In post 2769, Selkies wrote:I think we probably are all together. It's hard to call Nacho for sure due to not a lot of data.
Meant you and Cabd as a scumteam potentially. Cabd tossing that theory of me-scum out because of the lack of a NK is just like tossing out random stuff to see if it goes well with others, and that's while seeming to have no other real suspicions of his own today.
I also wish he had revealed what his intentions were during the steps he took during that super-awkward "dance." Doesn't it seem really inconclusive?
In post 2759, Guyett wrote:I've already PoE'd the game down.... I'm extremely confident in nacho flipping scum and would like selkies flipped to analyse do some good VCA
So don't you figure for a Day 3, it'd be beneficial to find out about the neighbors before lylo? Aka lynch Aronis?
coz my tinfoil theory here is that you no killed because (a) you're not actually a vig, and you can claim roleblocked, and (b) mafiassk was going to protect you so you can claim "lol obv i was protected no other explanation makes sense"
and i don't feel too good about selkies / nacho for entirely separate reasons (partially because others look more town, partially because gut twinges) so i lie awake at night staring at the ceiling thinking, "hmmmmm something doesn't make sense here"
i also don't really get why ffery is confident nacho is town here - or not confident, but at least thinks it's the case (with minimal interaction, and no real... trajectory... on the nacho read, afaik), and since ffery isn't talking about who she actually thinks is scum here, i dunno what's up with her atm
In post 2784, zMuffinMan wrote:and i don't feel too good about selkies / nacho for entirely separate reasons (partially because others look more town, partially because gut twinges) so i lie awake at night staring at the ceiling thinking, "hmmmmm something doesn't make sense here"
just because you lie awake at night dreaming about me doesn't mean i'm scum
i also think this is one of the towniest games i've ever played, for reasons only i will understand
i also don't know why ffery is townreading me, but she has her methods???
"Playing with Nacho is like playing with a religious conservative." ~UncertainKitten
-- Fate, Vanilla Townie, was brutally stabbed by a throwing sword in endgame.
In post 2759, Guyett wrote:I've already PoE'd the game down.... I'm extremely confident in nacho flipping scum and would like selkies flipped to analyse do some good VCA
where's your poe process? since when do you use poe?
"Playing with Nacho is like playing with a religious conservative." ~UncertainKitten
-- Fate, Vanilla Townie, was brutally stabbed by a throwing sword in endgame.
In post 2759, Guyett wrote:I've already PoE'd the game down.... I'm extremely confident in nacho flipping scum and would like selkies flipped to analyse do some good VCA
where's your poe process? since when do you use poe?
Quite a lot lately. check out the faith plus one game prior to the too many heads game
I think a lot about meteors. The purity of them. Boom! The end. Start again. The world made clean for the new man to rebuild.
selkies wrote:Bert do you really think Nacho is scum?
i think i asked you this at some point recently but i don't remember the answer and i cbf finding it
who do you actually think is scum right now?
I thought I answered, though the answer's changed a little bit from before the post disappearance. Aronis and GF, though GF going after Aronis makes me wonder about them as a team. Also Guyett. Usually it's aimed at someone else, but advancing a case to lynch for bandwagon analysis never sits well with me. So easy to say "Welp, I was wrong but look at all this data we have." The game setup makes me think that one of the protective roles is scum, zero kills instead of 2 is kinda messy. Objectively SSK has looked more town to me than GF has.
In post 2769, Selkies wrote:I think we probably are all together. It's hard to call Nacho for sure due to not a lot of data.
Meant you and Cabd as a scumteam potentially. Cabd tossing that theory of me-scum out because of the lack of a NK is just like tossing out random stuff to see if it goes well with others, and that's while seeming to have no other real suspicions of his own today.
I also wish he had revealed what his intentions were during the steps he took during that super-awkward "dance." Doesn't it seem really inconclusive?
If we were a scum team, Cabd would probably have bussed me, with my full blessing. That's actually a pretty minor point for town-Cabd though. As scum, I don't believe he'd concoct a voluntary fake-claim that makes his continued survival a question mark.
I wouldn't expect Cabd to give up anything specific about what he's looking for in a dance. It's an arms race.
In post 2759, Guyett wrote:I've already PoE'd the game down.... I'm extremely confident in nacho flipping scum and would like selkies flipped to analyse do some good VCA
where's your poe process? since when do you use poe?
Quite a lot lately. check out the faith plus one game prior to the too many heads game
In post 2732, Guyett wrote:One of my posts got eated so I'll try replicate it. I'm kinda leaning towards Cabds option A there
I think SSK was left alive as he's lynch bait. Not sure why he wasn't roleblocked though :/
So Cabd and SSK are prob town.
Scum Nurse doesn't make sense in a setup where there's a compulsive N2 Vig. So Goodfather is out of the lynch pool.
One of the neighbours could be scum and in that scenario I'd be leaning towards Aronis but I suspect both are actually town.
This leaves {Selkies, Bert, notscience and Nacho}
I'm very confident that Nacho is scum and Selkies is prob scum for the manner of the wagon dispersals. Not sure between ns, bert and possibly one of the neighbours
I think a lot about meteors. The purity of them. Boom! The end. Start again. The world made clean for the new man to rebuild.
So what I'm seeing from selkies and what I'm seeing from Guyett and vaguely from others is that Aronis can be seen as scum. The only thing holding us back from lynching him is that he's a neighbor. That shouldn't be a reason. Especially at Day 3. Let's just get this lynch out of the way before we're at one day to deadline once again scrambling. Because that would suck.
In post 2793, Selkies wrote:If we were a scum team, Cabd would probably have bussed me, with my full blessing. That's actually a pretty minor point for town-Cabd though.
Maybe, maybe not. Definitely a moot point. Where has he made a genuine push on someone for a lynch so far?
He saw the wagon, and looking back most realized that it wasn't going anywhere if he didn't hop on. His "sorting" of you was long-winded, which lead to indifference and indirectly derailed the wagon as we joined other wagons in hope of a deadline lynch.
In post 2793, Selkies wrote:As scum, I don't believe he'd concoct a voluntary fake-claim that makes his continued survival a question mark.
Cabd isn't predictable, and he has a history of fakeclaiming, so.... no, I don't buy this. SELL. Also, your townread on him was super sketchy. You rambled through your "philosophies" about town-cabd and announced him as likely town on Day 1 without much of a reason.
Don't you think something's off about him pawning some bullshit case on me due to NKA? And he's not even voting me or saying anything to make me think he's reanalyzing me.
