In post 501, Kazekirimaru wrote:Why don't you bother to read scumgames of people whose scumgames you're unfamiliar with?
Two factors, basically. First being laziness, the second being that I question the usefulness of doing so in the first place--second-hand meta is no substitute for first-hand experience.
In post 514, Venmar wrote:I think mastin is town. I'm quite sure this isn't his scum play.
While I appreciate the vote of confidence...why? I mean, I can understand some other players townreading me, but you're not among the ones I'd expect. My memory of you is that quite frankly, it took a ton of my power to make you stop scumreading me last time.
Orcinus becomes more town on page 21, by the way.
In post 539, Flandre Scarlet wrote:In regards to my last post not feeling genuine- (not really looking for sympathy, just explaining)- I'm trying to mask my playstyle (PL the metadodger) as well as get a feel for where I fit into the machine.
(By the way, basically the only reason I haven't figured out who you are is that I've put zero effort into trying. Your posting's really damn familiar, and that means your style even on an alt is shining through and I remembered it. I'm just not bothering to figure out why.
)
Cephrir's 576 is horribad, by the way.
Well, regardless of pie's alignment, you're scum. Pie's probably a scum bodyguard*, but not certainly so. However, even though I'm reasonably certain his claim's fake, it's not something I'm lynching today.
(*No, not really a scum bodyguard, as interesting a role as that'd be.
Pie is likely scum fakeclaiming bodyguard.)
If pie's town, Cabd might be scum.
Not to me, but I'm letting it pass for the time being.
In post 609, Varsoon wrote:Gotta sheep Kaze
VOTE: Pieguy
I don't think Pie's the kinda guy to fake-claim, but Pie has a tell that I'm relying on and right now it has me pinging scum there.
Too sick to sleep. God this sucks.
Regardless of pie's alignment, this is town. This is not scum bussing; this is not scum jumping onto a wagon on a PR. This is town, through-and-through.
In post 616, Cabd wrote:Well that pretty much confirmed pie's slot as town, as much as I hate alignment-indicative replace outs.
I see it as genuine and not faked, but that doesn't equate to town. I'm treating the act as a null-tell because the wording was, well...it felt like it could have been talking about a scum PM filtered through an attempt to have a town PM, if that makes sense.
Yep. This slot's scum.
In post 684, Venmar wrote:I'll probably end up being the only one who thinks Pie is still scum cause her post wasn't town bitching it was her as a player in general bitching. You people are gullible and ate it up for whatever reason, failing to realize it wasn't exclusively from a town perspective at all, but "omg pie threatened to leave the game SHE IS SO FUCKING TOWN HOLY SHIT AMIRITE". Whenever a player throws an AtE tantrum, tries to replace out, but then stays when people tell them to stay, they should either not fucking play this game again or they are just scum. The last time i've seen a player do this THEY WERE FUCKING SCUM.
(For the record, I do lean town on Venmar.)
[5] mastin2 (Cephrir, pieguyn, Cabd, Metal Sonic, Varsoon)
Ceph's scum, Metal Sonic's *probably* scum, and pie/Cabd will be sorted out. Varsoon's town, though.
In post 765, Cephrir wrote:It is worth noting, though, that I don't see ahypothetical scum neighbor benefiting from going after their neighbors... that would make them look worse once said hypothetical neighbors flipped town.
Yeah, you're scum.
Oh god. I just realized something--
I'm nearly impossible to lynch as scum, except when it comes to the players who know me well and have that high accuracy at reading me...and even then, they often have trouble. This extends to my mislynch rate as well, with my death via rope being quite uncommon.
Scum also tend to have a healthy respect for me, causing me to get nightkilled early-on a fair amount of the time. And it gets better--often, people sheep me quite easily, despite me giving little to no reasoning behind my pushes. Additionally, when I *do* give logic, it is typically crazy. (Plus, I say some pretty insane shit.)
But to top it all off? I also have a fondness for VCA, and of stubbornly pushing things. Yet it gets even better. I get the impression that in my town games, increasingly, I'm either amazingly right or amazingly wrong.
...I think I'm turning into DGB.
VOTE: Cephrir.
