The Reckoning III (Math is Hard) Holy crap, perfect town win

[Porochaz]

Seeing if they'd actually choose a different suit that in the f2f games would be town alignment.

Therefore they're hinting at being town, and I might trust them for now.

Wait, what? "Hinting at being town"...er we'll explicitly claim it? Is that better? (Are you, uh trying to imply the avatar thing was some sort of trap or some test? IDG what you're saying?)

Prozac's post is pretty boring, especially since I think there are reads available throughout the thread.

Tell me what reads you had from before this post. I've looked through and beyond getting a few slight townreads, I don't see anything worth looking at, at this point.

[A Simple Math Problem]

Vote Count 1.18

Your New Gay Overlords

(1) Fate

Eleven

(1) Gammagooey

Iecerint

(0)

Cheery Dog

(0)

Untrod Tripod

(0)

Gammagooey

(0)

InflatablePie

(0)

Nuwen

(0)

Ythan

(0)

Axxle

(1) Porochaz

ActionDan

(4)

ChannelDelibird, Eleven, Iecerint, Ythan

Sir Waffles Wafflington

(0)

eaglekit

(2) Triforce, pirate mollie

pirate mollie

(2) eaglekit, Axxle

Porochaz

(0)

ChannelDelibird

(0)

Triforce

(4)

InflatablePie, Nuwen, Your New Gay Overlords, Untrod Tripod

Fate

(0)

Not Voting

(3) ActionDan, Sir Waffles Wafflington, Cheery Dog

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch.

Deadline: March 22nd @ 3PM Commune Time

[Gammagooey]

i was dead on night 2 without claiming and no scum had flipped until that day so it's probably just the things i did in the game

Yeah, probably. I mean, I'll certainly let you know if I get a read on you either way here.

I did indeed (skim)read the whole game, just for a laugh. I really don't recall very much about the specifics of your game. I was surprised to check just now and see that I townread you so seemingly solidly. If you like I can try and reread you from there again but I'm not entirely sure what I would gain from it; presumably if something stuck out enough there I'll notice if something sticks out here eventually. I certainly don't have much on you either way at the moment.

It just seems weird to me that you'd throw me in the 'never gonna have a read' pile if you've played with me at all before

cheery dog sure
tri i disagree with but 3 heads IS a pain in the ass so that's reasonable at least
but i think i'm pretty readable like a pretty large amount of the time?

for ut

-
i still haven't read over the pirate/mollie cataclysm in much detail but mollie's play seems really off from what i expected given her face to face play and seems a lot more emotional than i think makes sense for her to be at the time. Like mollie's play is actually physically worrying to me whereas my other reads are more 'that feels a bit weird' or 'it makes sense for him/she/them/etc to do that as scum' i'm hesitant to vote them since i haven't actually gone over her posts in detail and i feel like if she were to get wagoned it would happen pretty fast and it'd be hard to get people to back off it if she did something town (or i read over something town in her posts but it seems unlikely given how her posts feel to me now) in the meantime

waffles exists and really the only thing that pinged me about them was them jumping on the 'gammas being weird' train after other people had starting pointing me out

nuwen hasn't been up to my expected standards of nuwen-play and i don't really trust fate's read on her to be correct right now (if it was like day 3 or something then i'd feel a lot better just going with his read) but it is still pretty early in the game

eagle is whatever at this point and i don't think they're particularly scummy or not scummy

farakitty is pretty much just a null read that i think most people will be a little bit too fast to write off as town because faraday's pretty good at mafia sometimes

actiondan doesn't seem particularly scummy to me but he hasn't done a lot so other people could be right about him being scum but im not going to care about him for a bit longer

and i think thats it for interesting opinions that i have. other people are obviously missing because i don't think i have anything interesting to say about their play that hasn't already been said by either me or someone else

[Sir Waffles Wafflington]

waffles exists and really the only thing that pinged me about them was them jumping on the 'gammas being weird' train after other people had starting pointing me out

Oh yeah gamma feels kinda like he did in the wizard game, so um yeah don't know what I'm feeling about that but not too alarmed by his posting.

And I still like cdb

Can you point out how me essentially saying that you kinda feel like you did (as town mind you) in a recent game, so I'm not alarmed by your posting, but essentially dont' have a read on you is me 'jumping on the gamma's being weird train'?

[Porochaz]

On page 10 and Im falling asleep. I have minor reads on people, and a scumread I might look over again if he doesn't get better in the next 19 pages.

UT/Dan/Eleven look pretty town at this point, and I will explain any scumreads at the end and hopefully dig into them a bit more.

[Porochaz]

On page 10 and Im falling asleep. I have minor reads on people, and a scumread I might look over again if he doesn't get better in the next 19 pages.

UT/Dan/Eleven look pretty town at this point, and I will explain any scumreads at the end and hopefully dig into them a bit more.

[ChannelDelibird]

It just seems weird to me that you'd throw me in the 'never gonna have a read' pile if you've played with me at all before

Well, sorry. I know some of the Communists seem to have a pretty good handle on you but I have always found you to be largely an enigma in face-to-face mafia (99% of my experience with you). My abiding memories are the affable but inscrutable shrugs. Clearly we just need to play more games together.

