Left 4 Dead Mafia! (Game Over!)

[GuyInFreezer]

Didn't we just go over about how my aggressiveness, lack thereof, laziness, etc. is neither a towntell nor a scumtell? Jesus.

Whatever, I'll let it ride for a while.

There is one more reason I'm townreading you other than that, but I'm not posting it here yet because I could be too hasty on this one.

What do you think about his post where he continued the "I'm scum hurr hurr" argument that looks an awful lot like towncred-fishing to me?

It didn't look forced to be "hur hur gimme towncred" posts.

Feel free to plaec voat.

But then if I do I might anger papa smurf :<

[BBmolla]

AP your townread on PV bugs me, he's the lurking scum, the other scum are probably big names.

[Rubicon]

Mastin needs to be lynched fucking yesterday. I want her dead as soon as is physically possible. If anyone is a dayvig please take care of this, thank you. Unless ActionDan said something super awesome during the downtime he's probably scum. Majiffy is also a mild scum read for me. There was someone else who seemed scum in the lost posts but I'm gonna have to wait until those come back.

Red Coyote is town.

[Majiffy]

pidgey is prob town for his "lol heres my reads withallth ese typos aye wat your post makes no fuckin sense Im startin to scum read you bro" or whatever. Feels enough like unconcerned town to make me like him.

so all I have to do is start posting with typos for the rest of the game whilst making hollow assertions and you'll call me town too?

Works for Kanye.

[Rubicon]

also

1. Rubicon's post is a scum-claim because he was questioning someone having town reads in a group of players that contained him.

You still think this? I don't want to be all confirmation-bias here, but I feel like the people who keep saying this are trying to discredit a reasonable point about BBmolla. Go look at what me/Aegor had actually posted when BBmolla said that and consider whether me wondering why BBmolla assumed there was town in the group might raise warning bells. It's not whether

I

know there's town in the group, it's whether he can reasonably make that assumption.

[sekai no ki]

They may not all be shit reads. I've lost patience trying to figure out where your reads are coming from, though, and you're abysmally wrong about me, and getting more wrong over time.

I dunno, I thought I've been pretty transparent all game and explaining things more than usual. Just ask Thor and RC.

Explained doesn't equate to "makes sense to me".

Also you've moved transparently but with zero connect the dots from "null-maybe-scum but some posts feel kinda town" to die-in-a-fire scum on me in the space of about 24 hours.

And I'll say once again - I'm not scumreading you for it. But it gives me zero confidence that you're generally firing on all cylinders here.

[mastin2]

1) GIF has provided reasoning for at least a few of these (if not in this exact post).

Not enough for them to be where they are, especially me.

2) So why didn't you bold Vezok (obvious town) and Bulbazak (probtown) who GIF managed to misplace.

Actually, I almost bolded Bulbazak, but then ultimately decided that he could legitimately have Bulb there. The reason isn't because his reads aren't the same as me. It's that the reads aren't where they should be from his content on them. His posting has been that I've been town (albeit for crappy reasons), so I can be town, but top-tiered town? Hell no, that's a faked read. Same for the others.

Somewhat explains the next one, too.

Molla is townreading you for no adequately explored reason but hes SO FREAKING TOWN according to you.

Yes, because I can understand Molla's townread on me. He hasn't made his reasoning explicit, but he doesn't need to in order for me to get it. GiF, on the other hand, hasn't done that.

[Majiffy]

It didn't look forced to be "hur hur gimme towncred" posts.

Guess I better bus.

Unvote;
Vote: Aegor

In context, this is unquestionably a towncred fish. Click the link, read back from the page before.

Feel free to plaec voat.

But then if I do I might anger papa smurf :<

Papa Smurf can stuff it.

[AngryPidgeon]

AP your townread on PV bugs me, he's the lurking scum, the other scum are probably big names.

pidgey is the lurking scum IMO.
I'm willing to talk about PV though.

[mastin2]

Mastin needs to be lynched fucking yesterday. I want her dead as soon as is physically possible. If anyone is a dayvig please take care of this, thank you. Unless ActionDan said something super awesome during the downtime he's probably scum. Majiffy is also a mild scum read for me. There was someone else who seemed scum in the lost posts but I'm gonna have to wait until those come back.

