Mini 1525: Tales of The Abyss Mafia GAME OVER!

[Nachomamma8]

see like every post this guy makes is town as fuck

[Nachomamma8]

fuzzy, what are your top three reads right now?

[The Rufflig]

Correct. It is the same pairing that I had yesterday, too. Nothing has changed since yesterday except that 1 of the players that must be scum flipped scum and one of the players that had to be town was night killed. Today is nothing more than a continuation of yesterday. Day 2 pretty much nailed it all down to this.

[ProHawk]

Just don't do anything stupid. We are pretty much in LYLO and things are a little less clear than they were yesterday.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

The above questions was aimed at Pro

I am sure Ruff is scum....after that I am not sure.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

I was thinking Pro was town which meant Mac was prob scum but I am not sure anymore

[ProHawk]

Nacho, the reason I had to re-eval my read on Ruff was because he was closing his options on me last game day whereas Fuzzy is leaving them open ^

[Nachomamma8]

Correct. It is the same pairing that I had yesterday, too. Nothing has changed since yesterday except that 1 of the players that must be scum flipped scum and one of the players that had to be town was night killed. Today is nothing more than a continuation of yesterday. Day 2 pretty much nailed it all down to this.

No reaction to Fuzzy voting you?

[Nachomamma8]

I was thinking Pro was town which meant Mac was prob scum but I am not sure anymore

Mac is still scum.

[Nachomamma8]

Nacho, the reason I had to re-eval my read on Ruff was because he was closing his options on me last game day whereas Fuzzy is leaving them open ^

I would be fairly suspicious of Fuzzy if Fuzzy chose a strong team and nailed them down completely. A large part of his play was the sort of unconditional trust in the neighborhood, in the sole "yeah I doubt there is scum here". Mac and I were strong townreads for him for a very long time. I would expect him to have a slow adjustment period, and I wouldn't expect him to see the you-towniness so quickly because it is for reasons I don't think he would be as likely to pick up on as others.

[ProHawk]

I was also right about NO Hana being scum though I second guessed myself.

No. This is the only post that was even remotely close to you saying NO Hana was scum. Also, you NEVER voted them the entire game.

Town

Nacho
Mac
Kaze
Orcinus
--------------------------
Myko
Proawk

The reaction to the lynch and than the flip itself really makes me think that these two are town
-------------------------------------
Tammy
Pit

Ruff
No Hana

I am not going to sit back and say this was a good lynch but i feel there was good info that came out of it

Everything else was speculation and what-if's...

I dont think that both Ruff and No Hana are scum.

Two scum claiming an investigator role would be ridiculously dumb. If I had to speculate .. I would say that either one is scum and the other is town or both are town. I would gues the former than the latter.

Hmm if there were only two Scum than thats would be a good reason we would not be a LYLO....

The question is if No Hana is making fake claims and would a scum No Hana buss a scum Ruff

If No Hana is not fake claiming that means you and Ruff are the likely scum.

Thats the question...is No Hana fake claiming
I would like to use all five days and get a good lynch....No need to rush lynch....

@ PR0
There is always a slight possibility that scum Hana would town read scum Ruff.

Not saying that is what happening

but it is possible

lets ay there is sum in the neighborhood...who do you think it is....

No Hana- Not sure what to make of her claims. With the mod confirmed claims we have had it is possible that her statement is true. I am tempted to leave her for the day and try to find the other scum.

Okay

ProHawk
No Hana
Ruff

Mac
Nacho

two or three of these folks are scum.

I was under the impression you did not and we talked in the QT about pressuring you to give you more info on your role.... I can see your point about the lynch. Still dont you think if No Hana is a JOAT/ Cop/ JK that this could be a problem for the scum?

This is a reason why I think NO Hana could be fake claiming.... I am not sure though

Okay

Fuzzy- Town
Kaze- Town

Nacho- most likely town
Mac- Prob town but not sure

Ruff- no clue

No Hana- unsure

Pro Hawk- Not sure

wishing that NO Hana was here to explain.

@ Kaze
do you think that we could have two type of scum.

Mybe a Godfather or scum that might not read as Not God General if No Hana is telling the truth

, Also how likely do you think this is possible,

What do you think of a Ruff lynch??

or do you think we should keep going on the No- Hana wagon

NO HANA WHERE YOU

To me, Hana's absence in the face of imminent lynch would support the fact that they were scum. But to Fuzzy, they BEG Hana to get in here instead of coming to the logical conclusion. I get the feeling from Fuzzy's posts that they are light-defending Hana in this situation.

[ProHawk]

All i know there are 9 townies ..... 2 are absolutely cobfirmed as town. Kaze ( by Mod confirmed) and me by ( PM confirmed) That means that atleast 2 maybe 3 are lying there butts off. )

Scum you better NK kill me bc if you dont I promise that I will hunt you down and throw your sorry selves into the abyss......

