The Fall of Gondolin Mafia: Game Over (The Tale of Gondolin)

[sirdanilot]

Esp f you wanna save your own skin, vote JS. Cause I really still want a wagon on you, but I think your scumbuddies are simply not allowing it, and the town is sheeping your buddies.

OH WAIT JS is your buddy of course it would be bad form to vote the buddy that's protecting you, sorry man.

[Espeonage]

And setting up a strong of lynches. How many more ways you going to try to ensure all of the lynchbait dies while you shoot all the smart townies?

[sirdanilot]

Haha JS is a smart townie?

I wouldn't set up a string of lynches if the town weren't sheeping your scumbuddies. My bloodlust is satisfied if and only if you're dead.

[Espeonage]

Wat? No i was calling him lynchbait.

Identifying you are being scummy, doesn't negate the scumminess.

[sirdanilot]

Haha okay scummypants.

Guys who of the scumteam will we lynch first?

[Espeonage]

TIP

[TheIrishPope]

haha
Guys, repeat the case on me, because I'm not seeing it

[Espeonage]

I'm mainly on you because your posting screams of knowledge. And then there's all the dismissive-ness and attempts to discredit.

[shos]

HEY GUYS
free town points to whoever votes actiondan or tells me why not

[Elscouta]

... or tells me why not

Easy. Because that close to the deadline, we won't get a consensus on him, and because there is already many scum in the open. Also, nothing he said particularly pinged my radar.

At this stage, if you aren't voting Esp, JS or TIP, you are working against the town. That's the only three lynches that have a decent chance of getting through.

[Shadoweh]

I'm completely convinced the only reason TIP is here trolling every ten posts is it doesn't look as likely he's going to be lynched. If only certain unnamed people would stop going out of their way to defend the trolls that are quiet and buddy buddy about it when they're willing to work up a lynching froth for the loud, obnoxious ones.

Mrr. I would really prefer to lynch TIP but I'll agree to disagree and vote Jacob if no one else wants to go for it. Going back to Esp feels like rebeating a dead horse.

[Elscouta]

I agree (...) not necessarily on TIP. his posts might be short one liners and fluff, but they are a ton, and together they provide content and not that much noise. even with posts like "hahahahahahahah" - it's basically a post saying 'I disagree'. I sorta agree with him on some things, and I don't think he's a scumlynch for the while.

Guys, repeat the case on me, because I'm not seeing it

My dislike of TIP comes from two things:
- His voting. First he is Nat (a terrible wagon, but one that he considers his top scum suspect), then he moves towards Esp (visibly a compromise wagon). But when Esp wagon is getting really close to completion, he jumps off for MafiaSSK based on super-weak reasoning. My thoughts are, why would he, as town, suddenly stops compromising on Esp when the wagon is about to go through, in order to move to an obviously never-going-to-be-lynched target?
- His style. I may have been wrong to call his posts "fluff". Indeed, he states clearly his reads. However, there is no reasoning about his votes and reads, just snark and handwaving. That wouldn't be a large concern to me if his votes were actually good, but they have been faaaar from it (see previous point).

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Unvote, vote: TIP

[shos]

Well then.

vote: jacobSavage

Best of those three.

[sirdanilot]

A tip lynch to me would be nothing but a compromise lynch.

[TheIrishPope]

dislike =/= me being scum
and your points have no tie to my alignment soooo

[Elscouta]

Faking willingness to comprise then jump off the wagon for bad reasoning on an irrelevant target is very relevant to alignement.

[Elscouta]

comprise -> compromise

[TheIrishPope]

when did I fake willingness to compromise?
and what's the difference between me and other people starting other wagons?
you're just aiming for low hanging fruit, aren't you. shame on you. if you wanna win as scum win with dignity.

[Elscouta]

when did I fake willingness to compromise?

Your vote on Espeonage, then quickly moving it on MafiaSSK

and what's the difference between me and other people starting other wagons?

The snarkiness and the lack of reasoning about your moves / votes

[TheIrishPope]

yeah explain how that's fake willingness to compromise and the point you still haven't answered, why the fuck does it make you think I'm scum
easy to generalize without proof huh?

[sirdanilot]

TIP shouldn't be a top scumread for anyone at this point. At most one of the minor scum reads.

Unless someone shows me meta that tip does not always act like this.

[Elscouta]

yeah explain how that's fake willingness to compromise and the point you still haven't answered, why the fuck does it make you think I'm scum

If you were willing to comprise, you wouldn't start a bullshit counterwagon to Esp. Given you provide little reasoning for your reads, the only thing we have is your voting pattern, and this voting pattern is horrible : 2 bad wagon, and a quick jump off from the only half decent wagon you participated to.

easy to generalize without proof huh?

I am sorry that I am not able to have a definite proof that the fingerprints found near Hùrin are yours. I am sure the legal team will be able to fix this once we take your hands off your dead body though. Ooooh look i can post snarky comments too.

[sirdanilot]

Els how is my voting pattern?

[Tierce]

118 posts.

ONE HUNDRED AND EIGHTEEN POSTS. Varda help us all. Plum, you owe me for this game.