You mean the posts in which he continues to push a crappy case based on things that aren't scummy, and cherry picks through the posts that are convenient to said case instead of doing proper analysis?In post 1971, ActionDan wrote:Ok I thought his last posts might have changed your mind.
VOTE: tierce
Weren't you reading the day during the night and saw the only obvious conclusion that Shadoweh was scum? Why on earth would she have otherwise flipped to me in such a scummy way?In post 1966, Tierce wrote:Because it was not the "only obvious conclusion". Her behavior around the D2 deadline looked Town.In post 1964, sirdanilot wrote:I am talking about day 3, not day 2. If you reread the events on day 2 the only obvious conclusion was that Shadoweh was scum.
Why did you not see that immediately?
Still not changin my vote, and you're getting awful close to a lynch, so why not just answer?
Difficult to get that from my posts, I know, must be the whole GOD(DESS) TALK that you're not able to decipher.
D3 started. I voted my main suspect, then went back and looked at Natirasha and Majiffy's posts. I should have used my goddess powers to travel back in time and discover the crumb before Plum even posted Majiffy's flip. Will do so next time, thanks for the notice! ^_^
I didn't arrive until after you had posted the crumb thing.You don't mention her again until D3, where you vote her after I reveal Majiffy's crumb. So tell me again how Shadoweh was so obvious scum that I should have time-traveled to be able to spot it before I went through Majiffy's ISO on D3?
This is terribad because of several reasons.In post 1972, shos wrote:VOTE: sirdan
That is a product of poe.
Mostly townreads,peoplei want to keep alive, and well tierces poats yhis page are overwhelming for scum.
Ill admit i have yet to win as town against tierce, though. Dat gurl touches me deep.
What are you, 12?In post 1979, sirdanilot wrote:1. It is not properly typed, I do not understand what on earth 'Mostly townreads,peoplei want to keep alive, and well tierces poats yhis page are overwhelming for scum.' means
It's only bussing if there's a corpse. I've already established that by the time she followed you on to sirdan, a NL was imminent. Following a town leader on to a scum wagon that you know will never come to fruition is a high-upside, no risk decision to make as scum.In post 1961, Tierce wrote:Desperado: I don't think Shadoweh was bussing at the end of D2. It's much easier to see the interaction between her and ActionDan at that point as scum theater (including the whole "why isn't sirdanilot around to protest his lynch at 4:30 am!" between them) than her jump on the wagon at my behest (oooh, fancy vocabulary, it's evidence of all my Amazon goddess powers) on her scumbuddy, when we know she could easily pretend to be asleep instead of bussing.
Majiffy was around and posting elsewhere. There was plenty of risk.In post 1981, Desperado wrote:It's only bussing if there's a corpse. I've already established that by the time she followed you on to sirdan, a NL was imminent. Following a town leader on to a scum wagon that you know will never come to fruition is a high-upside, no risk decision to make as scum.In post 1961, Tierce wrote:Desperado: I don't think Shadoweh was bussing at the end of D2. It's much easier to see the interaction between her and ActionDan at that point as scum theater (including the whole "why isn't sirdanilot around to protest his lynch at 4:30 am!" between them) than her jump on the wagon at my behest (oooh, fancy vocabulary, it's evidence of all my Amazon goddess powers) on her scumbuddy, when we know she could easily pretend to be asleep instead of bussing.
Everyone and their mother has said that compromising on you at deadline is not scummy. YOU compromised on me because there was no time to get a wagon elsewhere, so don't start that shitty argument again because if you are Town you should know deadline switches to avoid no-lynches are not scummy, even if they fall in your royally super duper obvTown Highnass. She didn't look like scum, so I voted her when I found the actual evidence against her.In post 1979, sirdanilot wrote:Weren't you reading the day during the night and saw the only obvious conclusion that Shadoweh was scum? Why on earth would she have otherwise flipped to me in such a scummy way?In post 1966, Tierce wrote:Because it was not the "only obvious conclusion". Her behavior around the D2 deadline looked Town.In post 1964, sirdanilot wrote:I am talking about day 3, not day 2. If you reread the events on day 2 the only obvious conclusion was that Shadoweh was scum.
Why did you not see that immediately?
Still not changin my vote, and you're getting awful close to a lynch, so why not just answer?
Des, then the same question goes for you on how that case comes from Town.
Difficult to get that from my posts, I know, must be the whole GOD(DESS) TALK that you're not able to decipher.