Question, since I don't actually know Rubicon that well. How fond of bussing is Rubicon?

[Rubicon]

Z, I'm still curious why you read BBmolla as town. I'm open to the idea, but there doesn't really seem to be anything in his ISO to point that direction.

[Majiffy]

AP your townread on PV bugs me, he's the lurking scum, the other scum are probably big names.

pidgey is the lurking scum IMO.

Yesplz.

[AngryPidgeon]

Yes, because I can understand Molla's townread on me. He hasn't made his reasoning explicit, but he doesn't need to in order for me to get it. GiF, on the other hand, hasn't done that.

Spoiler: Mastin in this game

[dopog]

Hey, back. : )

Not really seeing redcoyote just getting townread out of the wall, especailly inner circled by AP if reasons are same as @ this post

Welcome to the game, RC! RC is town (call it gut for now).

Further I'm definitely not seeing Peregrine town.
Remember skimming a couple posts of his before the downtime and seems like he's just coming up with arbitrary positions / no positions on other players and he was talking about waiting for the scum to out themselves. Read like scum non-contributing, but maintaining pc.

p-edit: bb's reading more town of late to me @

AP your townread on PV bugs me, he's the lurking scum, the other scum are probably big names.

Also another thing I read just before they popped me with the local was bulba questioning peeps who were scumreading me (sven, jiffy iirc) and just trying to nut out in my thoughts were he's coming from with all his stuff.

Yeah

[Rubicon]

I'm going to put my vote here for now:

VOTE: majiffy

[AngryPidgeon]

Mastin needs to be lynched fucking yesterday. I want her dead as soon as is physically possible. If anyone is a dayvig please take care of this, thank you. Unless ActionDan said something super awesome during the downtime he's probably scum. Majiffy is also a mild scum read for me. There was someone else who seemed scum in the lost posts but I'm gonna have to wait until those come back.

Red Coyote is town.

Your application for the Townblock has been received and is being rpocessed, thank you for your consideration!

[pidgey]

My reads are boring but they are what they are and if i ever flip youll see im true to them. Also its day 1 so they will obviously change.

And no i didnt mention it for the sake of it, especificay noticing that conversation made me weary of sven, who is slightly scummy now.

Also he might be sticking his neck to either defend scum or defend a scummy player, either of i feel is possible (regardn bbmole)

[mastin2]

Your application for the Townblock has been received and is being rpocessed, thank you for your consideration!

I'm actually open to that, too, if I get a good answer on Rubicon. He basically named all of my strongest scumreads in his scum list, so either he's a powerbusser or my read on him and/or the others is wrong.

[Majiffy]

I'm going to put my vote here for now:

VOTE: majiffy

u r dum dum

[pidgey]

Lol fuck you Ap you are probably fkn scum your case on me is "o he has easy targets" what the fuck is that shit and why are they easy no one is even moving their votes to them

[Zdenek]

You spend this entire post talking about Bulb and then you vote Pere? Why didn't you mention anything about Pere? This vote is really awkward.

If one of them flipped scum, I would instantly lynch the other.

[GuyInFreezer]

Lol fuck you Ap you are probably fkn scum your case on me is "o he has easy targets" what the fuck is that shit and why are they easy no one is even moving their votes to them

In case ppl are doubting pidgey town

[Zdenek]

Z, I'm still curious why you read BBmolla as town. I'm open to the idea, but there doesn't really seem to be anything in his ISO to point that direction.

I said why, at least earlier in the game. I've haven't really thought about him since. I'll get back to you when I'm done reading.

[Majiffy]

Lol fuck you Ap you are probably fkn scum your case on me is "o he has easy targets" what the fuck is that shit and why are they easy no one is even moving their votes to them

In case ppl are doubting pidgey town

What's so town about this?

[sekai no ki]

@AP

Do you remember this post?

I'm a little wary about townreading the hell out of redcoyote again on the basis of an awesome catch-up post.