Mini 1550 - Mean Girls Mafia: The Burn Blog -- Game Over!

[Aegor]

Votecount 1.4

[1]

Candillan:

Katarina LeBlanc
[4]

Hanzo_5:

xRECKONERx, Bicephalous Bob, Smudger, vezokpiraka
[1]

hiplop:

PrivateI
[3]

Katarina LeBlanc:

neil1113, Lord Mhork, Hanzo_5
[1]

Marquis:

Candillan
[1]

xRECKONERx:

Marquis,

[2]

Not Voting:

hiplop, Egg

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Day 1 deadline:

(expired on 2014-02-25 14:17:55) (25 February 2014)

Mod Notes

Remember to check out the Burn Blog! There are new posts.

Voting History

Spoiler:

Bicephalous Bob:

xRECKONERx, PrivateI, xRECKONERx, Hanzo_5

Candillan:

Marquis

Egg:

vezokpiraka, Katarina LeBlanc, Unvote

Hanzo_5:

xRECKONERx, Katarina LeBlanc

hiplop

Katarina LeBlanc:

Candillan

Lord Mhork:

Katarina LeBlanc

Marquis:

xRECKONERx

neil1113:

Katarina LeBlanc

PrivateI:

hiplop

Smudger:

xRECKONERx, Hanzo_5

vezokpiraka:

xRECKONERx, Hanzo_5

xRECKONERx:

vezokpiraka, Katarina LeBlanc, Marquis, Hanzo_5

[Aegor]

Serious and game-altering concerns about individual players should be brought to me directly by PM, not expressed in-thread. Thanks for your cooperation.

[Aegor]

I am conferring with the powers-that-be. I apologize for the thread being locked, but please be patient.

[Aegor]

Thread is now open. I will remind all players to READ THE RULES posted in this thread, including the site rules.

Discussing ongoing games is totally unacceptable and will not be tolerated under any circumstances.
Discussing this game outside of this thread and other sanctioned channels is totally unacceptable and will not be tolerated under any circumstances.
Any other serious or game-breaking infraction will not be tolerated either. This should be a fun game, and it will be, IF YOU FOLLOW THE RULES.

Any questions or concerns may be sent to me via PM; again, this thread is not the proper venue.

[PrivateI]

All right, let's get back to it.

So, I'm actually buying Hanzo's claim. In the movie, while Cady appeared to be a Mean Girl, she turned out to be the best of them, morally, but I can see how investigating her would show a mean girl still.

The problem is, it's really convenient as a claim, because the cop investigation can never be verified. What a dilemma.

Regardless, for today, I have no problem keeping Hanzo alive so long as we find someone more scummy. Speaking of which, Vezok, I don't really understand your vote on Hanzo. It seemed like you were jumping on an easy quicklynch, and that is not something I enjoy at all. With that in mind,

Vote: Vezok

[vezokpiraka]

privateI - I have serious reasons for this. I prefer not to divulge them unless I must.

[PrivateI]

Fair enough. I can give scum plenty of time to come up with a fakeclaim for unreasonable actions. Unless one of two things are your role:

You have to be the fourth vote on a lynch to get a super secret special power that is awesome,

Or you're a lyncher,

I don't like it.

[vezokpiraka]

Fair enough. I can give scum plenty of time to come up with a fakeclaim for unreasonable actions. Unless one of two things are your role:

You have to be the fourth vote on a lynch to get a super secret special power that is awesome,

Or you're a lyncher,

I don't like it.

I'm neither, but I have strong reasons to think that hanzo is scum.

[PrivateI]

All right. Whatever floats your boat. After that exchange, my vote is staying where it is.

[xRECKONERx]

So, I'm actually buying Hanzo's claim. In the movie, while Cady appeared to be a Mean Girl, she turned out to be the best of them, morally, but I can see how investigating her would show a mean girl still.

THE PROBLEM IS THAT I AM ONE OF THE 'MEAN GIRLS' AND AM TOWN.

