Mini 1543--Natirasha's On Parole!(Game Over)

[Selkies]

No I don't, he is tough to read.

And you are not terrible at catching scum-nacho. That's a bold-faced fib.

I haven't caught him and held onto the read since buzzword bingo.

[Bert]

You have enough past analysis that you've already done so that you can't classify it as anything less than adequate

[Cabd]

With our supposed protective AND me out, I'm kind of tempted to say we should popcorn massclaim.

[Selkies]

ffs Bert.

Learn to read me.

Ffs you said this in 1526 so don't give me that

I said something similar. I don't think there was any real bite to it. I don't really get annoyed at someone for being right. I get annoyed at myself for being obviously scum.

That's not what's happening here.

[Selkies]

You have enough past analysis that you've already done so that you can't classify it as anything less than adequate

Proof is in the pudding.

[Bert]

Everything Nacho has posted can be easily faked, so until he starts revving up he's actually null so you're right in a sense

Circle-jerking and fluff for him are all null

[Bert]

Last night I had a daydream about a notsci-IK pairing

Notsci u listed IK as a scumread but never explained. Explain

[Bert]

IK's D1 "I hate to say this but notsci is prob town" was soooo weird considering his stances about policy lynches and new posting styles (tirade)

Soz spammed 3 posts on phone, I'll dig back later

[Nachomamma8]

And here is where I start to have a fucking problem with everything:
STOP FUCKING SAYING THAT LURKING IS SCUMMY BUT WHEN I POST A LOT SAY THAT I'M ScuMMY TOO. Fucking stop.

i never said that lurking was scummy
i just said it wasn't town

So then why vote me?

Because everyone else has reasons for why they could possibly be town

[Nachomamma8]

Wow.

Who are your scumreads, SSK?

Selkies, somewhat you, and recently I could see how Goodfather could be scum.

why

Selkies because I feel like they could really be playing on an apathetic town.

Aronis because he hasn't really seemed to have any meaningful content, just fluff.
Goodfather, because his reasons are all bs and he seems to do a lot of bandwagon hopping.

Why?
Why are Goodfather's reasons bullshit?

[Nachomamma8]

Thoughts on Cabd's claim- It makes me feel town, but I pretty much suck at reading Cabd so :L

Thoughts on SSK- I'm a sucker for AtE flipouts. He was softing kinda hard and now that he's claimed I'm tempted to believe it. That being said, I need to know-

Bert

did SSK do a huge flipout before he fakeclaimed in the one game?

Nacho

Why are you townreading Cabd? (yes I know I have him as a townlean but I'm not really confident in it)

Aronis's recent post makes me think that there's no shot in hell him and Katsuki are a scumteam (why would he post that rather than berate her in the QT?)

I'm not really sure who I want to vote currently. I have as town-

Katsuki
Bert
SSK (depending on Bert's response)

And everyone else is kinda in a pool of townlean-scumlean.

I mean now there's the really good and confirm able vig claim thing so

[Nachomamma8]

See, this is what happens when people go so far against policy lynching. It encourages people to just not play, period. You can't kill them, because then you're not scumhunting, which means they aren't incentive to play any harder. Which means you can't get any reads on them, which means you CAN'T scumhunt. It effectively limits the town's targets to people who are active, giving people who AREN'T active a free pass. That just sucks the life right out of Mafia. I don't care if the meta changes, I don't care if people start looking for different kinds of tells, THIS is the real scourge of MafiaScum, and it will kill the game.

As it sits, we would not be able to get a good read of Katsuki's play until D4 or D5.

This is bullshit.

That's entirely too late in the game, because we'll be focusing on everybody else. So a policy lynch/policy vig is our ONLY way to avoid that. Sure, it may be sub-optimal for any given game, but in the aggregate it would improve the play quality of the site as a whole. So for heaven's sake, Cabd, shoot Katsuki.

I don't think getting lynched a lot makes people play more
For example, look at SSK,

[Nachomamma8]

I don't really see real effort, Katsuki. You're acting like people are lynching you because of everything you do, and that's so not true. Plus you've been saying you'll get to the game eventually, and then you are here but you don't get to the actual game and catching up.

To start with I would like reasons as to why you think Goodfather, Selkies and whomever are scum. And please stop mentioning that you won a scummy for whatever, because this is a new slate and a new game and your past doesn't qualify you for special treatment in this game. cos every time someone asks you something, you have a stalling answer that puts yourself in a bad light

if there's anything scummy about your play today, it's the tone/attitude you have when being pressed for information.

:effort: =\= town
Lack of :effort: =\= scum
Open your eyes, Berty.

[Nachomamma8]

Hello all
someone fill me in on important stuff pls... 70 pages is a lot to read

There's a three man neighborhood; I'm a compulsive night two vig that plans on shooting your slot unless you obvtown it up, and SSK claimed doctor.

shooting that slot would be dumb

[Nachomamma8]

I'm liking Guyett so far.

Nacho's kinda bugging me. I keep pushing scary thoughts away, but I don't have a good read there.

why am I bugging them?
why aren't you airing your scary thoughts?

[Bert]

Go to pooperville

[Bert]

It's where the Bellagio is

[Nachomamma8]

Everything Nacho has posted can be easily faked, so until he starts revving up he's actually null so you're right in a sense

Circle-jerking and fluff for him are all null

I thought it was a towntell?

[Bert]

I don't really see real effort, Katsuki. You're acting like people are lynching you because of everything you do, and that's so not true. Plus you've been saying you'll get to the game eventually, and then you are here but you don't get to the actual game and catching up.

To start with I would like reasons as to why you think Goodfather, Selkies and whomever are scum. And please stop mentioning that you won a scummy for whatever, because this is a new slate and a new game and your past doesn't qualify you for special treatment in this game. cos every time someone asks you something, you have a stalling answer that puts yourself in a bad light

if there's anything scummy about your play today, it's the tone/attitude you have when being pressed for information.

:effort: =\= town
Lack of :effort: =\= scum
Open your eyes, Berty.

Ffery is obvscum

ALSo notice I stuck with Kafsuki as town read all game never wavered

[Bert]

Everything Nacho has posted can be easily faked, so until he starts revving up he's actually null so you're right in a sense

Circle-jerking and fluff for him are all null

I thought it was a towntell?

No u r too good so it's null

but I'm trying to be normal this game hahaha bugga and try to look at ur play

[Bert]

Everyone give nacho a round of applause

Cos today I bought a blanco nacho and extreme nachos from a chicken wing place for the table

[Nachomamma8]

Everything Nacho has posted can be easily faked, so until he starts revving up he's actually null so you're right in a sense

Circle-jerking and fluff for him are all null

I thought it was a towntell?

No u r too good so it's null

but I'm trying to be normal this game hahaha bugga and try to look at ur play

Then why is efforting a town tell for me?

[Bert]

It's not

But the more content u have the ezer it is to read u

Doy ma boi

[Bert]

Dun misrep me

Effort = ezer to read

Get the picture bub from stub hub

[Nachomamma8]

Why does more content make me easier to read?