Newbie 1471: Italian Ice (Game Over!)

[pisskop]

guys, whos my scummbuddy? i mean besidesme whos neck is out?

[Sakura Hana]

guys, whos my scummbuddy? i mean besidesme whos neck is out?

TS has been defending your slot pretty heavily despite it being a person that only fluffed enough to avoid getting prodded, he eventually got prodded and replaced in the end but come on.
Have you ISO'd your predecessor?

[ika]

guys, whos my scummbuddy? i mean besidesme whos neck is out?

TS has been defending your slot pretty heavily despite it being a person that only fluffed enough to avoid getting prodded, he eventually got prodded and replaced in the end but come on.
Have you ISO'd your predecessor?

i feel like regardless of what pisskop flips atm we are going to flip ts next. did you see my IoAA (if thats right) and why he is a better candidate atm? i feel like ts flip would be more benifical atm and would clear up this emeral/pisskop/bjc thing that just happened

[pisskop]

Posting content is not equivalent to the content or the person being town. Even if the content in isolation is pro-town, it must also be considered in how it is delivered (word choice, etc), when it is delivered (after other people say the same thing?), why it is delivered (oh noes wagons on me?), and other things of similar nature.

[snip]

Content that does not further the process of finding scum or is posted in such a way as to indicate that the poster is scum is inherently not going to be pro-town content.

[snip]

If the game were as easy as "posters of content are town, posters of not-content are scum," then mafia would never have become an interesting or worthwhile game.

RayTown makes a point I think Ill be rehashing later.

pedit: whats with being so lynchhappy?

if i die tonight why would ts be worth lynching d3? if I flip town is he scummier? chill out, its bothering me.

[pisskop]

page 22. going to bed.

-----town

rayTown
hana - Aabott was town. you act just as town.
bjc - i gutread you here for a few reasons.

everyone else is null or less.

i do have specific quotes in mind.

@hana, nope, but I can inagine he was nothing special. Iwant to finish reading through first.

[pisskop]

ohh, one more thing. somebody from my townlist please expkain why nacho is obvtown? do not see it.

[TierShift]

Hey kop.

Your entrance is not very convincing. Any scumreads? Things that look awkward? Other things that stand out?

[RayFrost]

I don't think he's obvtown. I think he's more likely to be town than other players in this game, given certain conditions that I haven't stated yet. And that won't be stated for the time being.

[pisskop]

fair enough. ^^

@tier, a few things. I almos posted several selects, but I can find them again after if they are so bothesome? i want to iso a few players, one for a percieved readflop.

[emeraldemon]

@ika
I can't tell if you're lazy or scum, but I'm hoping lazy. Let me quote for you the parts of the thread you should have read already:

Time is short, we're gonna have to lynch soonish. Post 670 from Tiershift actually felt townish to me, but maybe I am getting too caught up in it. I have always been OK with lynching Rob.

Rob is probably going to get replaced with 48 hours left or something like that, his replacement will make a spurt of vaguely townish posts, and either we'll lynch him anyway or we won't. I feel like it'll be very difficult to get an accurate read on a completely new player in a day.

The question is, do wait for the replacement in case he claims PR?

Claim.

nope lynch me.

Any questions?

[TierShift]

fair enough. ^^

@tier, a few things. I almos posted several selects, but I can find them again after if they are so bothesome? i want to iso a few players, one for a percieved readflop.

I have no idea what you're trying to say here.

[Sakura Hana]

For me is mostly because Meta or the personal experience type, I've played with Nacho in many games and even hydra'd with him, so I know more or less how his mind works. That meta is all from 2013 tho, so idk what kind of meta Ray may have on him.

[pisskop]

fair enough. ^^

@tier, a few things. I almos posted several selects, but I can find them again after if they are so bothesome? i want to iso a few players, one for a percieved readflop.

I have no idea what you're trying to say here.

i do have reads. its killing me not to blurt then out and see what sticks, but Im 12pgs behind and no iso yet. obvious statement though, scum know their way around a game.

