Mini 1531 ~ Mafia Pinnipedum (Game Over!)

[The Purple Plague]

Who are your scumreads?

This is probably going to be a PoE game for me. :/

I do like your PA case. Will put our vote there if Orcinus agrees.

What are your thoughts about Kanye?

So we have two imposing wagons one built up slow and incredibly hard to lynch, while the one fast but diffused just as fast as it built. This is interesting how the two contrast.

After taking a second look my town reads are pretty much split onto both wagons while my scum reads are focused on Penguin alien.

I'm going to retract my statement about PA being the preferred lynch because even through 543.

Also

VOTE: Smudge

that's l-1

This is what I have a problem with.

Peng wasn't a slow wagon. It built up incredibly fast.

I thought he was saying the Smudger wagon was slow and hard to lynch?

If its a Poe game, scum are people who don't make their way into your townreads.

Kanye is still town. Why?

[The Purple Plague]

nachio do you not think smudger is scum anymore? because the pa wagon seems to have had the opposite effect on you than it had on me

I'm not as sure he's as scum as I thought he was before, no. I might have another read flip in the near future, though. Why do you think smudge recent posts are scummy?

[The Purple Plague]

You're town, and you're bad

Really? I think I'm feeling the opposite actually.

You really do suck as town, Cabd.

You don't get to townbin me this quickly.

And yet somehow I did. I'm a loose cannon!

[The Purple Plague]

personally i was orig thinking they were both scum when i placed my vote, but the speed with which smudger followed onto the wagon leads me to think otherwise at this point. there does not appear to be the "should i bus to save my skin" delay that i was expecting.

I can agree with this. His hop on sucked pretty hard.

[The Purple Plague]

Re: Smudger being self conscious:
Why do you think he's putting on a show? You were also the scummiest on his wagon when it was formed, along with Kaze. I'm guessing that scum didn't get to L-1 without scum help, so.

[The Purple Plague]

Penguin reaction to wagon is still pretty good, I suppose. Eager in more shit being produced, although I wouldn't cry if Smudge was hammered after I touched bases with Selkies.

[Smudger]

......... yawn.......

[Smudger]

Purple if you and Selkies touch base anymore you will need to move in...

[kanyeknowsbest]

nachio do you not think smudger is scum anymore? because the pa wagon seems to have had the opposite effect on you than it had on me

I'm not as sure he's as scum as I thought he was before, no. I might have another read flip in the near future, though. Why do you think smudge recent posts are scummy?

his more recent posting seems more damning to me because he looks to me like scum desperate to get traction on anyone else besides himself. he cycles his votes through several people who "look" like good targets with very little actual substance.

[kanyeknowsbest]

nachio do you not think smudger is scum anymore? because the pa wagon seems to have had the opposite effect on you than it had on me

I'm not as sure he's as scum as I thought he was before, no. I might have another read flip in the near future, though. Why do you think smudge recent posts are scummy?

his more recent posting seems more damning to me because he looks to me like scum desperate to get traction on anyone else besides himself. he cycles his votes through several people who "look" like good targets with very little actual substance.

[kanyeknowsbest]

what about his recent posting makes you think hes less likely to be scum

[penguin_alien]

Re: Smudger being self conscious:
Why do you think he's putting on a show? You were also the scummiest on his wagon when it was formed, along with Kaze. I'm guessing that scum didn't get to L-1 without scum help, so.

I think it's a show because given that we have half the day left according to the battery and he was only the second wagon to get past the 'halfway to lynch' mark, him throwing in the towel isn't reasonable even if he's a VT as claimed. The self-conscious part is him not knowing how to react in order to derail the wagon, and there's a sense of him analyzing his own posts/soliciting feedback to figure out where he went wrong.

To clarify, you're saying that of those who have voted Smudger, Kaze and I are your top overall scum reads or your top reads for scummy jumps onto the wagon?

[Smudger]

or I might actually agree with the wagons,

but then my opinion is worth shit....

[Smudger]

Re: Smudger being self conscious:
Why do you think he's putting on a show? You were also the scummiest on his wagon when it was formed, along with Kaze. I'm guessing that scum didn't get to L-1 without scum help, so.

