The Reckoning III (Math is Hard) Holy crap, perfect town win

[Cheery Dog]

That was an interesting vote, Cheery Dog. (Eleven, you should totally join the wagon!) Define "sappiness." Why do you think it's a scumtell?

The whole area where both of you are calling yourselves the worse hydra partner ever feels fake and excusable for whatever it was you were doing at the time. (bugger rereading)

It may also be the pointless happy picture trolling from yesterday (as I'm also slightly suspicious of UT as well after that).

I don't expect the wagon to go anywhere, but it seemed like a good use of a vote I wasn't using.

[Fate]

Mollie what if I said I believe you now

[Sir Waffles Wafflington]

People are just making me sad this game.

[Triforce]

I 100% do?

flavored doctor sounds plausible on its own, why even bother with the survivor part? it's needlessly complex (aka likely the truth).

This is actually a good point.

No, it isn't. Put on your Mafia 101 cap and take a wild guess as to what happens on N1 to the claimed protown protective role.

Not including our win con would have been suicidal.


As an aside, I'm p sure that role would be stupidly OP of it were protown. Every night it either protects a town player or makes itself immune to a scumbag? Seriously, kids.

[Sir Waffles Wafflington]

I 100% do?

flavored doctor sounds plausible on its own, why even bother with the survivor part? it's needlessly complex (aka likely the truth).

This is actually a good point.

No, it isn't. Put on your Mafia 101 cap and take a wild guess as to what happens on N1 to the claimed protown protective role.

Not including our win con would have been suicidal.


As an aside, I'm p sure that role would be stupidly OP of it were protown. Every night it either protects a town player or makes itself immune to a scumbag? Seriously, kids.

You do realize that the point she's agreeing with is that the way you claimed sounds like it's the truth, right?

[Iecerint]

Counterexample: mentat.

</split personality disorder>

Something I noticed based on the rules:

NOTES FOR THIS GAME SPECIFICALLY

1. Your alignment will not change over the course of this game.
2.

Anti-town factions will be given relevant fake roles and flavor.

3. Sample VT role PM

Bold added. I think this makes it very unlikely that Triforce is scum because TriforceScum probably has a town fakeclaim.. It is possible that Triforce is actually a relatively anti-town 3rd party, but it is not likely that they are scum.

Eh. I think that means stuff like Mafia Trackers having Town Tracker fakeclaim. Triforce could be a Mafia goon with a VT fakeclaim who invented this themselves. I still think it's much more likely they're an AIDS-infector variant, though.

It's trivially possible that they could be a Goon who invited stuff about green shirts and such, but the triviality needs to be italicized.

I think it's zany that a role in Gay Mafia is being used like a standard role in this discussion. But if we're talking about that role, NS won and the game continued.

[Sir Waffles Wafflington]

But it's been used in other games too. Quadz/UT used it in Anything Goes, which Angry Pidgeon played in. So, it is possible, I guess but I'm not the role specialist, that's Mina.

[Cheery Dog]

If a role wins a scummy, it should be included in games after it's original.

[Iecerint]

Also, if they just needed to give people shirts to win independently, I don't know why they wouldn't just claim that...?

It's not any more sinister than the current claim. The only difference is that the current claim includes town utility while simultaneously risking exposure on their parts (because if someone dies with a green shirt who wasn't already a green-shirt target, it will undermine their utility claim).

[Sir Waffles Wafflington]

I wonder if the green shirt recipients also give green shirts to whomever they target? Cuz that's along the lines of the aids infector.

[A Simple Math Problem]

No altslips today!

Vote Count 1.23

Your New Gay Overlords

(0)

Eleven

(0)

Iecerint

(0)

Cheery Dog

(0)

Untrod Tripod

(0)

Gammagooey

(0)

InflatablePie

(0)

Nuwen

(0)

Ythan

(0)

Axxle

(3) Porochaz, Ythan, Your New Gay Overlords

ActionDan

(4) ChannelDelibird, Eleven, Iecerint, Sir Waffles Wafflington

Sir Waffles Wafflington

(1) Cheery Dog

eaglekit

(2) Triforce, pirate mollie

pirate mollie

(1) eaglekit

Porochaz

(0)

ChannelDelibird

(0)

Triforce

(5)

Untrod Tripod, Fate, Gammagooey, InflatablePie, Axxle

Fate

(0)

Not Voting

(2) ActionDan, Nuwen

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch.

