Newbie 1471: Italian Ice (Game Over!)

[TierShift]

do you have some real reasoning for once?

Says the guy who said: 'let's lynch tier cause he has the most nulls

@Sakura:
I strictly opposed the sentiment that the lurking was scummy. I showed that I disliked nacho for pushing a lurkervso strongly. If, however, I need to choose between an ED and a robw lynch you can be damn sure I'll vote rob.

[TierShift]

post 589

is the biggest tell tale to me imo, its fresh from today

You are hilarious.

[Sakura Hana]

It looked like a taunting question wrt to my previous post to me... the other points are mostly what I was referring to.

[bjc]

Time to bring TS down.

unvote; vote: TierShift

as a side note, the f*** are you talking about TS? Every time the game stalled out I did something to at least help propel us forward. I drew attention to myself; I drew both scum on my wagon; I pointed out things I didn't like.

I'm sure if you asked TS he'd tell you I was the worst player evar at mafia.

Whatevs, bro. It's time we get a flip.

You also misinterpret what I said about rob to my "attackers" and you also conveniently missed my post when I originally made it!

[Sakura Hana]

so bjc, you think TS is scum, or are you just voting him because you want a flip.

[bjc]

I don't really believe TS is town. That's where I am with him. He has done absolutely nothing to improve his image; he's only made it worse.

[TierShift]

It's still us three posting in circles...

I can't see ika being scum.

I am having a hard time seeing TS as scum and his ability to think about things (if genuine) has helped my view on him.

People I want to hear from:
Nacho
LMB
AboTT's replacement
Robw's replacement (

MOD: It's very clear this guy is not settling into this game; please replace him.

)

Time to bring TS down.

unvote; vote: TierShift

as a side note, the f*** are you talking about TS? Every time the game stalled out I did something to at least help propel us forward. I drew attention to myself; I drew both scum on my wagon; I pointed out things I didn't like.

I'm sure if you asked TS he'd tell you I was the worst player evar at mafia.

Whatevs, bro. It's time we get a flip.

You also misinterpret what I said about rob to my "attackers" and you also conveniently missed my post when I originally made it!

Delicious newbscum.
Why again did everyone jump off of his wagon?

[Sakura Hana]

He made several posts between those 2 you know...
more importantly:

How on earth is TS's above post pro town in any way?

I guess i should have noticed this before as well, but at the time I was too busy trying to sort TS myself as I already thought bjc was town enough.

[TierShift]

Explain to me how it is anti town in any way.

[Sakura Hana]

So bjc, can you explain your thought progress from Post 580 to 622 to 678?

[TierShift]

His read on me changed from town to scum based solely on post 620, as far as I can see. He insinuated in his latest post that I had been scummy for a long time and that my image only deteriorated, while that is just untrue if you look at his posting from like a day ago in which he calls me town.

[ika]

gameflow...

nothing has truly changed yet. i could see it going wither way with all the interactions. for me its just that its say 1 and ont only confirmed towns im my eyes are me. both of you are jabbing at each others necks like no tommorow. day one has the most chaos atm. how about this for both of you

give me one gian case on each other on why they must be scum. if you are going to refer to posts, use the number only. so far you 2 bickerings is starting to look like OMGUS to me. if you 2 are so decided that one is town and other is scum prove it with one giant post of a case

[TierShift]

Are you talking about me vs bjc?

[bjc]

enough of your survivalism play. at this point your play is becoming more hindeirng to me then helpful if your town.

......... Okay. Whatever, someone hammer me so I can play in a different newb game.

^
Does this look like survivalist to you?
And if his play is hindering you then you're effectively pushing for a policy lynch, now that i finished reading im thinking on bjc as more town. Maybe because I've been in his position before.
Also Ika leaning more scum =/

Don't even try to insinuate 608 is not very very easily fakeable by scum.

That said, bjc doesn't look like it's gonna happen and emerald is, so I'll switch over the next few days if bjc doesn't start picking up votes again.

This post is scummy as hell, that's my opinion. AT BEST it is anti-town.

This thread has a very good opening post.

QFT

Also I don't see why my last post is bad, I showed that I want a bjc lynch more than an ED lynch but just by a bit.

This actually makes it worse IMO.

I just wanna hear from emerald once more before driving him up to a claim...I'm not really convinced so far.

Now, because he knows ED is town or his scumbuddy, he's backing off. Riiight.

Not to mention I believe someone showed his flip-flopping with RobW.

[bjc]

Also, interacting with others/this game becoming alive again has also helped.

[bjc]

TS is doing his best to deflect everything coming his way as best as possible.

[ika]

terishift, bjc

make one giant post on why the ohter is scum. using any of the other persons post is allowed but must be numbereed like you did in 685.

p-edit: yes im talking aobut you 2 if you guys are gonna shove each other might as well 1v1 it in one big case to settle the matter

[Sakura Hana]

if you are going to refer to posts, use the number only.

As an additional suggestion if you're going to do this use post tags

Code: Select all

[post]234[/post]

Becomes 234, which links to that exact post number in this thread

[Sakura Hana]

interacting with others/this game becoming alive again has also helped.

You're welcome.

[TierShift]

Bjc, you are just quoting my posts, making one liners and calling jt a day. You really need to elaborate.
Why is my post anti-town?
Why does the followup post make it worse?
Why is backing off a scumtell?

I can't argue if you don't provide reasoning and then you call all my responses deflecting.

[ika]

im gonna be getting ready for work i will glance back before i leave and prob give imput come the end of it when i get off work.

p-edit: that will work, this little challenge i set up should settle it once and for all. also you may not refute any points the person made untill you make your case on the opposing person. if you to i will consider it scum stalling

[bjc]

ika, IMO that is a stupid idea. I am not one to do great big posts about why someone is scum, and generally don't get the point across as well as I should. So you want to vote based on who the better presentation-giver is? Sounds legit to me.

[ika]

ika, IMO that is a stupid idea. I am not one to do great big posts about why someone is scum, and generally don't get the point across as well as I should. So you want to vote based on who the better presentation-giver is? Sounds legit to me.

either you do it or myvote will easily switch back to you. so far all i have seen from the 2 of you is you guys shouting each other is scum. this isnt only for my benifit, this is for everyones benifit to decide.

if you want to be listened to build a case instead of using one-liners for everything

[TierShift]

My case is in 505. Adding to that is his sudden scumreading of me when all the other players flipped on me (see 681 and 685) where he's again just pushing all lynches that aren't him. Especially here, his sentiment on me changed very quickly after he saw two votes on me.

This is my case, stated in a nice and concise manner. I have heard no refutal to any of the points made here as of yet and I'm wondering what made you all reconsider your scumread on bjc.

[bjc]

Your post was anti-town because you're holding off on the ED wagon for silly reasons. If you really do prefer a wagon on me by just a little bit, you should be a-okay with voting for ED. After all, you make it sound like you're down to vote him. You're stalling for some reason.

Perhaps it's because ED is your scumbuddy. I doubt that is it. So perhaps it's because you

know

ED is town. After all scum know who the townies are.

Perhaps you want to make sure you can kill someone else once ED has claimed a PR, that way you can attempt or think about killing ED at night to put the town down two including a PR the next day. Who knows? That's why I want a flip on you.

Then you say, "why was my last post bad? I just said I prefer a bjc lynch by a little bit." So you should be fine with seeing an ED flip! Should you not?

All in all you show a reluctance to vote ED and put him L-1, which does not mean ED will be lynched by any means. Why is that?

p-edit: ika, am I supposed to be afraid of you voting a townie? No? Okay, so why do you always threaten me if I don't play by your rules?

That gets old.