[TheIrishPope]

Guys this is pretty disrespectful to GM.

[Guyett]

FTR I think scum could have continued and possibly won. Sure a few of us had the team pegged but a lot of others didn't.

[Cabd]

Guys this is pretty disrespectful to GM.

Not really. You really think we hadn't talked to her first?

[Cephrir]

I think he meant talking like the game is over when it's not officially over.

[Cabd]

Oh. Well yeah, players that are dead or not in the game need to STFU.

[goodmorning]

The scumteam has conceded the game. The Town has won.

Full setup can be found here.

[Cabd]

...Innocent child and a JOAT? Ok then...

[Toomai]

I'll be marking this down as a "no contest", not a win.

[Sakura Hana]

At least I felt like I was trying to find the scum team, but that does seem too OP for town... I'm going to honor the scumteam's resign and not mark this as a win but as a Draw.

[Cabd]

No, town won.

[Guyett]

Well this was a fun game anyway
Sorry for the shit D1 play and especially the thing with AFB
Fell sorry for the mafia team too
Thanks for modding GM

[Sakura Hana]

ftr by the end of D1 i was planning on gambit CCing orc, but decided to just suicide.

[Sakura Hana]

No, town won.

Even if you say that... it doesnt feel the same.

[Cabd]

If it makes you feel any better pretend you lynched sangres, ceph shot AFB, and then you lynched me the next day; because that's exactly what would have happened. For bonus points pretend Jacob cop guiltied me too.

[Cephrir]

My town wins are too sparse for me to pass them up

[Guyett]

My town wins are too sparse for me to pass them up

mine too lol

I had a good D3 with you

[Toomai]

I'm also disappointed that, not only did I not get the chance to activate the Innocent Child (first PR drawn as a player here), but I couldn't even get it set up by being suspicious enough to vote for because of all the other stuff flying around.

[fferyllt]

There was some really good town play in this game. I was super impressed with Yessirree, Ceph, Guyett, TiP and Toomai. Hermy also. Jacob lurked hardcore, and we thought we'd eventually be able to mislynch him, but probably not with the JOAT.

RC I was recently fake-guiltied by another player who wouldn't retract the gambit because he couldn't read my reaction as town. I was lynched. You happened to be right, but I have no respect for the way you handled the gambit. Recent experience makes me extremely skeptical of people who fake-claim guilties and don't treat it as a data acquisition exercise. Trying to strong-arm your read that way is risky as fuck. It lost town the game on day 4 when it happened to me. I don't think town was in a position to win that game, but it didn't have to be such a curbstomp.

[Cabd]

I'm also disappointed that, not only did I not get the chance to activate the Innocent Child (first PR drawn as a player here), but I couldn't even get it set up by being suspicious enough to vote for because of all the other stuff flying around.

You should pop it now!

[fferyllt]

And I already quoted that early day 1 post by MVP where he nailed the entire scum team.

[Sakura Hana]

Well at least im happy i found half the team by the end of D1.

[Cabd]

And I already quoted that early day 1 post by MVP where he nailed the entire scum team.

An interesting hydra, giffy-notsci-people