The Fall of Gondolin Mafia: Game Over (The Tale of Gondolin)

[MafiaSSK]

THIS IS GAWLD

EVERYONE JOIN ME ILL EXPLAIN LATERZ

VOTE: Natirasha

I think I actually have to sort of agree with shos here. Nat feels off.

[sirdanilot]

Yes I am from the old days too. I still only play in a small amount of games at a time.

Good I like your reads.

What are everyone's shos, shadoweh and especially Esp reads? And does anyone else feel like Esp should die?

Shos is eh.
Shadoweh is town.
Esp, I think I could actually get behind as scum.

Reck is fine, btw. UNVOTE:

How do you read shadoweh town? Though he is number three out of my scumreads, and obviously mot of the game I haven't had any meaningful interaction with yet.

THANK you for seeing the err of Esp's ways

[sirdanilot]

THIS IS GAWLD

EVERYONE JOIN ME ILL EXPLAIN LATERZ

VOTE: Natirasha

I think I actually have to sort of agree with shos here. Nat feels off.

My reference point of nat is that he claims miller first thing page 1 and is scum, and he did not do that now so I don't share your read just yet. But we'll see.

[MafiaSSK]

Yes I am from the old days too. I still only play in a small amount of games at a time.

Good I like your reads.

What are everyone's shos, shadoweh and especially Esp reads? And does anyone else feel like Esp should die?

Shos is eh.
Shadoweh is town.
Esp, I think I could actually get behind as scum.

Reck is fine, btw. UNVOTE:

How do you read shadoweh town? Though he is number three out of my scumreads, and obviously mot of the game I haven't had any meaningful interaction with yet.

THANK you for seeing the err of Esp's ways

Shadoweh read mostly comes from upick of ice and fire, where I feel like she acted similarly.

[shos]

Hey SSK, whats your role claim?

rolefishing. exhibit A.

VOTE: xRECKONERx

I will be starting the Silmarillion on the plane tomorrow.

I started it last week again

*snip of useless fluff*
You're throwing a fuss *more snip*

This is true, but this is very characteristic for reck, and regardless Reck is conftown to me so nobody vote him please. let's just say that if I were a doc I'd doc him regardless of what happens today

I actually like this wagon.

Odd.

Reck had 4 votes by the votecount, then me and MSSK joined, then natirasha says this and doesn't add a vote. exhibit B.

Sure we can talk.

In a time long ago, before I took my long break, I got ripped up after a game because I "let the scum win".

Because the scum opted

to play the game

instead of being a pile of lurkaderps. I said it right then, that I would rather lose to someone playing the drag them to victory.

AND SO IT HAPPENED *gasp*

Esp is playin (don't take an affront there) but I literally have no faith in a town that will not purge that with fire. Immediately.

So, bet your ass I'll comment on other things, but if it makes you feel better I'm now a tree stump and he's hated.

And yes, I'm making it very, VERY clear I dont even necessarily think scum there - there'd be actual thought and process behind that claim as scum at this juncture and it SHOULD require mad huevos because it SHOULD be lynched.

But, it doesn't change a thing.

This post is hoooorribleeee horrible, and if you're going to play like it, please replace out asap

CES, any reason you posted the way you did in this post?

Reck is obvtown what are you all doin?!?!

I can only assume you're lovers because that's the only way I can understand this comment.

Moar rolefishing~! for the second time now. ^^^that guy be scum lads, all aboard the wagonasha!!!

VOTE: Natirasha


@Sirdanilit 55 - if you realy think that claim is true then lol @you mun

Reck is obvtown what are you all doin?!?!

Will you join me in my noble quest to lynch Espeonage?

VOTE: xReckonerx

Oh just spotted this. I can guess your answer: 'No because I'm his scumbuddy, shhh !'

and finally someone spotted this. it was a teeny reaction test as it was and it managed to get at least one fish - I called him town and voted him, and for that I and him are both scum, yes? kewlz.
^^^that guy is probscum as well - helps a policy wagon based on bullshit-who-publicly-admits-he-doesn't-even-think-target-is-scum, and this.

also ISO natirasha her posts are terribad indeed even for RVS

*sigh* how comes sirdanilot is a 2006 player who doesn't have the ability to think? he prematurely assumes that the claim is real, he actually suspects me for the random posts I've been posting in tehf rsit two pages, what the fuck is this serious

well that's pretty funny my wagon is taking steam may as well just join it

@post 88 by des, my post 87, despite being all caps and 'GAWLD', was the first actual post I made. I have not yet read the game(except the VC) until then, lol, and that post came by because natirasha fell in the pit I set up for her, and managed to rolefish, which now when I read the game from the start was already the SECOND time she did that.
either way I was on my phone up until now so that's how it happens