I think it's a show because given that we have half the day left according to the battery and he was only the second wagon to get past the 'halfway to lynch' mark, him throwing in the towel isn't reasonable even if he's a VT as claimed. The self-conscious part is him not knowing how to react in order to derail the wagon, and there's a sense of him analyzing his own posts/soliciting feedback to figure out where he went wrong.
quote]
this is purely subjective and based on nothing more than you second guessing me. As town, and having made pretty much a crap game play, do you not think I would also want to analyze where I went wrong and welcome feed back?

[Smudger]

damn it, broken tag

[Smudger]

PA is slowly but surely pushing my lynch, it makes sense to her as scum she needs to stay in the game I am resigned to being lynch in fact welcome it as, regardless what anyone may say it will help town as the game progresses. PA's post smack of self preservation and nothing more

[Smudger]

his more recent posting seems more damning to me because he looks to me like scum desperate to get traction on anyone else besides himself.

How so, I disagree, I have asked questions and challenged others. I accept I am going to get lynched. open your eyes.

[The Purple Plague]

Question to everyone, why have I not been hammered yet, and don't jump on me immediately, its a good question when you appreciate I am not going to self hammer as I am town, but then hindsight is only going to help you see that one

For one I liked this post. Its Smudger giving hints that he there's something to look back on his lynch in order to leg the scum, which is consistent with the whole "my lynch will help the town" mindset he had earlier.

He also has a townie dying defiance that I like the most and can't see many people faking as scum.

[The Purple Plague]

Purple if you and Selkies touch base anymore you will need to move in...

Fun fact: I am moved in with Selkies. Fferyllt is my mother and orcinus the original is my father. We're a he'll of a mafia family, right?

[The Purple Plague]

Re: Smudger being self conscious:
Why do you think he's putting on a show? You were also the scummiest on his wagon when it was formed, along with Kaze. I'm guessing that scum didn't get to L-1 without scum help, so.

I think it's a show because given that we have half the day left according to the battery and he was only the second wagon to get past the 'halfway to lynch' mark, him throwing in the towel isn't reasonable even if he's a VT as claimed. The self-conscious part is him not knowing how to react in order to derail the wagon, and there's a sense of him analyzing his own posts/soliciting feedback to figure out where he went wrong.

To clarify, you're saying that of those who have voted Smudger, Kaze and I are your top overall scum reads or your top reads for scummy jumps onto the wagon?

I think that giving up the towel ridiculously early is not a scumtell at all and am interested in hearing why you think otherwise. And him not knowing how to derail the wagon is different then what we are seeing now, which is part acceptance, part being absolutely defeated. He certainly isn't pulling the "oh why are you wagonning me??? People voting me are scummy!" response that most new scum produce. He's also been visibly upset by his play this game, and seems to be trying to salvage what he can for the town which is a pretty town attitude to take.

[The Purple Plague]

You and Kaze are the scummier people om the Smudge wagon, yeah.

[kanyeknowsbest]

Question to everyone, why have I not been hammered yet, and don't jump on me immediately, its a good question when you appreciate I am not going to self hammer as I am town, but then hindsight is only going to help you see that one

For one I liked this post. Its Smudger giving hints that he there's something to look back on his lynch in order to leg the scum, which is consistent with the whole "my lynch will help the town" mindset he had earlier.

He also has a townie dying defiance that I like the most and can't see many people faking as scum.

yeah i saw that stuff too, and i contemplated that take on it but his grasping at any straw is at odds with his "im town and i accept that im dying" angle. its that sort of gap between a presented image and actual intent that usually locks me deeply into a scumread.

[Garmr]

Purple if you and Selkies touch base anymore you will need to move in...

Fun fact: I am moved in with Selkies. Fferyllt is my mother and orcinus the original is my father. We're a he'll of a mafia family, right?

Hits my head against the wall. I have a sick sick mind.

Anyway change of subject since you are family, how well do you think you can read fferyllt?

[Garmr]

^
Probably a weird question to ask at this stage of the game But I'm kinda gathering data for future games as well.
I have a drive to beat the people who I respect on mafia scum. Strikes mean I have beat them.

Desp(Though he can be a bit grr I still respect him)
Fferyllt

Slaandar

ABR

SpyreX
Brian Skies

The list is still growing.

What is a worthwhile question Is the one I asked Cabd Because to me It could change my views on him.

[Smudger]

Purple if you and Selkies touch base anymore you will need to move in...

Fun fact: I am moved in with Selkies. Fferyllt is my mother and orcinus the original is my father. We're a he'll of a mafia family, right?

nice, how do you hide the fact you are scum?