D3 started. I voted my main suspect, then went back and looked at Natirasha and Majiffy's posts. I should have used my goddess powers to travel back in time and discover the crumb before Plum even posted Majiffy's flip. Will do so next time, thanks for the notice! ^_^
I am not going to argue with you that I read shadoweh kinda town up to and including day 2. Congrats. But as soon as I read the events resulting in the no lynch, it was extremely obvious to me that shadoweh was scum.
Everyone and their mother has said that compromising on you at deadline is not scummy. YOU compromised on me because there was no time to get a wagon elsewhere, so don't start that shitty argument again because if you are Town you should know deadline switches to avoid no-lynches are not scummy, even if they fall in your royally super duper obvTown Highnass. She didn't look like scum, so I voted her when I found the actual evidence against her.In post 1979, sirdanilot wrote:Weren't you reading the day during the night and saw the only obvious conclusion that Shadoweh was scum? Why on earth would she have otherwise flipped to me in such a scummy way?In post 1966, Tierce wrote:Because it was not the "only obvious conclusion". Her behavior around the D2 deadline looked Town.In post 1964, sirdanilot wrote:I am talking about day 3, not day 2. If you reread the events on day 2 the only obvious conclusion was that Shadoweh was scum.
Why did you not see that immediately?
Still not changin my vote, and you're getting awful close to a lynch, so why not just answer?
Difficult to get that from my posts, I know, must be the whole GOD(DESS) TALK that you're not able to decipher.
D3 started. I voted my main suspect, then went back and looked at Natirasha and Majiffy's posts. I should have used my goddess powers to travel back in time and discover the crumb before Plum even posted Majiffy's flip. Will do so next time, thanks for the notice! ^_^
I am not going to argue with you that I read shadoweh kinda town up to and including day 2. Congrats. But as soon as I read the events resulting in the no lynch, it was extremely obvious to me that shadoweh was scum.
1. I was obvtown (and am epecially since the shadoweh flip); you were not. She firmly townread me throughout the entire game, she assumed I was town. And she was right in doing so of course. Her flip made no sense. She could have also flipped to you, but she didn't.tierce wrote:Everyone and their mother has said that compromising on you at deadline is not scummy. YOU compromised on me because there was no time to get a wagon elsewhere, so don't start that shitty argument again because if you are Town you should know deadline switches to avoid no-lynches are not scummy, even if they fall in your royally super duper obvTown Highnass. She didn't look like scum, so I voted her when I found the actual evidence against her.
Show me proper analysis.In post 1975, Tierce wrote:You mean the posts in which he continues to push a crappy case based on things that aren't scummy, and cherry picks through the posts that are convenient to said case instead of doing proper analysis?In post 1971, ActionDan wrote:Ok I thought his last posts might have changed your mind.
VOTE: tierce
Tell me who is scum in 2 scenarios.In post 1988, sirdanilot wrote:1. I was obvtown (and am epecially since the shadoweh flip); you were not. She firmly townread me throughout the entire game, she assumed I was town. And she was right in doing so of course. Her flip made no sense. She could have also flipped to you, but she didn't.tierce wrote:Everyone and their mother has said that compromising on you at deadline is not scummy. YOU compromised on me because there was no time to get a wagon elsewhere, so don't start that shitty argument again because if you are Town you should know deadline switches to avoid no-lynches are not scummy, even if they fall in your royally super duper obvTown Highnass. She didn't look like scum, so I voted her when I found the actual evidence against her.
2. The way in which she did it does not ring like a 'meh I still think sirdan is town but I want to lynch him anyway'to me. It rang like she was fabricating a scumread on me to get away with it. You, as the selft proclaimed mafiascum goddess should have spotted that.
No clue. Only one saying it is Teirce (unless I missed something and someone wants to point out their CES townread.)In post 1992, sirdanilot wrote:I have no idea. I read CES as scum for the most part, but now there's talk of him being town? Why is this?
Esp scumread is kinda independent from Tierce.
If Desp were scum WITH Tierce, then he eitherI would guess desp and tierce make a good pairing?
In post 1994, Elscouta wrote:Is it the usual town meta of PV to stay on the sidelines for 4 days, then suddenly launch a crusade on day 5?
Currently investigating the dead QTs of scum-Tierce.
Espeonage wrote:We have a spare phase, I don't see why we shouldn't lynch Tierce here.