@PLUM

, Is the votecount in 89 correct? there are 2 'shos' wagons in it, is this how it is supposed to be? :O

Nope, I'm a derp, thanks for pointing it out. Fixed

lol@sirdan I no 5p33|< 1337 14w1

I think that your (sirdan) post 90 is way too forced. in general, all your posting so quickly in the game looks terribly fake, like you're trying to look like you're a hardcore scumhunter by post 11, having 10 scumreads on 9 people who posted 8 posts with 7 votes on 6 people. I mean seriously, take a fucking look at your own ISO and tell me if that is something regular in a 4-page 18-people mafia game. there's literally no way one can muster up so much in true seriousness, and it realy doesn't look like you're joking, not a titbit.

^ I could imagine esp-scum using that gambit and try claiming VT on page 1.
Another thing that you haven't addressed is that Esp leaves room open to change his claim later. Now it THAT AINT SCUMMY I DONT KNOW WHAT IS.
And thirdly, IF he's town then a policy lynch will learn him that his play is absolutely no good and extremely detrimental to the town.

WELL OBVIOUSLY BECAUSE THAT CLAIM IS A FUCKING REACTION TEST IT IS NOT REAL YOU NUTFUCK(s)...<<<the 's' is there to show that it's not personally against you, it's against all you littl'uns in this discussion

##Vote: shos

It's 7 days to early for the paranoia to be that unspeakable though!

sirdanilot: Why do you keep bringing up my join date like it matters? I don't know you from years ago or something if that's what you're asking. I'm saying your posts are town but terrible and will only result in tears for everyone.

There's only about 4 or 5 players in this game that are post '08. You just happen to be one of them.

OMG I feel like a supernewbie and I'm here for over 2 years

[shos]

TL;DR
Natirasha has been rolefishing twice: in post 15 and 54. other than that, natirasha's posts are reaheaally bad. vote natirasha, bawyz.

sirdanilot has been posting like it's a 15 pages game already, lots and lots of content, waaay too many overreactions and reads in such little time, that it seems like he is just faking it all to look like he's scumhunting.

reck is conftown.

[PeregrineV]

Vote: Aegor

Since I've never played with you.

Sunday post, so probably not much until Monday.

[sirdanilot]

This is true, but this is very characteristic for reck, and regardless Reck is conftown to me so nobody vote him please. let's just say that if I were a doc I'd doc him regardless of what happens today

K just noting this here, this is interesting. Don't like how you are claiming this so early though, absolutely no need for it. A couple pages back during the reck wagon, yes, but now?

and finally someone spotted this. it was a teeny reaction test as it was and it managed to get at least one fish - I called him town and voted him, and for that I and him are both scum, yes? kewlz.
^^^that guy is probscum as well - helps a policy wagon based on bullshit-who-publicly-admits-he-doesn't-even-think-target-is-scum, and this.

Your little reaction test was good, but the conclusions you're jumping to are terrible. Any towny would point out an obvious inconsistency like 'X is obvtown' vs 'vote x'.

I think that your (sirdan) post 90 is way too forced. in general, all your posting so quickly in the game looks terribly fake, like you're trying to look like you're a hardcore scumhunter by post 11, having 10 scumreads on 9 people who posted 8 posts with 7 votes on 6 people. I mean seriously, take a fucking look at your own ISO and tell me if that is something regular in a 4-page 18-people mafia game. there's literally no way one can muster up so much in true seriousness, and it realy doesn't look like you're joking, not a titbit.

Check my meta guy. 3 scumreads isn't that much. And aside from Esp who should die nothing is certain yet.

I actually like your Natirasha case better than the case on you. But your read of me is very ill-informed.

unvote shos

VOTE: Natirasha

[shos]

This is true, but this is very characteristic for reck, and regardless Reck is conftown to me so nobody vote him please. let's just say that if I were a doc I'd doc him regardless of what happens today

K just noting this here, this is interesting. Don't like how you are claiming this so early though, absolutely no need for it. A couple pages back during the reck wagon, yes, but now?