Deadline: March 22nd @ 3PM Commune Time

[Triforce]

I 100% do?

flavored doctor sounds plausible on its own, why even bother with the survivor part? it's needlessly complex (aka likely the truth).

This is actually a good point.

No, it isn't. Put on your Mafia 101 cap and take a wild guess as to what happens on N1 to the claimed protown protective role.

Not including our win con would have been suicidal.


As an aside, I'm p sure that role would be stupidly OP of it were protown. Every night it either protects a town player or makes itself immune to a scumbag? Seriously, kids.

You do realize that the point she's agreeing with is that the way you claimed sounds like it's the truth, right?

yeah def thought that said "unlikely"

[Ythan]

I'm gonna vote for this survivor claim.

VOTE: Triforce

[Your New Gay Overlords]

is it weird my immediate response to the claim is to... let it live? Survivor could benefit town in the long run, and it certainly seems the ability helps town.

Although I guess it's a safer bet to lynch a non-town claim than try and find scum and be more likely to hit town. Huh.

[Ythan]

ew

[Iecerint]

Triforce is almost definitely not mafia, so they should not be lynched. They're definitely not town, too, but they probably have a pro-town effects from being around.

Bad lynch. You should utility lynch me before that I think.

[Axxle]

I disbelieve the doc protect part of the claim.

[Your New Gay Overlords]

Why specifically the doc part of the claim?

For me, I think Triforce wouldn't dare fakeclaim anything after Balto.

[Nuwen]

[quote="In [url=http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 8#p5732298]post 924[/url], Sir Waffles Wafflington"][quote="In [url=http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 1#p5731021]post 886[/url], EagleKit"][quote="In [url=http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 6#p5730996]post 878[/url], Fate"]I 100% do?[/quote]

flavored doctor sounds plausible on its own, why even bother with the survivor part? it's needlessly complex (aka likely the truth).[/quote]
This is actually a good point.

[quote="In [url=http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 1#p5731041]post 889[/url], Nuwen"]I think

UT is stoking the flames and adding a new layer of Stuff To Fear.

[b]unvote[/b] for now[/quote]
Hey, Nuwen, can you just come out and say, "I am scumreading UT," rather than throw around this kind of soft shit?[/quote]

Why is your tone hostile in this post?

[Fate]

Waffles tone is wafflin


I'm so sorry mollie you were right all along for some reason I thought farady thought they were town

[Fate]

I'm gonna vote for this survivor claim.

VOTE: Triforce

oh NOW you open your eyes

[Sir Waffles Wafflington]

I 100% do?

flavored doctor sounds plausible on its own, why even bother with the survivor part? it's needlessly complex (aka likely the truth).

This is actually a good point.

I think

UT is stoking the flames and adding a new layer of Stuff To Fear.

unvote

for now

Hey, Nuwen, can you just come out and say, "I am scumreading UT," rather than throw around this kind of soft shit?

Why is your tone hostile in this post?

I'd maybe call that aggressive (I'm a lot less "sweetness and light" than you'd expect in forum Mafia), but not hostile. Now answer the question and commit to an actual stance on UT. I don't 't think you've had many opinions that aren't tangential sideswipes or null dis

[Sir Waffles Wafflington]

I still haven't got the hang of this new phone, so it was easier to just submit that. EBWOP: I don't think you've said much that isn't a tangential sideswipe or debating the merits of vigging a miller vs. a beloved princess.

[ChannelDelibird]

Everyone indulging in mod-outguessing over possible alternative interpretations of Triforce's claimed role name can glug a nice refreshing can of shut-the-fuck-up juice. If I learned one lesson from the Balto invitational (and I did), it's that flavour is a bad influence.

Meanwhile AcscumDan continues to powerlurk and hope that we'll derplynch the survivor.

[Iecerint]

Meanwhile AcscumDan continues to powerlurk and hope that we'll derplynch the survivor.

I'm also inclined to believe that he thinks we'll get tired of waiting if he powerlurks.