Xenosaga Mafia (Game Over)

[Cephrir]

Dan conspiracy. Why don't I have a cop result right now?

I can't tell if this is serious, but if it is, I can think of a possible reason.

[ActionDan]

U suck

[Kazekirimaru]

What I'm wondering is, why did pie die instead of sangres last night?

Simple answer: Because Pie protected Sangres again???????????????????

AP Conspiracy answer: Mafia team thought Pie was just a doctor after having failed to kill Sangres so they targeted her (her BP already being gone)?

But he was only a 1-shot...

...wait.

now I see the problem.

[Angry Frat BROs]

1 Shot bulletproof you dunce.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: SkullDuggery

No whammies, no whammies

[Kazekirimaru]

1 Shot bulletproof you dunce.

I read it wrong. Hush. >:

[Cephrir]

U suck

(It could easily be something else, but it sounds like you know)

[macmollie]

Do you have anyone as a potential SK?

Nope! Not a damn clue. Don't know, don't particularly care, either. The SK's clearly not someone who'd be wise to leash (both sources of kills have been tremendously anti-town), so they're basically an extra scumbag, just one without interactive tells. I'll scumhunt and maybe catch them, but I'm not going to discriminate and hunt specifically for them.

oh hell no mastina you are always banging on about how leashing the sk is always good for town

VOTE: mastina

[macmollie]

AP GET IN HERE PLZ ASAP!!!!

[Angry Frat BROs]

AP GET IN HERE PLZ ASAP!!!!

You rang?

[macmollie]

Alright, I've self-loathed enough. I'll get back on this.

So, disregard everything despondentKaze said yesterday. I don't want to poke at ActionDan at all.

SSK claimed tracker, eh?

So, I was thinking about something this morning regarding the watch results and the nightkills.

Cabd, SSK, pie, and Dan all targeted sangres Night 1.

pie claimed Bodyguard, and Cabd claimed watcher(which got us results). Both of them flipped Town last night.

What I'm wondering is, why did pie die instead of sangres last night? Cabd I get, but the other kill looks odd to me. pie was essentially a VT after the save, and killing him only really served to help validate the "someone NK-targeted sangres N1" theory(especially since pie was 1-shot bulletproof). Killing sangres would have left us with pie, SSK, and Dan alive to duke it out and cause more chaos today, which sounds like a better position for any anti-town role to hide in.

The only explanation I can think of is that pie was 100% without-a-doubt an SK kill and the SK is trying to direct attention to the group that targeted sangres N1. This further leads me to believe that the SK is definitely outside of the aforementioned group - probably someone who has kept their distance from the situation.

But, anyway, can someone explain to me how they're even entertaining the idea that none of the group is scum? pie, a 1-shot BP bodyguard who targeted sangres N1, is now dead. Cabd is dead. One of SSK or Dan had to have targeted them with a NK. (I know there's a theory floating around that none of them NK'd sangres and a Scum Ninja is to blame - but Occam's Razor won't let me entertain that idea.)

So, are we waiting for a tracker CC or what? Because I'm at a loss as to the direction this game is going.

I WAS WONDERING IF HOW PIE'S ROLE WORKED AND IF HE WAS SHOT N1 BUT THE BULLETPROOF PROTECTED HIM AND THEN HE SAVED SOME1 LAST NIGHT WHOM SCUM TARGETED IS THAT NOT HOW THAT ROLE WORKS

[Angry Frat BROs]

also skull is uber town!!1!

Thank you, but unfortunately, the feeling isn't mutual. I'm still waiting for you to impress me, Mollie!

Mollie why does this quote make me

[macmollie]

whoops caps lock

@ AP

thoughts on mastina plz

eta: cos you are being retarded

[Angry Frat BROs]

I WAS WONDERING IF HOW PIE'S ROLE WORKED AND IF HE WAS SHOT N1 BUT THE BULLETPROOF PROTECTED HIM AND THEN HE SAVED SOME1 LAST NIGHT WHOM SCUM TARGETED IS THAT NOT HOW THAT ROLE WORKS

Pie was definitely shot on N1 and 2. Well ALMOST definitely. The question is did her

target

get shot or did she get shot?

P-edit: mastina is sketchy. Not sure if I want to lynch, but sketchy. Feels too not-manipulative to be mafia? Maybe a lurkaderp SK trying to avoid night kills?

[Angry Frat BROs]

Skull doesn't feel a bit..forced there?

I dunno, it would help if I actually put my nose to the grindstone in this game, but that Skull quote feels super awkward.

[macmollie]

my thing is, is that mastina has consistently held the position that sks ought to be leashed and that they should be given a chance. he doesn't even know who they are and already he is like ACK! ACK! LYNCH THE SK ARGGGHHHH!!!

^ does NOT sound like the mastina that I know

@ muffina

I noticed that all you are doing is sheeping nacho who isn't the 1 you have been dealing btw and not doing shit on your own wats up wif dat

[Cephrir]

Feels too not-manipulative to be mafia?

which mastin posts have /you/ been reading?

[Angry Frat BROs]

my thing is, is that mastina has consistently held the position that sks ought to be leashed and that they should be given a chance. he doesn't even know who they are and already he is like ACK! ACK! LYNCH THE SK ARGGGHHHH!!!

Uhhhhhhhhh?

1. We don't have any idea who the SK is (maybe mafiaSSK, but even then thats not a great lead).
2. Mastin's point that there is no reason to SK-hunt is totally valid; if there were a claimed SK or obvious/confirmed SK, I could see him actually caring.
3. Except hes not saying "lets lynch the SK?". He is saying "the SK is whatever, lets just lynch scum"

[macmollie]

Skull doesn't feel a bit..forced there?

I dunno, it would help if I actually put my nose to the grindstone in this game, but that Skull quote feels super awkward.

honestly I can't read skull worth shit I thought she was scum in both 2 rooms and xeno2. she was moaning about being the lynch today in the neighborhood last night I would think if she were town she would here getting her last licks in and scumhunting like a mo fo but she isn't doing that. I thought her posts looked very town on d1 similar to how she was in 2 rooms altho not with the analysis but the set up is different

[Angry Frat BROs]

I think Im mostly amused that Skull is thanking Mollie for townreading her

Ffery, where you at.

[Angry Frat BROs]

Feels too not-manipulative to be mafia?

which mastin posts have /you/ been reading?

The ones where she votes Flandre, unvotes Flandre and says some crap about wagons, lurks, then calls SSK town for ~reasons~ that amount to gut.

Basically mastina is like trying to look intentionally scummy? IDGI.

[ActionDan]

No one shoots a bodyguard.

They shoot town people they don't know the roles of.

this is.

mafia 101.

[Angry Frat BROs]

Mollie's reason for scumreading mastin feels a bit off. The whole "mastin would leash an SK" argument feels largely irrelevant in the current game state and mastin's spiel about SKs in this game felt legit to me more than anything else shes said.

Mollie you aren't trying to get suspicion started in mastina's direction are you?

Skull/Mollie?

P-edit: I guess, but shooting a BG is like putting one in the bank so when the Cop claims, you dont have any obstacles. Not saying I 100% believe Pie was shot, but its possible. Its possible someone Docgtor read her after the kill failed and she was still alive.

[sangres]

I think Im mostly amused that Skull is thanking Mollie for townreading her

Ffery, where you at.

o hai

[sangres]

pie is a guy.

[borkjerfkin]

srgwerfvgsdcasdsdf234whtrhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh44444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444