Mini 1537: ATTACK ON TITAN (Game Over!)

[Tammy]

But you also know that a hammer on day one doesn't ruin the game.

[pieguyn]

well that's interesting. fakegod quite obviously had that planned out. the way FG did it it was 100% fakeable and there was nothing whatsoever that would stop him from doing it as scum. not to mention I don't really know how much fakegod's plan would even help and it certainly wouldn't break the entire setup. this felt different in that it lookde like she was legitimately trying to figure out shit. the way she want about it felt town and seemed like it came from an angle of having an idea and trying to get the most info possible while withholding info from scum

I'm really bad at explaining this. does anyone else see what I'm seeing here?

[Bert]

But you also know that a hammer on day one doesn't ruin the game.

Sucks the life out of town. It's like a QB throwing an interception after his team's defense just got a huge stop.

[Brian Skies]

I'm seeing what you're seeing, which is why I said I thought her posting was coming from a town-mindset at the end of Day 1. But appearing to want to "break the game" isn't something I consider alignment indicative. You have to look at the whole picture.

In the game I linked, I knew FG's set-up spec benefited scum, but didn't know whether it was coming from town or scum. It wasn't until after his terrible push on Nacho that I could tie it together.

[Kazekirimaru]

I'm having a shitton of trouble seeing her scum after she tried to figure out a way to outright break the game

Why do you people write this off as a town-tell?

Don't remind me of that game. ._.

I thought the role seemed useless since flavor isn't alignment indicative

I thought Paschendale and Plum were equally likely to flip scum. Pasch's was confirm able via neighborizing.

As a bad player who is not bright and says stupid nonsensical stuff, I am speechless even though I make worse mistakes all the time, it seems. Hope that idiot hammer didn't ruin this game

Like fuck you did, Bert. Plum specifically said she could get names of peoples' abilities. You know what that means? She could have caught someone in a fakeclaim!

Yeah, you knew what you were doing.

[Bert]

Yeah, I missed that part...

Thought she/he only got flavor.

[Bert]

Oh my god, I am so dead today...

[Tammy]

I'm having a shitton of trouble seeing her scum after she tried to figure out a way to outright break the game

Why do you people write this off as a town-tell?

You're comparing kagami to fake god? FG who mods games and runs complicated setups to kagami who is new? I mean, no, trying to break a game is not outright town, but you have to look at the way people do it and I don't see going FakeGod did it so Kagami's isn't necessarily town.

[Tammy]

Oh my god, I am so dead today...

This is not how I would expect town you to react to getting heat.

[Brian Skies]

I'm having a shitton of trouble seeing her scum after she tried to figure out a way to outright break the game

Why do you people write this off as a town-tell?

You're comparing kagami to fake god? FG who mods games and runs complicated setups to kagami who is new? I mean, no, trying to break a game is not outright town, but you have to look at the way people do it and I don't see going FakeGod did it so Kagami's isn't necessarily town.

You're missing what I'm trying to say. Pie said he was having a hard time seeing Kagami not be town because the way she was trying to "outright break the game." And I offered Pie an immediate counter-example of Scum-FG appearing to "outright break the game." And although I know the type of player FG is now, I didn't know the type of player he was when I played that game with him. And obviously, based on my conversation with Mara in the dead QT, FG's reputation AS A MOD was giving other players in the game townvibes BECAUSE of his set-up speculation.

Pie's reasoning for Kagami being town was much better explained in his most recent post about Kagami. But thinking somebody is town just because of "appearing to try to break a game" is complete bullshit. It's all about the motivations behind their actions.

[Kthxbye]

Why isn't Bert dead yet?

[Brian Skies]

I don't know.

I was under the impression Muffin wanted a mass-claim and nobody else has said anything on the matter.

[Brian Skies]

I actually don't want a mass-claim, but I'm willing to claim my role since I don't see a point in keeping it hidden anymore.

[Rancid Broderick Drake]

I don't know.

I was under the impression Muffin wanted a mass-claim and nobody else has said anything on the matter.

Yaar, me skipper conscripted me into this game so he could be mission control while I ran a tight ship. Blame the lass fer the Pirate King's arrival.

But, aye, a mass claim will break this game. I hear it in the wind!

If ye wish to lead us off, do so, but let the Jesus wannabe be second, fer he has ye all fooled!

[Rancid Broderick Drake]

I was under the impression Muffin wanted a mass-claim

Aaaargh, but I have not yet posted today. I been in me cabin making origami out of old maps. I made a parrot. Would ye like ta see?

[Brian Skies]

I'm

Petra Ral

, an

Informed Human

(townie). I have a passive ability called

His Solid Rock: ActionDan

which tells me his flavor (Lance Corporal Levi) and his alignment (that he's with the human faction). It's also the reason why I had such a strong townread on him yesterday (because he was already confirmed to me). I was told that he was not aware of my alignment (so although the reciprocated townread felt good, I'm pretty sure that was just his read on me).

I don't trust zMM too much. tbfrank.

But I want him to be town. If you could lynch any one person today, who would it be?

This is me straight up addressing the person who is confirmed town to me. Not a breadcrumb.

Why am I so unsure about all my reads Muffin?

Well, not all of them.

This one was unintentional. But I decided to turn 888 into a breadcrumb with 889, since Dan was already confirmed to me and all.

Also, ActionDan is town.

Indubitably.

This is me trying to nitpick my way into Mastin's reads to remove doubt about whose alignment I was informed about should I end up getting NK'ed.

Dan Town. Mostly a gut-read and because

a little birdie told me so

.

A breadcrumb that Pie thinks is a scum-slip. The little birdie is my role PM.

You didn't really go by vibes which you tend to do. Also, the reasoning behind it felt bunched together and artificial. That's just how it looks. I thought it was a reaction test, in the mold of a Falcon reaction test, when I first saw the post. <3

No, those are my reads this game and my reasoning. The "vibes" may or may not be worded a different way, but they're there.

I just wanted to at least get my reads out before tonight in case something unexpected happens to me.

And I think you've seen enough of my games to know I don't like to commit to Day 1 deadline wagons (not really a deadline wagon, but it's getting close to being one).

This wasn't planned because Bert asked me about my reads. But it was an open invitation for the scum-team to night kill me. I'm also a 1-shot commuter, but I didn't use it last night.

So if Dan died because of me last night, my apologies to him.

Also, if town wants to mass-claim, that's your choice. Seeing as how town is expected to have 1-shot commuters, I have some reservations about it. You can consider this post a popcorn to Jesus if town does decide to do it.

[Rancid Broderick Drake]

I be lookin' for a few good pirates to join me crew. Today is the day we do what the Romans couldn't; kill Jesus and make him stay dead.

[Brian Skies]

So, like, I don't know. Are you both doing the whole role-play thing?

[Rancid Broderick Drake]

Pirates don't roleplay, ye thilly thailor.

[Brian Skies]

Aaaargh, weerrr de ter o' ye captervated bah de shimmerrrin seeee?

[Rancid Broderick Drake]

Speak English, please. Ye give pirates a bad name.

[Brian Skies]

[Rancid Broderick Drake]

I'll make ye me first matey though for effort!

[Rancid Broderick Drake]

Not so fast, Cap'n.

If he wants to join the crew, he needs to pass the exam first. It ain't all fun and games bein' a pirate, ye need to 'ave smarts.

Spoiler:

Question: Who lives in a pineapple under the sea?

[Brian Skies]

Dat one yellow spongy dude that I hate with a passion.