@hana
okay, hes not like soo scummy I need to killhimnow, but I just didnt see obvtown.

[pisskop]

enough of your survivalism play. at this point your play is becoming more hindeirng to me then helpful if your town.

......... Okay. Whatever, someone hammer me so I can play in a different newb game.

^
Does this look like survivalist to you?
And if his play is hindering you then you're effectively pushing for a policy lynch, now that i finished reading im thinking on bjc as more town. Maybe because I've been in his position before.
Also Ika leaning more scum =/

it was a pure test to see his breaking point, he sat at l-1 for a very long time, and he continued to tryt o stall it out and push elsewhere. at first i thought it was flail scum, but his continued fight makes me think hes town. also his last post saying "fuck it lynch me" was all i needed to know to make me think hes town.

i still feel like there was survivalism play in it but it wasnt scum driven survivalism.

i come back and see pisskop first few posts. im almost tempted to sheep him becasue i still want to see a bjc flip becasue it would also contain info.

i was reflecting back on this game at work and was tossing an idea around

ts/bjc are the scums

i cant be the only guy reading this, and iys not the first time hes flopped on a read based on current events. killitwithfire. and a rope.

vote: ika

[bjc]

Not convinced.

[ika]

@ika
I can't tell if you're lazy or scum, but I'm hoping lazy. Let me quote for you the parts of the thread you should have read already:

Time is short, we're gonna have to lynch soonish. Post 670 from Tiershift actually felt townish to me, but maybe I am getting too caught up in it. I have always been OK with lynching Rob.

odds are he will just be tommorows lynch

Rob is probably going to get replaced with 48 hours left or something like that, his replacement will make a spurt of vaguely townish posts, and either we'll lynch him anyway or we won't. I feel like it'll be very difficult to get an accurate read on a completely new player in a day.

then why did you not vote him sooner, why did you wait for replacement?

The question is, do wait for the replacement in case he claims PR?

again, yours just stalling, if you planned on lynching him, why not just vote him and do it later.

Claim.

nope lynch me.

Any questions?

is that your sole reason? then your just scum up the ass for doign something like that if he is to flip town

so main thing is, why wait for votign him if you were going to do it anyway?

[ika]

863: we already discussed my flips and flops, im not the lynch for today at this time, if they want to lynch me tommorow they can. if you can get a flash wagon on me for today you can do that too.

your most likely town. you missed the bigger point of many of my post appaently.

[pisskop]

so explain them. apparently you are lynch material if Im joining a wagon, and long/frequent posts =/=town.

as far as nachos request I claim, wifom under the bridge. hes not town to me,and he would have reason to say that no matter his alignment. dont generate content where there is none to be had.

[Sakura Hana]

I direct you to this page as to why Nacho thinks you're scum: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... &start=725
And there's also PoE involved, also look how TS reacts towards all statistical accusations on your slot.

[bjc]

vote: pisskop

[bjc]

L-2

[pisskop]

Yea youd be stupid to lynch me without the rest of my reads.

[ika]

so explain them. apparently you are lynch material if Im joining a wagon, and long/frequent posts =/=town.

as far as nachos request I claim, wifom under the bridge. hes not town to me,and he would have reason to say that no matter his alignment. dont generate content where there is none to be had.

its my playstyle. iirc i have only your vote so its not really lynch material, think of it more of my playstyle on how i play. i know that long/frequent posts =/=town. but my post have been scum hunting.

if you can convince others then go ahead. im just trying to give you benifit of a doubt atm becasue i want to see a ts lynch much more if anything atm. but if i have to settle for a lynch on you i will. i still feel like your lynch will have little to no info come the end of it. the only info we can get is if you flip goon. if you flip town it doesnt give us as much, i still feel like ts should be lynch.

[Sakura Hana]

L-2

Actually it's L-1

[GuyInFreezer]

bump