Mini 1537: ATTACK ON TITAN (Game Over!)

[Tammy]

AND I'VE ALREADY SAID YOU'RE THE PLAYER I WAS TRYING TO NOT MAKE SCUM BUT MAKES MORE SENSE AT SCUM.

LIKE FFS, READ MY GD POSTS, BEFORE POSTING SELF-HELP DRIVEL.

[Tammy]

can we just lynch someone and go to night, all this stalling and nonsense posting and ego posting is doing shit for the game. hell fucking lynch me if it gets a lynch to happen sometime this century and everyone's too scared to lynch someone who actually looks scummy.

[zMuffinMan]

Spoiler:

00:34 for one that most people playing this should recognise

THEN WHO IS SCUM MUFFIN?

because pasch, mastin and kthnx is the best i've got

mastin probably is, kthx and pasch probably aren't. still think plum is likely scum, dunno about brian, kaze also likely scum

when I do that, people call me stupid and inflexible.

there's nothing wrong with being stupid and inflexible

[Plum]

Apologies for needing to be prodded.

We lynch Pasche, even though, yes, kthxbye kinda sucks.

[pieguyn]

kaze also likely scum

explain

[zMuffinMan]

well, what happens in mafia games is some people get town role PMs and some people get non-town role PMs. i think it's likely kaze is part of the latter group, so i said that

[pieguyn]

anything specific as to why you think that?

[zMuffinMan]

yeah i don't like him

i don't like scum

put two and two together

BAM

[zMuffinMan]

also nothing he's saying looks town, there's that too, i guess

but more important is the reasoning in 857

[Kazekirimaru]

You don't like me? ._. Way to hurt my feelings, man.

Anyway, I've been ready for this Day to end for like four IRL days now or something.

[Kagami]

My lynchpool is pasch, kthx, and maybe mastin as a distant third.

[Kazekirimaru]

Switch out mastin with muffin and we can be bffs

[Bert]

Mastin's 848 is pointless drivel

[BROseidon]

Slight warning--I'm keeping up with the new content, but because my internet was knocked out for 24 hours, I'm playing catch-up across the site as a whole, meaning reading the game from the start is going to be delayed a bit.

This doesn't even make sense mastin and looks like you just talking to talk. Let's take a look at my whole post, shall we?

Now, read my post again. And rethink your questions.

I did read the post, Tammy. But bluntly. If you're town.

You have a problem.

So fuck calling me scum. FIX THE GODDAMNED PROBLEM. You don't have a handle on who the scum are. You

should

. So I ask again. Who's scum when I'm revealed town, Tammy? You don't have an answer. I know what. That's why I asked. Because you need one. Who are the players you shouldn't be townreading? Who are the players you're making not scum when they shouldn't be? Tell me now. Rather than others on day two.

But I'd like Mastin to talk to me about it. Because although I can see town motivation in what Pasch is saying, I think his "scum role-fishing" theory is a little far-fetched and I'm wondering why he went there instead of just occam's razor. Have any of you played with Pasch before? Does he do stuff like this as town?

Pretty sure he does. Maybe even moreso as town than as scum. Would have to double-check my games with him to be sure.

I don't know. Maybe kthnx, pasch, mastin.

Then help me bus my buddy.

VOTE: kthnxbye.
Don't remember who he replaced, but his posting's been awful.

Okay, here's what I'm seeing with mastin:

Arguments for scum-mastin:

1) He replaced F-16

2) From my experience with him in Anything Goes, I knows he likes to hide a bit more as scum. He's not been super-active here.

Arguments for town-mastin:

1) Posts like this one read town to me. Content wise it's okay, but what I'm honing in on is the writing style. It reads in line with how I'd expect town-mastin.

UNVOTE: mastin

More generally:

There's probably scum between {pasch, mastin} but I'm having a hard time working out which one. Myko's postings weren't super town, and kthx's posts have been blegh. Kagami also still reads super scummy to me, as does pie, but apparently I'm crazy for thinking that or some shit (sort of like how I was crazy for thinking mastin/katsuki were scum in Anything Goes OH WAIT A MINUTE I WAS FUCKING RIGHT).

Also Bert's burning through the town-equity he got from the miller claim; his behavior this game is in-line with how he was in my open where he was scum (disengaged, disinterested, coasty after getting early town reads). Still wouldn't lynch today, but it's worth noting.

Switch out mastin with muffin and we can be bffs

No.

Muffin, I don't see Kaze-scum or Plum-scum over any of my scumreads, and you're not gonna convince anyone if that's how you explain shit. Read my every post to Venmar in Xenogears to prevent me from yelling the same shit again.

[ActionDan]

putting faith in writing style over content this late in the day is a fallacy. One of these days the world will know this slot to be scum. that day could have been today, but the chance of that is lessening. Also Myko's slot was town.

[BROseidon]

putting faith in writing style over content this late in the day is a fallacy. One of these days the world will know this slot to be scum. that day could have been today, but the chance of that is lessening. Also Myko's slot was town.

"Don't use one of your main scum hunting tools"

How about, uh...

No.

[ActionDan]

well when mastin flips scum you'll learn how worthless that particular tool is.

[ActionDan]

it has a time and place actually. but neither is here nor now.

[BROseidon]

How do you feel about pasch, kthx, kagami, and pie?

[ActionDan]

don't know (not opposed to lynch), town, town, .... lean town? (at least probably better options [like pasche])

[Kthxbye]

So, do I need to spell it out for those not seeing it or ... ?

I'm thinking from the responses thus far AD, zMM, and Brian are town.

[BROseidon]

So, do I need to spell it out for those not seeing it or ... ?

Yes

[ActionDan]

I don't trust zMM too much. tbfrank.

[Bert]

RIP F-16-sama

inb4 I was right on my scumteam guess and that's why F-16 rep- ok I'll stop now \:D/

This emotion isn't as sincere sounding as I'd like.

If all three wagons suck, I need a new one on actual scum. Thus, Plum.

Why Plummy?

i dunno what you're hoping to achieve with the plum vote here. i don't think plum is town, but

i don't really see plum getting lynched today

Plum lynchwagon party pooper!

Hey guess what guys I'm actually skimming the game for real. I am like...DUDE I showed up 10 days in. *squirm*

no one will ever convince in 1 million years that either bert or Kagami are scum this game.

someone's overconfident

[Bert]

But sometimes there's something sinister in it.

Right, what was this sinister thing in it, exactly?

Bro - what do you think of mastin's entrance?

It's one of those entrances which you either love or want to list on the market. Didn't love it, I don't buy it.

My character is Reiner Braun. Having only watched the anime, I had assumed I was a weak human because reiner is a lame side-character, and my flavor says I'm super sad because of my first mission.

Turns out that I'm a titan-shifter like Annie. Reiner is the armored titan who breaks wall maria near the beginning of the series. As such, it's reasonable to assume the weak modifier belongs to shifters.

You sound so knowledgeable. I'm guessing you've played/seen Attack on Titan...weird.

I refuse to believe that there isn't

something

to be found within this setup. I just need to figure it out. I don't care how much I get yelled at for thinking so. >.>

And you didn't do this on D1 in AA, why? This kinda figuring out, ya know. I smell FISH!