Remind me this in case Reck is nearing a lynch, so I will tell you why he is town without him claiming, and we'll see.

and finally someone spotted this. it was a teeny reaction test as it was and it managed to get at least one fish - I called him town and voted him, and for that I and him are both scum, yes? kewlz.
^^^that guy is probscum as well - helps a policy wagon based on bullshit-who-publicly-admits-he-doesn't-even-think-target-is-scum, and this.

Your little reaction test was good, but the conclusions you're jumping to are terrible. Any towny would point out an obvious inconsistency like 'X is obvtown' vs 'vote x'.

That is true, but not every towny would go vote me on the spot for that, call me scum, etc. a normal townie would point the inconsistency and direct a question to me.

I think that your (sirdan) post 90 is way too forced. in general, all your posting so quickly in the game looks terribly fake, like you're trying to look like you're a hardcore scumhunter by post 11, having 10 scumreads on 9 people who posted 8 posts with 7 votes on 6 people. I mean seriously, take a fucking look at your own ISO and tell me if that is something regular in a 4-page 18-people mafia game. there's literally no way one can muster up so much in true seriousness, and it realy doesn't look like you're joking, not a titbit.

Check my meta guy. 3 scumreads isn't that much. And aside from Esp who should die nothing is certain yet.

I actually like your Natirasha case better than the case on you. But your read of me is very ill-informed.

unvote shos

VOTE: Natirasha

comments in bold.
re: last quote - can you link me to meta? I'm kinda busy at home today so I don't feel like investigating.

[chamber]

Code: Select all

I don't like the way Peregrine came into the game like that. I'm wondering if he even read the thread.

tiercexReck is really boring. I don't think I see any useful information there, were you expecting reck to do anything other than FAKERAGE by piling on the pressure? Hard to get meaningful reactions from him.

I don't really get the shos wagon. He's being a bit of a derp but most of that was after it started. I need to go look for the root cause of it.

Shadoweh has had some more bad posts since her first. Especially post 64.

I'm VT, just going to obv town it up and get NKed though, nothing special. Spryex locking in his vote means it will happen sooner than later.

Vote ShadowEh

Sorry. All votecounts have been fixed.

Because apparently it got missed the first time.

[chamber]

Code: Select all

 Eh, I was wrong. The votes did follow after that calling the person you are obv town thing. I'm still not sold on that deserving that attention it got him though.

[ActionDan]

wtf.

[ActionDan]

are you doing what based on a role stipulation or just trying to be cute.

[chamber]

I'm neighbours with CES, whether we got it in our role PMs or not. DUH.

[ActionDan]

props to you I suppose if you bot hare just on the same wavelength. if you're not neighbors I'd say that highly suggests town actually

[sirdanilot]

What is the point of the CODE thing? If there is no point, please stop using it, it's extremely annoying.

That is true, but not every towny would go vote me on the spot for that, call me scum, etc. a normal townie would point the inconsistency and direct a question to me.

Well yeah that's how I roll dude. The town's strongest weapon is the vote; I often vote people while questioning them.

I don't like the way Peregrine came into the game like that. I'm wondering if he even read the thread.

I didn't like it either but I suppose he just didn't read the thread and made a RV assuming the thread to still be in rvs. I expect actual content from him now though.

[chamber]

What is the point of you posting? If there is no point, please stop, it's extremely annoying.

[xRECKONERx]

VOTE: xReckonerx

Reck is obvtown what are you all doin?!?!

?????

VOTE: shos

[shos]

^^^lol

[chamber]

VOTE: xReckonerx

Reck is obvtown what are you all doin?!?!

?????

VOTE: shos

Nice reading mate A+.

Unvote Vote Reck

[sirdanilot]

What is the point of you posting? If there is no point, please stop, it's extremely annoying.

Hahaha no.

Lol reck that's bad, read the thread guy

[MafiaSSK]

VOTE: xReckonerx

Reck is obvtown what are you all doin?!?!

?????

VOTE: shos

Nice reading mate A+.

Unvote Vote Reck

How is that a voteworthy vote?

[xRECKONERx]

wtf there was a 5th page ok

I see shos's post now. Still a dumb reaction test IMO but I do agree that sirdan's reasoning is pretty horse shit

VOTE: sirdan

[xRECKONERx]

VOTE: xReckonerx

Reck is obvtown what are you all doin?!?!

?????

VOTE: shos

Nice reading mate A+.

Unvote Vote Reck

this is also gross but also just chamber so idk

[sirdanilot]

wtf there was a 5th page ok

I see shos's post now. Still a dumb reaction test IMO but I do agree that sirdan's reasoning is pretty horse shit

VOTE: sirdan

lol