Marvel Avengers Alliance - Game over

[Zekrom25]

@Thor explain your list further

[XScorpion]

I just got home; I'll respond to everything that I've missed since I left on Friday as soon as I have a chance (it is about dinner time now). Expect a post tonight from me.

[XScorpion]

Spoiler: BROseidon

I don't think that the push against cxin is bad (I pretty much agree w/ Thor in 117). Re: 121 - Do you think cxin is competent town? Incompetent town? Scum?

Spoiler: bulbazak

It was somewhat serious. Why would you have no problem voting me if I said I was 100% serious about what I'd said?

I believe the appropriate buzzword is 'stretching'. Seriousness at that stage of the game seems uncalled for.
If you thought the OMGUS wasn't worth discussing, why didn't you say so earlier?
Who have you looked at besides porkens? You haven't really reached out much and have spent (in my opinion) way too much time interacting with him while disregarding the rest of the game. I can't tell if you think Thor is scum or not.

Spoiler: porkens

126 comes totally out of nowhere. Why suddenly dropping the push on bulb? Are they scum together?

Which airplanes are you guys on, btw?

What is the purpose of asking this question?

Spoiler: smargaret

I disagree with the 'disproportionately scummy' comment; just because they know the game has started doesn't mean they need to start posting in the thread right away.

Spoiler: thor

I entirely agree that I think Bulb knew it looked bad. But you accused him of being scum in the post right after, before he started talking to Porkens. Your points make sense in hindsight, but what was your reasoning in post 8?

Spoiler: Yates

If he isn't pretending to scumhunt, what is he doing? Claiming scum?
I do like your line of thinking about the low-hanging fruit. What would it take to convince you he is town?

Spoiler: zakk

Please tell me how serious you thought 'lynch all liars' was.
And maybe tell me what you think about the rest of the game while you're at it. Why was my post more interesting than everything else?

Spoiler: zekrom

You need to explain why you are asking the questions you are asking. I am not convinced that things like '@Thor please provide a detailed description of your emotional stat currently' are helpful to anyone. How have you helped catch scum?
You say thor is scum for not helping you scumhunt. I am not helping you scumhunt either. Are we both scum?

Smudger and I seem to be along a similar wavelength.
Meanwhile, Cxinlee is on a wavelength I can't identify.
And I think the only people I missed otherwise haven't posted.

[Yates]

If he isn't pretending to scumhunt, what is he doing?

Absolutely nothing. Which was the point of that statement.

What would it take to convince you he is town?

Combination of Town role and mod confirmation? I don't know. What does it take to convince YOU someone is Town? How about this; something more than nothing?

[XScorpion]

He's doing nothing, but I think he is pretending (poorly) to do something, which is why I think he is scum.
He could convince me he was town by behaving like a townie. If he was clearly trying (actually trying) to search for scum I would think he was town, but he isn't.

[XScorpion]

He's doing nothing, but I think he is pretending (poorly) to do something, which is why I think he is scum.
He could convince me he was town by behaving like a townie. If he was clearly trying (actually trying) to search for scum I would think he was town, but he isn't.

[cxinlee]

Ill go into this later.

Porkens could you define opinion?

no!

Don't try to drag this into the worst semantic argument in history. Do one of the following:

1. Say "no, fuck you porkers; I

have

given opinions, and here they are: <quote>"
2. Turn you life around, give some opinions, and discuss the actual things happening in the game
3. Gently accept the rope

I don't want to argue about semantics. I want to know how you define opinion.

From the thread you can infer the following:

I think Thor is town

I think Xscorpion is equally likely to be town than scum

I don't support the Zekrom wagon. And I don't agree he's scum

[XScorpion]

^^ who is most probable scum in your eyes then?

[Thor665]

@Thor explain your list further

What list?

I entirely agree that I think Bulb knew it looked bad. But you accused him of being scum in the post right after, before he started talking to Porkens. Your points make sense in hindsight, but what was your reasoning in post 8?

I feel like my answer applies to 8 as well as my current attitude as I described both my initial reaction to the comment from him, and now the further evidence I gained from the continued reaction.

[Thor665]

I just ISOed myself, I don't think I've even made a list this game.

[Thor665]

Heck, I barely make lists in any game.

[Porkens]

Xscorpion, how carefully have you read this game thread? Are there any parts that you haven't paid much attention to?

[XScorpion]

I'll admit I barely read anything about your fight with Bulb. I'd say I have thoroughly read about...70%?

[Porkens]

Then I'll keep my (dumb) secrets bwahahahah. <ps it's irrelevant>

[Zekrom25]

hmm....

[Smudger]

Thor I think Zekrom25 is referring to your town pool. He seems to think it is a list. Maybe he hopes he is on it.

[Bulbazak]

If you thought the OMGUS wasn't worth discussing, why didn't you say so earlier?

Because by that point I was pursuing an actual suspect, and I didn't think it was relevant anymore.

Who have you looked at besides porkens?

Cxin and Zekrom. Zekrom especially still hasn't answered the simple question I asked him.

I can't tell if you think Thor is scum or not.

I'm not sure.

@Zekrom: Answer my question. How is Thor not helpful?

[jasonT1981]

Day 1 Vote Count 2

Zekrom25 6 - XScorpion,Smudger,Thor665,BROseidon,Porkens,Yates
Bulbazak 1 - cxinlee
cxinlee 1 - smargaret
Porkens 1 - Bulbazak,
Xscorpion 1- zakk
Thor665 1 - Zekrom25

Not Voting

T S O
Yiley

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

(expired on 2014-02-27 16:44:37)

till Day 1 Deadline

[jasonT1981]

TSO & Yiley Have been prodded

[T S O]

oooh, this game.

catching up.

[T S O]

Thor, what meta on Zekrom convinced you that it was time to move from Bulbazak?

Because Bulba looked like he was panicking at being caught on d1.

VOTE: Bulbazak

BROseidon's entrance was incredibly bad, but he sorta got better, so I'm not gonna go after him for now.

Zekrom wagon is shamefully poor. No-one here can read him whatsoever, but almost no-one has admitted they don't have a clue about him. I'd be very surprised if there isn't scum on Zekrom right now, potentially multiple scum.

[T S O]

Thor's incredibly opaque, so while he looks Town, it doesn't count for much imo.

If Bulba flips scum, then he's practically an IC.

[T S O]

I genuinely feel we could have this wrapped up nicely.

[Yiley]

Sorry guys didn't know this had started reading now

[T S O]

I empathise, Yiley. I empathise.