Mini 1537: ATTACK ON TITAN (Game Over!)

[BROseidon]

BS's wall looks town.

Hey muffin, can you hold off on posting till I get through with my spam? Or I can wait for you to get down if you'd like.

The intermingled convoing reads weird.

[zMuffinMan]

no

[Kazekirimaru]

so I'm confbiasing bc he's town ok. what makes my case on him wrong? as it is you're not giving me anything besides "he's town", making this logic circular.

feel free to knock my case on him down if you want but just saying "he's town" isn't gonna cut it

Like I sad before, reading your correspondence with him reminds me of our arguments in Ace Attorney.

Speaking of which, you should really try to cut back on this habit.

[zMuffinMan]

actually yeah i can. i have other games to post in. but since you said that, no

[BROseidon]

Yes, I've noticed. In fact, I would even call your assholishness a probable town-tell by comparison with sabo mafia.

Which in turn should negate your assertion that I wouldn't be so brazen towards the mod...

pedit: Boo you whore >:C

[BROseidon]

Looks like human-titan shifters have a specific implementation in this setup, and it looks to me like Eren lacks that for some reason. This is a good part speculation, but it meshes with muffin's idea, so I'm trying to think about what muffin must know in the hopes that I can clear him in my mind.

...Something different in the source material, I take it?

[pieguyn]

Like I sad before, reading your correspondence with him reminds me of our arguments in Ace Attorney.

Speaking of which, you should really try to cut back on this habit.

care to explain how?

also why are you townreading him? the only explanation you gave was early game which I argued and then you thought we're both town bc it feels like AA:MFA. why do you think it'd be different if BRO is scum?

also why should I cut back on a habit when I was 3 for 3 on my scumreads that game and the 4th scum was someone who I was scumreading before Nat townread him?

[Kazekirimaru]

care to explain how?

also why are you townreading him? the only explanation you gave was early game which I argued and then you thought we're both town bc it feels like AA:MFA. why do you think it'd be different if BRO is scum?

also why should I cut back on a habit when I was 3 for 3 on my scumreads that game and the 4th scum was someone who I was scumreading before Nat townread him?

Shall I direct you to pretty much every one of your posts where you hit the caps lock button?

I'm townreading him because I am. It's good feelings. :3

Because habits can lead to bad situations. Like this one, where 2/3 of your scumreads are townies.

[zMuffinMan]

remind me what your reads are, kaze

i want a good laugh

[Kazekirimaru]

remind me what your reads are, kaze

i want a good laugh

then you should look in the mirror

Kay then. Only because I love you so very much.

Brian Skies - null
ActionDan - null
Kazekirimaru - scrub
Bert - lurker
BROseidon - town
Plum - town
Kagami - leans town
Pieguyn - town
Paschendale - scum
F-16_Fighting_Falcon - leans scum
Tammy - town
zMuffinMan - scum
mykonian - null

[zMuffinMan]

and i'm scum because paschendale is scum? or independently of that read?

[Kazekirimaru]

Independently.

[zMuffinMan]

y

[Kazekirimaru]

the odds are ever in my favour.

[zMuffinMan]

good luck ever getting me lynched this game, i wish you the best of luck

truly

there's nothing i want more this game than seeing you try to lynch me

but i don't think you have the balls to even try

[Kazekirimaru]

Oh, dear. I've been challenged.

What am I to do, now that my pride is on the line? Such agony! I should just vote you right here in a blind rage and scream at you in caps!

Right? Nah. Just sit tight. I'll get to you soon enough.

[pieguyn]

I'm townreading him because I am. It's good feelings. :3

why are you having good feelings about him?

also

Pretty sure both Pieguy and Bro are town because their argument sounds a lot like the argument Pie had with me in Ace Attorney mafia when we were both town.

why do you think the argument would sound different if BRO is scum?

[pieguyn]

hey zmuffin what's giving you reservations about BRO-scum

[zMuffinMan]

stuff

there are certain things i look for in scum-bro and town-bro and i'm seeing more things i expect from town-bro than scum-bro

i don't have any intention of delving any further into this at the moment, partially because i'm not all that confident about it and partially because i don't see a point

[zMuffinMan]

If Pasch is scum, Pasch/Pie/Muffin team makes sense

Muffin is a bit weaker, but he doesn't make sense as scum except for his hard-defense of Pasch

actually i don't like this, because if he thinks paschendale is scum, he should basically think i'm more conftown than an IC for this

but whatever

[Paschendale]

@Pasch:

Agree with Kaze's notions on Pie and F-16 in post 48. Pie's tone worries me, too.

Looks like a lot more assurance than is really warranted.

can you explain what was with your initial scumread on me and F-16? you were agreeing with Kaze who didn't explain either of them. also, what does bolded mean?

also, can you walk me through your read on BRO in more detail? I get your initial scumread of him but then around 500 it feels like you were starting to have reservations based on your questioning and responses to him. can you explain how your read on him changed over time plz?

Your early posts came off like you were stating a lot of thing unequivocally. That is, invoking knowledge you didn't actually have. False bravado or even unfounded confidence tends to worry me, since I think town should always keep in mind that we can be wrong. That kind of language, to me, looks like a false push rather than a reasoned argument. But you haven't been doing that as much, so I haven't continued it. As you obtain more information, your tone seems to become more reasoned. Though a lot of it has just been your argument with Bro that I haven't had a super strong read on, at least not compared to Kagami and Plum. And that's a topic on which I know you share some of my suspicions.

As for Bro, he does look to be scumhunting. He's not just setting his sights on one or two targets, but is analyzing quite a few people. Early on, it looked like he panicked for a while and just went super defensive, but he's moved past that. I see town motivated analysis. I don't necessarily think he's right on all of his reads, like the strength of his scumread on you or his townread on Plum, but it doesn't look like lies to me. From either of you.

I think you two should stop fighting with each other and help me lynch Kagami. Or Kaze or Plum. But mostly Kagami.

[Kagami]

Muffin, does your read on pasch stand up to the possibility that the scumteam might be incentivized to lynch me?

[zMuffinMan]

sure

[Paschendale]

Muffin, does your read on pasch stand up to the possibility that the scumteam might be incentivized to lynch me?

You mean that your partners might bus you.

[zMuffinMan]

i'm going to take a wild stab in the dark and say that's not what he meant