Mini 1537: ATTACK ON TITAN (Game Over!)

[mastin2]

VOTE: mastin

No.

kaze you're so transparent

your plan to paint zmuffin as scum in the neighborhood didn't work so now you have to switch to tammy. hardly ggs

Indeed.

VOTE: Kazekirimaru.

Pie is the only one I really trust, but my current opinion is that there's a strong possibility that the entire neighborhood is town, but if it isn't, kaze is the scummo. I think that bro+kthx are probably town, but the "loss" they suffer from the other dying is completely silly.

Pie more or less gave the gist of my thoughts on why bert is a bad lynch for today. I have additional thoughts about how what goes down tonight might be interpreted, but they're little more than wild speculation until it actually happens.

Why do you think mastin is town?

I still think that this is scum.

Interesting. I was thinking mastin/kaze/brian, but I would have expected kaze to make the kill in that case.

That's because it requires someone being scum who isn't.

Kagama/Kaze/Brian, however, does--with you making the kill.

[Kazekirimaru]

Ladies and gentleman, I am not a crook.

VOTE: Mastin

[mastin2]

Ladies and gentleman, I am not a crook.

VOTE: Mastin

Yeah, not a crook--
A titan.

[Kazekirimaru]

Ladies and gentleman, I am not a titan.

[Paschendale]

Alright, reports from bro, pasch, and kthx?

I used up my one shot ability on night 1.

Ladies and gentleman, I am not a crook.

Kaze not handing in the kill doesn't really change anything for me. And I certainly see him as far more likely scum than Mastin.

VOTE: Kaze

[Kagami]

Why do you believe you used it up, pasch?

[Kazekirimaru]

Ladies and gentleman, I am not a titan.

gentlemen*

Atrocious. How did you people let me make such a mistake?

Anyway, Mastin should die, etc.

[Kagami]

Ladies and gentleman, I am not a crook.

VOTE: Mastin

Yeah, not a crook--
A titan.

Ladies and gentleman, I am not a titan.

This is a very interesting exchange.

Titans for the scum-team is the obvious contrast with "Human," but the flavor for both nightkills suggest the killers are not titans. If we're dealing with titans, this sounds like a knowledge-slip from mastin. If they aren't titans, then kaze's denial is similarly suspect.

Bro, what do you think about the night kill?

[Tammy]

Can you puhlease star doing more scumhunting puhlease. The flavor speculation, role speculation, etc etc is getting ridiculous and I'm starting to believe you might be scum who doesn't know how to fake Scumhunt so you're focusing on flavor and roles to hide.

[Kazekirimaru]

Kagami has speculated role stuff in every game I've played with her/read of hers. I'm pretty sure that's just her thing.

[Tammy]

There's one thing for speculation here and there and another for it to be almost all you do. Also she needs to learn when it's actually dangerous and gives more info to scum than they need to have.

[Tammy]

Also I'm still not convinced on pasch being town.

And pie was a weird kill, yeah.

[Rancid Broderick Drake]

Yaar we be 90% on Kaze/mastin.

VOTE: Mastin

Paschedale is next on me list o' traitors, perhaps more than Kaze if Mastin flips scum.

[Kazekirimaru]

I'm confused.

You were so set on me, NatiMuffin. I don't understand why you're going this route.

[Kagami]

Also I'm still not convinced on pasch being town.

And pie was a weird kill, yeah.

Pie kill was more than weird. Among other things, it implies that scum do not have a roleblocker.

[Rancid Broderick Drake]

Aye, I am set on ye, but we have wanted mastin dead since the first dawn.

And goddammit it will happen!

[Kazekirimaru]

I don't follow.

[Tammy]

Also I'm still not convinced on pasch being town.

And pie was a weird kill, yeah.

Pie kill was more than weird. Among other things, it implies that scum do not have a roleblocker.

Actually it doesn't, though I'm inclined to not believe pasch anyway.

I was a scum rb once, and we killed vanillas and left the tracker alive until endgame getting no results all game long while we killed more dangerous yo us players. Thing is I don't know why pie would be considered dangerous, so I'll have to go back and look at him.

[Kagami]

I agree on the mastin lynch, but I want kthx to check in on the off chance his mystery power did something valuable last night.

[Kagami]

Also I'm still not convinced on pasch being town.

And pie was a weird kill, yeah.

Pie kill was more than weird. Among other things, it implies that scum do not have a roleblocker.

Actually it doesn't, though I'm inclined to not believe pasch anyway.

I was a scum rb once, and we killed vanillas and left the tracker alive until endgame getting no results all game long while we killed more dangerous yo us players. Thing is I don't know why pie would be considered dangerous, so I'll have to go back and look at him.

What? Who on earth would a roleblocker block if not bro?

[Tammy]

You didn't tie it to bro, you tied it to the pie kill. But I'd say a roleblocker would block either bro, kthnx (if he's town I have my doubts) and me if they really wanted to make sure their kill went through.

[Kagami]

To kill pie implies that they believed a bro kill wouldn't go through (because you'd block it), which they wouldn't be worried about if the had a roleblocker.

[Rancid Broderick Drake]

To kill pie implies that they believed a bro kill wouldn't go through (because you'd block it)

Ye be thinking about things too one-dimensionally, young lass.

[Paschendale]

Would someone like to actually give some support for the Mastin lynch? I was asking yesterday and no one rose up to the challenge. Is it just PoE? Is it just gut? Is there a reason?

[Kagami]

Pasch,

1. How many scum do you think were on plum's wagon?
2. Why did you know your neighborize had failed prior to bert saying it did?
3. Why did you assume your shot was consumed by the roleblock?