The Fall of Gondolin Mafia: Game Over (The Tale of Gondolin)

[Plum]

VOTE COUNT 6:5

Tierce

- 1 - PeregrineV

PeregrineV

- 3 - Elscouta, Desperado, Tierce

ActionDan

- 1 - shos

SpyreX

- 1 - ActionDan

Not voting (2):

Cogito Ergo Sum, SpyreX

With 8 players alive it takes

5

votes to lynch.

Deadline is in

(expired on 2014-03-15 06:00:00)

This malware business should be fixed now, sorry

[shos]

Crap. Ima read this goooood after work today.

[shos]

I have to say though i might vite PV

[Elscouta]

@Plum: I unvoted, sorry if the formatting was improper.

Unvote

So this is a 1v1 Tierce vs PeregrineV?

I don't know. On one side, i tend to give the benefit to the player forcing the 1v1, and it justifies a bit that PV pushed a forced case on Tierce yesterday. On the other hand:
- do you really keep a tracker-guilty under the belt when you have a reasonable chance of getting NK'ed, and when 2 scums are already down?
- 2 Trackers, 1 Weak Doc and 1 Super VigCop of Doom?

Unvote while I ponder.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Which shos had said he wasn't, so...?

Doesn't matter. Scum would know better and that doesn't match your proposed rationale for unclaiming Jailkeeper.

If you're town, Tierce, there's a 3-man scum team out there to catch with connections between them. So catch that scum team.

[Tierce]

If you're town, Tierce, there's a 3-man scum team out there to catch with connections between them. So catch that scum team.

I've already said that I don't much care about this Today. Peregrine goes first because

I'm lazy

he's confirmed scum. I'm busy now (yay flaky mods), then I need to go to bed, and I won't be around for much of tomorrow. I've given this as much time as I currently can. Tomorrow will feature irked phoneposts when I'm not tripping over my own feet.

[Tierce]

Long nap, SpyreX.

And awfully long game review you're having, ActionDan.

[Tierce]

Oh

hello

. Desperado, come out and play! We're cooler than those other kids, promise! There's confirmed scum for you to lynch and all. /)

[Tierce]

And with this

thrilling

contribution, I am going to go collapse. Lynch PeregrineV, and thank you for helping us help you help us all.

[ActionDan]

I don't believe there's 5 scum if peregrine is scum. If he's town I don't think there's 5 either. People thinking there is 5 scum seem kinda derpy to me

[PeregrineV]

I don't believe there's 5 scum if peregrine is scum. If he's town I don't think there's 5 either. People thinking there is 5 scum seem kinda derpy to me

Tierce wants you to believe there's 5 scum and it's lylo after she had a guilty on her. How is that derp and not scum?

[ActionDan]

Which shos had said he wasn't, so...?

Doesn't matter. Scum would know better and that doesn't match your proposed rationale for unclaiming Jailkeeper.

If you're town, Tierce, there's a 3-man scum team out there to catch with connections between them. So catch that scum team.

Like this

[ActionDan]

There's some stuff directed at you earlier. I haven't read it but some people say it's incriminating.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

Which shos had said he wasn't, so...?

Doesn't matter. Scum would know better and that doesn't match your proposed rationale for unclaiming Jailkeeper.

If you're town, Tierce, there's a 3-man scum team out there to catch with connections between them. So catch that scum team.

Like this

I'm not expressing a belief in a 5-man scum team there. I'm trying to see where Tierce takes that logic.

[Cogito Ergo Sum]

But yeah, Pere, you should respond to #2263.

[PeregrineV]

There's some stuff directed at you earlier. I haven't read it but some people say it's incriminating.

I'm willing to answer everything. I'm going to keep my cool right now and avoid the obvious posting that I so desperately want to do.

So, what are your questions, ActionDan?

pedit- Sure, I will start with that.

[PeregrineV]

He is scum because it is the second guily that he gets, and he never spoke of the first.

There was no first guilty.
Night2 I tracked Jacob to MafiaSSK.

Why Jacob?
Because he was a claimed PR that was still alive, and I failed night1 to catch an under-the-radar ActionDan performing any nefarious deeds. Night2 I would either catch him trying to protect someone while being killed, or, if the player he was "protecting" died, I'd have caught scum.
TiP/Reck died that night.

ABR claimed Even Night Cop on day 2 when JacobSavage was a claimed bodyguard.
PV is supposed to have tracked JacobSavage to MafiaSSK day 2, which would be at least a very strange target.

Yes, quite.

There is scum in ABR or Jacob, possibly both.

But, choosing bad targets as town happens. You can argue the whys, but there was, at that point, no reason to out myself when I had no usable results.

He doesn't speak of it. He doesn't even pretend to be interested in what JacobSavage did, when asking "who did you target, JS" would have been totally fine on day3.

Tierce was busy bussing day3. Jacob was bussing. Since we were lynching scum, what's there to say?

He waits until day 4 when JS is confirmed scum to hop on the bandwagon.

At what point was Jacob confirmed scum TO YOU?

To me, it was right here:

I targetted ABR N2,
ActionDan N3.

Cool enough.

Vote: JacobSavage

[PeregrineV]

Which shos had said he wasn't, so...?

Doesn't matter. Scum would know better and that doesn't match your proposed rationale for unclaiming Jailkeeper.

If you're town, Tierce, there's a 3-man scum team out there to catch with connections between them. So catch that scum team.

Like this

I'm not expressing a belief in a 5-man scum team there. I'm trying to see where Tierce takes that logic.

She's not taking it anywhere. She's scum.

Tell me you don't see it, and tell me why.

[ActionDan]

Let my do a few isos

[ActionDan]

Peregrine after the comment "i want to believe Jacob" i made, what were you feeling in your next post?

[PeregrineV]

Peregrine after the comment "i want to believe Jacob" i made, what were you feeling in your next post?

This one?

:/ i really want to believe him

That was actually the fastest wagon/lynch I've seen recently.

This was my attempt to make scum not connect 1764 with a results-oriented counterclaim. I was hoping to squeeze out at least one more result.

[shos]

hey guys, I'll be catching up in a few minutes, meanwhile - I need replacement in my game, Open 551 - Hard Boiled. anyone want in? it's only 5 pages long so far

[ActionDan]

k

##Vote Tierce

I believe PeregrineV. Or at least, it's more likely he's town.

[ActionDan]

the only thing is getting over 2 trackers.

[ActionDan]

but it isn't too awful.

17 players 1 weak doc / 1 GODROLE 1-shot cop-vig / 2 trackers / possibly 1 voyeur (who if scum is probably a roleblocker/jailkeeper lol) / 8 - 9 VTS / 1 strongman of sorts / 1 rolecop / 2 other scum

sounds right.