[Gammagooey]

@waffles

On that note, Gamma, your CDB vote is terrible. Why are you being so weird this game?

[Untrod Tripod]

i still haven't read over the pirate/mollie cataclysm in much detail but mollie's play seems really off from what i expected given her face to face play and seems a lot more emotional than i think makes sense for her to be at the time. Like mollie's play is actually physically worrying to me whereas my other reads are more 'that feels a bit weird' or 'it makes sense for him/she/them/etc to do that as scum' i'm hesitant to vote them since i haven't actually gone over her posts in detail and i feel like if she were to get wagoned it would happen pretty fast and it'd be hard to get people to back off it if she did something town (or i read over something town in her posts but it seems unlikely given how her posts feel to me now) in the meantime

waffles exists and really the only thing that pinged me about them was them jumping on the 'gammas being weird' train after other people had starting pointing me out

nuwen hasn't been up to my expected standards of nuwen-play and i don't really trust fate's read on her to be correct right now (if it was like day 3 or something then i'd feel a lot better just going with his read) but it is still pretty early in the game

eagle is whatever at this point and i don't think they're particularly scummy or not scummy

farakitty is pretty much just a null read that i think most people will be a little bit too fast to write off as town because faraday's pretty good at mafia sometimes

actiondan doesn't seem particularly scummy to me but he hasn't done a lot so other people could be right about him being scum but im not going to care about him for a bit longer

imo I think we don't start throwing rocks at mollie until later because lordy loo I don't want to wake that up until we have something to go on

my impression of waffles has been a whole lot of nothing posting. it doesn't set off my day 1 scumdar yet though

correct me if I'm wrong but isn't nuwen usually this quiet early?

I dunno what to feel about eagle

I think you make a good point about farakitty. in fact, I have a scumread on them atm

I'm reading dan as town right now.

[Untrod Tripod]

gamma, with your permission, I'd like to start a posse

you can be viceroy if I can be chancellor

[pirate mollie]

cdb I am probably cling to you all game you and ut. I think ut is town.

yaye I think I have an anchor

I am thinking you might be right about danny he gets kind of lurky as scum and I can't remember a thing he has said

eta: ut I am not a thing!

[pirate mollie]

also the city while digging giant holes in my yard cut the cable line and I can't find my phone. I am at wild wings right now but my activity will be spotty until they get it fixed

[Gammagooey]

gamma, with your permission, I'd like to start a posse

you can be viceroy if I can be chancellor

seems good

[Gammagooey]

nuwen is just pretty damn good at the game a lot of the time and all i've seen was a big post about triforce that was partially based on a misconception with reck's claim

like it IS early so it's not a big thing but it's not up to my (admittedly high) expectations of her.

[Untrod Tripod]

okay viceroy gamma, first order of business:

when was the last time you looked at cheerydog's face?

is it scum?

PEdit: Okay, I guess it's second order

I see what you're getting at, but I can absolutely see town Nuwen opening the thread for the past 15 pages and going "oh hell nah" and closing it without posting

[Fate]

Notice the complete and utter lack of a response from Triforce

The signs they are there

don't let them be unread


Grasp this truth in the midst of a sea of darkness

[Ythan]

Fate you're voting for the fags.

[Eleven]

Tell me what reads you had from before this post. I've looked through and beyond getting a few slight townreads, I don't see anything worth looking at, at this point.

I don't know! I don't keep track of my reads at any particular point. Presumably I had some though ^_^

[Eleven]

still haven't read over the pirate/mollie cataclysm in much detail but mollie's play seems really off from what i expected given her face to face play

her forum play is p different btw, to the point that i was surprised she didn't speak very often in f2f

[Eleven]

I think anyone with a townread on Dan is probably reading the wrong game or like accidentally clicked balto invitational or something. He's PRETTY scummy.

Gamma when he flips scum I can coast to endgame, right? I'm totally not bussing him or anything.

[Fate]

Fate you're voting for the fags.

I already know that it isn't going to happen.


It saddens me, but if everyone were enlightened the world would already be over so it isn't all bad.

I am just taking my stance firmly to make my truths known.

All we have is one voice, one vote.

[Fate]

There's more than one scum Faraday.

Let me have this today, you know I'll carry your torch if they kill you over me.

[Eleven]

farakitty is pretty much just a null read that i think most people will be a little bit too fast to write off as town because faraday's pretty good at mafia sometimes

it's okay fate can read me p well in the forums (I mean he can't get me lynched lol vengeful claims but that's not really what matters here and it may not even be all that true of a fact since that's just 1 game but the important thing is you believe it!)

[Eleven]

who are you voting? reck? I mean I could totally see reck being an actiondan buddy hence my PRODDING at him over his reaction to it, idk, the magua being a beloved princess thing also makes no sense whatsoever and I have a feeling roles may be related to flavour p close idk (given dn's + iec's claimed things at least!!)

oh i also might have a question for reck let me go see if I do

[Eleven]

oh no i don't not yet, maybe later that's a shame.