I am camped out starbucks for the day. here is my readslist so far:
cdb - if he is scum I am going to
fly
to the uk to hit him with a pillow I mean this is a read I might not get weird on. ever.
prozack - seems genuine as fuck, I like where is head is it wrt the flow of the game. he seems to be trying to work things out and actually
paying attention
to what is going on in the game.
reck - I lean town on reck cos of the early red role pm thing cos I had the same initial reaction to the red ink I had to read it twice. (sorry fate)
iceyrent - I like some of his stances, the claim seems genuine.
fate - he just feels like fate to me, I am not seeing the same limp wristed scumplay as i did in the cross site game where he was scum with thorella. admittedly I am not that familiar with fate, I have only 1 completed game with him (we were both town) but he feels mebbe town and that is how I am treating him.
ut - what keeps him out of my town pile is his obsession with indies and that bizarre cult stuff. I am not sure if this is just a site meta clash or what. what is INTERESTING is that fate is doing the same thing but it just doesn't send the same alarm bells as it does with ut, I am not sure if it is cos I feel like fate is getting his hands dirtier outside the scope of indies or not, ut stands out more cos he seems more single focused with it. I have noticed that it is scum who worries about indies moreso especially on d1 since gives them a great wagon to hide on and obscures vca a bit.
nuwen - nuwen reminds me of a player offsite who I have been playing with for years (she even has a couple of completed games on here from a while ago) who doesn't really get warmed-up until d3. I liked her observation about ut and I like her observation/push on waffles. unsure leaning mebbe town but really need to see more of her.
gamma - I don't know! some things he has said that I agree with and I like that he was trying to take time to distinguish forum/f2f wrt me. but he is just so sneaky he will be hard to ever really trust.
inflatable pie - I remember thinking that I liked what he said but now I can't remember it. I will have to reread him. does reck's perfect read on gamma extend to forum mafia? I have noticed that reck has not been really vocal about him.
waffles - *sigh*. it is frustrating that no1 will really get why I thought their initial push was hostile in that it seemed that they were baiting me with a well-known sore point right from the get go. I can't find a positive motivation behind and the passive aggressive follow-up combined with victim behaviour and the constant bleating makes me think scum. it is a scum tactic that I have often seen used, where you bait some1 into an emotional response and then call them scummy for it. <---- this is what it felt like. it seems like they are using it as a smokescreen in lieu of the very in-depth level of scumhunting I know they are capable of. this isn't it. scumzorz
eleven - I am not sure how any1 even remotely has them as town. I have 1 completed game with faraday and he was really easy to read as town that game and I was even fairly new to the site and did not know him. he is constantly baiting people, contradicting themselves and where I would expect that hydra to be fairly deft at cutting through the mist they instead seem to be generating a ton of it. unsure lean scum
axxle - I am not feeling the town love with axxle. 1 completed game where he was town and I am going to go check for a comparison. unsure lean mebbe scum.
eaglekit - scumz. desp has never misread me ever so that he is in this game is startling. not to mention they are doing nothing but vote parking on an early read. there is no reach out from them and the sticky vote looks awful. scumz.
ythan - dunno. like I really don't know.
triforce - I believe their indie claim but the doc claim seems far fetched. hhmm...
cheery dog -
hey cheery what's up!
I have played with you more than most of the people here and I am not seeing that same level of play that I am used to seeing from you! why is that?
anyways just wanted to get this out there.