This reads

extremely

fake to me.

[ProHawk]

Can you tell what significance the title given to you by Tammy has to your name and or PR ( if any) Thanks

This came well after....

According to what i read of the game mythos

Anise's Belove would be Ion

. This would make him town or maybe third party.

This clears Prohawk as being scum

and

It's his relationship with Mafia's character.

So... why would Fuzzy ask me a question he already knew the answer to? Not to mention is beginning to waffle on me despite having pretty strong conviction that my title and name essentially clear me from being scum.

[ProHawk]

Nacho, did Fuzzy say anywhere in your QT that they thought Minami was scum?

[ProHawk]

Third point, Fuzzy's experience here is pretty limited game-wise and yet he beats this drum that more than one scum in a neighborhood is taboo/couldn't possibly exist.

Why couldn't it? The definition of a neighborhood is alignment hidden, so by definition there could be any number of combinations scum-town.

[Yulia Jue]

Votecount 4-1

With 5 players alive, it takes 3 votes to lynch.

The Rufflig (1): TheFuzzylogic99 (L-2)

Not Voting (4): Mac, Nahcomamma8, The Rufflig,, Prohawk


(expired on 2014-01-09 13:05:00)

[The Rufflig]

No reaction to Fuzzy voting you?

Nope. Fuzzy's vote for me doesn't scare me. Watch this:

VOTE: TheFuzzylogic99

Neither of these votes means much, though.

[Mac]

No, but I'm not lynching Minami immediately.

Ok Nacho, what exactly do you need to sort out?

For one: Fuzzy is bleeding bleeding bleeding town.
Mac is not bleeding bleeding bleeding town.

You are bleeding bleeding bleeding town.
Rufflig is not bleeding bleeding bleeding town.

Could it really be that simple?

well first thing is that this has been my most town game i've had in a while, the last day aside where I lost track of myself on here due to real life taking over a bit.

(cop claim from scum in particular).

explain this?

I think I would like to lynch Mac today.

if you could explain this, this would be good.

my lynchpool today is Ruff or Fuzzy. I think those are the last two scum, in fact. ProHawk I think has been pretty fucking town the entire game since he was wagoned early doors, and the only way I could see Nacho scum,since he's been cleared(?) which would be godfather I think - but then the miller claim makes no sense unless he's trying to through a red herring or something. Either way, Nacho likely town but needs to open his eyes.

Plus I don't see your trajectory on how your read on me when from "playing a stellar game as scum" to "scum full stop." You said it was in thread but I don't see it so some clearing up is needed.

Edit--
I really believe she would town read him

@ Pro
if you give me a good reason I go along with a Mac Vote

If you think there's 1 scum in our hood then why on earth do you need a reason to vote me?

But I think I see your point on Mac and will most likely vote him unless his next post is incredibly town.

Oh dear.

Alot of fuzzy's posting in thread and QT is what I think cautious-scum and not "town as fuck" as Nacho is portaying. alot of his posts of confidence in the scum end with "yeah I could be wrong though" and he gives himself alot of ways out of opinions he makes. I'd probably vote him as my top read today, but since we're probably in LyLo I'm going to hold it back for now until we have some more conversation.

[ProHawk]

Mac, this is why we lynch you: Today is most assuredly LYLO.

You made it a Fuzzy/Rufflig lynch.
Fuzzy made it a Fuzzy/Rufflig lynch.
Rufflig made it a Fuzzy/Rufflig lynch.

I don't think Fuzzy and Rufflig are scum-partners. That only leaves you. Safe scum-lynch is Mac.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

LOL @ The Ruff OMGUS vote.... you just made me think that are even more scum than I did before The whole apathy and OMGUS play doesn't seem very townie to me

Pro Hawk

True, I dont know alot about this site....it just dont seem very likely that there are two scum in the neighborhood. Plus the theme makes me believe that there at least one other neighbor along side me....
Can you give me a reason to vote Mac.... #2093 doest seem to be a very strong reason IMHO

[ProHawk]

YOU GAVE YOURSELF A FREAKING REASON.

In what world makes it very unlikely?

[TheFuzzylogic99]

ok....here is why not
nacho/ mac team =you said it yourself nacho is town
fuzzy/mac= I am town!!!! this is an impossibility. You also said that this team lineup was unlikely
nacho/ fuzzy= we are both town

Therefore it is very unlikely , I would say unlikely that there are two scum in the neighborhood

the only reason I have to consider Mac is prob is scum is bc is your title claim

so there

the safest lynch in my opinion is Ruff.... I believe he is scum.

[ProHawk]

Let me walk this through with you.

How many scum are left?

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Unless there is some weird set up there are two scum left. For argument shake lets say two since three is the norm for a thirteen and the town caught one

[Cabd]

Bump