In post 718, Skullduggery wrote:Actually, you know what? Orc's entire case on me is built upon the erroneous belief that I was role-fishing, but how can I be role-fishing if he (presumably) already told us his role? This just reinforces my belief that he was lying when he said he was hated until Night 2. He would only accuse me of role-fishing if his role is different from what he told us it was.
The only question now is why. Why would he lie about being hated until Night 2, and is this lie coming from a Town mindset or a Scum mindset? Anyone want to help me figure this out?
While I disagree about him lying, I'll pretend I believe he is for a moment.
By saying he's hated until N2, that makes early wagons against him more cautious. However, he'll still get quickwagoned up to L-1 on D3 for said claim (to test the truth).
Scum would lie about hated for obvious reasons, make wagons against them more careful.
Town could claim hated until N2 (and actually be permanently hated) to try and fool scum off of quickhammering him in lylo.
Town could claim hated as a way to prevent scum from targetting them at night.
Frankly, he's not playing methodically as I'd expect scum who claimed hated to be.
As for rolefishing, he only mentioned hated. Correct me if I'm mistaken, but can't modifiers such as (hated, miller) also include an actual role?
I do think he's town, however I disagree with him re:you.
You're solid.
