Newbie 1476 - Game Over

[RachMarie]

no argument from me on that notty, mutt feels town to me.

[serrapaladin]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT 1.02

Zivel (2) - notscience, goodmorning
Luca Blight (2) - Not_Mafia, burn_209
notscience (2) - RachMarie, Zivel
burn_209 (1) - Luca Blight

Not Voting (2) - Graeyfurredmutt, joker443

With 9 alive, it's 5 to lynch.

The deadline for Day 1 is in (expired on 2014-03-01 23:59:59).

[burn_209]

What about mutts post makes you feel like he is town? It seems to me a lot of what he has posted are common sense inquiries that anyone could have came up with. Definitely nothing to me that could be considered as a scum or town feel.

[notscience]

GM I lied I want to wagon burn

VOTE: burn

[notscience]

What would the mafia do today. My assumption is that they would naturally want to just let the town make a wild guess and hit a townie so as to attract minimal attention to themselves. The more active and obvious someone is the easier it is to analyze them and find the small hints. So that would leave us with a question of what are they actually doing. I personally prefer as mafia to have the group be diverse. While being just helpful enough to not look bad and just quiet enough to not be obvious is probably the safest, assuming people don't look there first due to anticipating strategies, it's not the most useful. Being a leader of the town can be quite profitable for the mafia. So what do you think?

Scum would not come right out and say this and be this transparent

[Graeyfurredmutt]

What I'm trying to do is to increase discussion so we have some data to go off of, this is innately town positive in my opinion (which is why I'm doing it by the way) however it wouldn't be that hard to do town positive things as a mafia it just has more risk involved. I'm assuming any reads stated so far are very hazy do to our lack of information. I do however notice that no one has actually responded to the content of my post.

[notscience]

What mafia do varies by the person.

Some people go high-risk high-reward (Cabd is an example, the dude gambits like a motherfucker and it pays off in dividends)

Some go low-risk (I do that, I try to stay in townreads and don't worry about who gets lynched)

Overall it's a variety of paystyle. Trying to find one central thing that all scum do is like trying to find a flavor of ice cream everyone will like

[Graeyfurredmutt]

What do you tend to do as mafia? I originally tended to be on the lurker side of things when I first played mostly because I had no idea what to say but with more experience I would try to be a "contributing" if somewhat unimportant member of town.

[RachMarie]

No member of town is unimportant, Mutt. Numbers and our votes and our discussion is our advantages over scum.

[joker443]

/confirm
Sorry only just got the message game had started lol
These early assumptions already are quite entertaining

[joker443]

Been in one game with Gm so know quite well how they play but may be different this time

[notscience]

What do you tend to do as mafia? I originally tended to be on the lurker side of things when I first played mostly because I had no idea what to say but with more experience I would try to be a "contributing" if somewhat unimportant member of town.

My goal as mafia is to emulate my town meta.

I have apathy issues occasionally, and it really shines through with my mafia side so much that I will just keep prod dodging

[Not_Mafia]

If someone slips describing their own scum meta then policy hammer them immediately.

I'll jump on this burn wagon,let's get to L-1

UNVOTE: Luca Blight
VOTE: burn_209

[notscience]

UNVOTE:

Don't want any derphammers.

What do you mean slips describing their scum meta?

[Not_Mafia]

Derphammer is a risk I guess but the people here seem to be of a higher stndard

I was kinda being facetious with that comment. For instance if I said something like "As town I am really quiet and one of the least frequent posters but as scum I like to lead wagons and post a lot". I should be policy lynched for stupidity

[Not_Mafia]

But yeah, I haven't actually been scum yet. But I would just try to play my town meta as best as I could. i.e stay active and try to pressure on multiple people.

[joker443]

Sounds like a play not mafia

[joker443]

Plan that was meant to say btw

[burn_209]

UNVOTE:

Don't want any derphammers.

What do you mean slips describing their scum meta?

I like this post.

Town points for you

Derphammer is a risk I guess but the people here seem to be of a higher stndard

This one not so much. Justifying the risk on the derphammer on a judgement call that in a NEWBIE game, that we are 3 pages into, that we have players here that are a higher standard isnt very smart. But hey one vote is always one vote closer to a townie lynch right scum?

VOTE: NOT MAFIA

[Zivel]

So let me try this reading thing out.... I want a look at NoSci:

So quickly starting wagons and trying to get one going so early seems very scum to me... is it not a strat to try and get a wagon going and hope that it goes all the way? Seems logical and especially with a newb game where votes might fly easily. This makes sense to me, and has NoSci not tried to do this twice now, bailing on the last one could be a bluff, letting the wagon get some more speed before then pushing it over the top.

Also the idea of a Newb flailing is interesting. This will give a lot of information and could be entertaining to watch but surely if that person is town the Mafia know this and then they know that the info wont help the townies to much, but might allow a mafia lynch.

Now I honestly have no idea what I am doing but hey, its better have stabs in the dark than no stabs at all right?

[Zivel]

Edit by way of post... just realised its NotSci not NoSci sorry....

[Not_Mafia]

This one not so much. Justifying the risk on the derphammer on a judgement call that in a NEWBIE game, that we are 3 pages into, that we have players here that are a higher standard isnt very smart. But hey one vote is always one vote closer to a townie lynch right scum?

VOTE: NOT MAFIA

You were on L-2 after my vote so there was hardly a massive risk, nice omgus now that the wagon is focused on you

-

FTFY

[Not_Mafia]

I fail at quoting

[joker443]

Zivel this has happened the first game I was in never gets anyone lynched lol

[serrapaladin]

bump