The Fall of Gondolin Mafia: Game Over (The Tale of Gondolin)

[Tierce]

That was more a general thing. But I have to make sure we stay on the same page:

Sirdan isn't dying. You should know why.

But come on butter my bread. You know what I want.

I'd rather not do that before going through Shadoweh's stuff, since I don't quite know what I'd ask in return besides ABR.

[shos]

Alright.
VOTE: ABR

His claim(s) do not make sense. He claimed to have been roleblocked yesterday. He claimed to have been roleblocked today too.
If he is a VT, he wouldnt do that today. He is lying. Or extremely unluckily correct.

Should I claim, or can we have him lynched without me claiming?

[shos]

Actually if he was town then why would scum RB him tonight if he is even night? So even moreso scum

[shos]

Hey guys
I have a (hypothetical of coursr) question
If I am a jailkeeper and theres a claimed cop
Do i jk him or not?

[Espeonage]

If you're claimed say your randomising between the cop and another player then randomise it.
If unclaimed, then yeah. For the first day, then claim, then do the above.

[shos]

More answers please

[Tierce]

There are arguments for and against it. Wouldn't be surprised either way, it's a WIFOM game.

[shos]

I asked for ypur opinion.answer.

[Tierce]

Actually no, you asked for answers to a hypothetical question. I am not interested in the details of this hypothesis at this point, and therefore am not interested in giving you a more detailed answer. It doesn't concern me, because without details about the reads of this hypothetical Jailkeeper and how likely they thought the Cop claim was true and how likely it was that the Cop was to be Nightkilled if the claim was true, all you're getting is "a Jailkeeper might or might not think that jailing the claimed Cop is a proTown action". It's a WIFOM game and getting down to number-crunching, which would be my personal answer, is a matter for MD, not for a game where we're lynching ABR. Move along.

[Espeonage]

About time I had accurate reads.

[sirdanilot]

Spyrex, he's like that in every game, town or scum.

Not back in 22008. He was MUCH more pro active as town back then, if he said 'we lynch A' then A was lynched.

Spyrex have you lost your powers or are you just a scummypants?

Sirdan is 100% town and I'm sad at how busy I've been that it took me this long to realize it.

You were unable to ever realize this in 2008. Are you able to realize it now because you're scum?

My lynch pool is Tierce and CES

How could I possibly lynch you? Your reads are so excellent. I don't

want

you to be scum

Hey guys
I have a (hypothetical of coursr) question
If I am a jailkeeper and theres a claimed cop
Do i jk him or not?

This is HORRIBLE HORRIBLE HORRIBLE and TERRIBAD.

[Elscouta]

WOOOOOOOOSH

VOTE: Albert B. Rampage


Weak Doctor + Cop/Vig + Half Cop. Yeah right.


Question. Was Majiffy killed, or did he suicide? First post suggests the latter.

The death flavors are different, so it implies different things killed them.

##Vote: JacobSavage

If we're going to point out the role that doesn't make sense, a Bodyguard and a Weak Doctor don't make sense in the same game. Also the kill is weird enough to suggest they're just trying to make him look like he should still be alive.

stop talking lol xD
I'll be posting for realz in the evening cuz I'm stupidly fat after eating at a family ceremony; and now I'm going to play basketball(gonna puke all over)..so after that.

Meanwhile, people should be voting Tierce; not ABR and definitely not shadoweh.
I'll explain later.

ABR: cop report, plox; I bet you've been blocked?

Tierce: show me those majiffy crumbs please?

I'll search for them later myself, but if you already have, please do tell

Well I take back my tierce scum decision. for the while.

ABR is confirmed town.
the Majiffy-targets-shadoweh crumb is enormous, and I'm definitely biting. it said 'THEY are quicklynching you' - not 'WE'; as in, he knew he's gonna die and we'll find it.

VOTE: Shadoweh.
After this one, I think CES is a very good scumdidate. The willingness to hit ABR after he said he was blocked(which I believe strongly) sounds to me like CES is scum, knew he was getting blocked, or jailkept, and tries to make town lynch him over that. it is also a wise decision - why kill someone when there's a wifom on him, and he is only even-night, so you can just block him whenever he manages to shoot?

so Shadoweh and then CES.

This needs to be explained. This is horrrrrrrrrrribly scummy, and couldn't be closer to "uh i was planning to defend my buddy by some claim, but I let a bit of time pass, and now i think that it was a bad idea. Let's forget about what I said, i'll bus properly". This whole jailkeeper thing and the "ABR Is confirmed town" feels horrible too.

Also, Jailkeeper + Weak Doc + Bodyguard?

--

ABR probably also needs to die. The only thing that kept him alive at end of day 2 was a dubious claim, and now he even admitted he lied about it.

[ActionDan]

No quick lunches just yet. The vca that I'll do is ripe. When I do it sometime

[Elscouta]

Also, i'm pretty sure we aren't in 2008 anymore.

[shos]

Interesting.

ABR needs to die.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

P.S. I wish I was scum with Tierce. I could day-neighborise her and everything.

[PeregrineV]

Back and reading.

[Desperado]

Vote: Albert B. Rampage

Sirdan is still scum and if Spy or Tierce or AD could explain why he's 100% town that would be great

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

You could just take our word for it?

[Albert B. Rampage]

You're lynching a VT.

[shos]

A VT who claimed cop and wasn't shot two nights in a row?

[Albert B. Rampage]

I don't see why this is so hard to believe. You need to stop what you're doing right now and change your mind.

[Albert B. Rampage]

It was really stupid to softclaim after I said I lied at the beginning of the day about being a PR.

[shos]

because if I were scum and you are town, I would either kill or block you on N2, and if you're still alive N3, then I wouldn't.

I know that is not what happened; so you're scum.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Vote: Albert B. Rampage

Sirdan is still scum and if Spy or Tierce or AD could explain why he's 100% town that would be great

What is this? Unvote me. You're being crazy.