[vezokpiraka]

Fair enough. I can give scum plenty of time to come up with a fakeclaim for unreasonable actions. Unless one of two things are your role:

You have to be the fourth vote on a lynch to get a super secret special power that is awesome,

Or you're a lyncher

,

I don't like it.

This game contains no Cults,

Lynchers/Lynchees

, Jesters, Survivors, or any other such roles.

Bolded for emphasis.

There are three posibilites:
1)You didn't read the rules properly.
2)You were trying to get a lyncher claim out of me or something?
3)You were trying to paint me bad by giving me only 2 very improbable possibilities.

I think that 3) is correct. If so I find that a scummy move. If you are scum with Hanzo (who I strongly believe is scum) you are trying to start a new wagon on an easy target.

[vezokpiraka]

So, I'm actually buying Hanzo's claim. In the movie, while Cady appeared to be a Mean Girl, she turned out to be the best of them, morally, but I can see how investigating her would show a mean girl still.

THE PROBLEM IS THAT I AM ONE OF THE 'MEAN GIRLS' AND AM TOWN.

For real?
Then hanzo is scum 99,9%( was 90 % before for me)

[xRECKONERx]

I'm assuming I'm remembering the movie correctly and that Karen Smith was one of the 'mean girls' right

[Marquis]

yes

in fact we should hold a movie watching party

[vezokpiraka]

yes

in fact we should hold a movie watching party

wow
such content
so scumhunting

[PrivateI]

Karen was the blond ditzy mean one, yes.

And Reck's claim adds a new wrinkle into things, which intrigues me.

[Marquis]

also i dont get whats so bad about hanzos claim i mean claiming the main character would automatically get you a lot of attention including negative like????? idk it seems too easily scum interpreted or distorted

pedit dogelindsaylohan.gif

[vezokpiraka]

Karen was the blond ditzy mean one, yes.

And Reck's claim adds a new wrinkle into things, which intrigues me.

There is no wrinkle. Hanzo is still scum.

[PrivateI]

also i dont get whats so bad about hanzos claim i mean claiming the main character would automatically get you a lot of attention including negative like????? idk it seems too easily scum interpreted or distorted

pedit dogelindsaylohan.gif

3rd the force replacement.

Does the Miller claim not ring true to you? I think if you are a Miller, it would be in your best interest to claim that early.

[vezokpiraka]

Does the Miller claim not ring true to you? I think if you are a Miller, it would be in your best interest to claim that early.

The miller claim does not ring true to me.

Even if he was a miller, I don't think claiming miller this early in the game is the best way to go about it. I am thinking that as a miller late day 1 or maybe not at all but try to attract a nightkill on you seems the best way to go about it.

[xRECKONERx]

Even if he was a miller, I don't think claiming miller this early in the game is the best way to go about it. I am thinking that as a miller late day 1 or maybe not at all but try to attract a nightkill on you seems the best way to go about it.

Claiming miller D1 is pretty standard play, actually.

[Marquis]

why would you not claim miller as early as possible, if they were really scum it restricts your ability to fakeclaim later on and as town it's like a warning to the investigative roles

i mean claiming miller this early if hanzo was scum has more drawbacks than benefits, see: the sudden wagon on him, with pressure drawn away from kat

hanzo is town even if he needs to explain his claim better imo

[vezokpiraka]

Even if he was a miller, I don't think claiming miller this early in the game is the best way to go about it. I am thinking that as a miller late day 1 or maybe not at all but try to attract a nightkill on you seems the best way to go about it.

Claiming miller D1 is pretty standard play, actually.

I know that. I was just saying what I would try to do. Also is claiming miller early D1 standard play or claiming mid or late D1 standard?

But do you agree that a miller claim should be more clear. Like: "I am a miller base on the flavor of my role PM and I am... " and not the way hanzo claimed?

[Marquis]

also claiming miller tends to draw policy lynches to you but can we not do that today

[Marquis]

also i dont get whats so bad about hanzos claim i mean claiming the main character would automatically get you a lot of attention including negative like????? idk it seems too easily scum interpreted or distorted

pedit dogelindsaylohan.gif

3rd the force replacement.

hi i was making a post