Open 551: Hard Boiled - GAME OVER

[mastin2]

Side-note, but I really did kinda feel like I was replacing myself. Protector is quite obviously not me, but posts like this one feel like, well...the same sort of...whimsy, I guess?...that I have.

Kid A and I are not going to be friends. I do not like him. Very possibly town. Very probably worthless. Very definitely needs to have opinions on mafia games rather than N64 games.
I also probably will not be friends with Not_Mafia. I do not like him either and I do not like his questions. He can be town, perhaps.
Egg seems town. Judgment on his character will be held off until a later date.

The seedy one catches my eye. My gut feeling is that I should desire a chance to stick something sharp through his gut.
Earthquake gives me pause. I know not why. Perhaps scummy. Perhaps poor hydra skills. Perhaps tone. Time holds many dirty secrets.

(Also, Protector's thoughts are

exactly

the same as my own.)

Also, while it feels way too easy, my initial instinct is in fact a CDB-Earthquake-Quill scumteam.

[AngryPidgeon]

Town: Lia, KidA, mastin
Meh-town: NOTMAFIA, formerfish

Scummy: Antihero, Earthquake

[mastin2]

btw does anyone else think the lia wagon is pretty suspect

*raises hand*
Yep!

Not_Mafia (4) - Dritan, Kid A, Antihero, Quill.
Kid A (4) - Egg, Not_Mafia, Zar, Formerfish.
ChannelDeliBird (1) - mastin2.
Quill (3) - Earthquake, chamber, ChannelDeliBird.

I'm wrong on Quill and/or Earthquake/CDB, given that counterwagon.
Still, though. Honestly, these wagons all seem like they suck. Kid A's pretty dang town.

Town: Lia, KidA, mastin
Meh-town: NOTMAFIA, formerfish

Scummy: Antihero, Earthquake

Sure. You can be town.
Sell me on Antihero scum, though; he's null.

[Antihero]

eh, ap got a scumslot. admirable effort, but whatever.

[Antihero]

actually, dritan might have just been newb, scratch that

Also, while it feels way too easy, my initial instinct is in fact a CDB-Earthquake-Quill scumteam.

i feel like there was a lot more scum involvement in that kid a wagon than just quill

please, tell me more about CDB

[Earthquake]

if the next person not voting protector doesnt claim intent to lynch then theyre scum fyi

Some questions for everyone

How much forum mafia experience do you have, mafia scum or otherwise?
Are you the mafia?
How many games were released on the N64 in North America? Guesses only please if you google you are scum

just a year on ms
yes but dont vote me im a vengeful mafia
i dunno n64 was a little bit shit it was probably like 150

Some questions for everyone

How much forum mafia experience do you have, mafia scum or otherwise?
Are you the mafia?
How many games were released on the N64 in North America? Guesses only please if you google you are scum

just a year on ms
yes but dont vote me im a vengeful mafia
i dunno n64 was a little bit shit it was probably like 150

Why was this the only thing with which you engaged?

because none of the other posts had words in them that made me want to respond with more words

VOTE: earthquake

Mastin, explain to me how this is town. It ain't.

We got Lia, Quill and Kid A. Whenever someone starts a wagon on the other, they either chainsaw or otherwise attack the wagon as it's forming.

[AngryPidgeon]

eh, ap got a scumslot. admirable effort, but whatever.

Willywonka.jpg

[AngryPidgeon]

Titus.

Your posts are so boringly scum motivated.

[Antihero]

eh, ap got a scumslot. admirable effort, but whatever.

Willywonka.jpg

oh, so now you're too good for me to actually go find a pic?

MAKE ME LAUGH, CLOWN

[Antihero]

well, your townread on not_mafia is actually enough of a joke

when you think about it, it really isn't that funny, though

[AngryPidgeon]

Side-note, but I really did kinda feel like I was replacing myself. Protector is quite obviously not me, but posts like this one feel like, well...the same sort of...whimsy, I guess?...that I have.

Kid A and I are not going to be friends. I do not like him. Very possibly town. Very probably worthless. Very definitely needs to have opinions on mafia games rather than N64 games.
I also probably will not be friends with Not_Mafia. I do not like him either and I do not like his questions. He can be town, perhaps.
Egg seems town. Judgment on his character will be held off until a later date.

The seedy one catches my eye. My gut feeling is that I should desire a chance to stick something sharp through his gut.
Earthquake gives me pause. I know not why. Perhaps scummy. Perhaps poor hydra skills. Perhaps tone. Time holds many dirty secrets.

(Also, Protector's thoughts are

exactly

the same as my own.)

Also, while it feels way too easy, my initial instinct is in fact a CDB-Earthquake-Quill scumteam.

I'm on my phone. Mastin I feel like our reads are very similar this game. I had a gut scum read on cdb. On of him or anti is scum prolly

[Antihero]

oh, well screw you guys then. i don't need to be in your stupid ass cool kids club

i'll make my own cool kids club. with blackjack, hookers, and a formerfish/not_mafia scum flip

[Egg]

Vote quill

They way protector handled her wagon was very poor and forced imo. I was torn between wondering if it was forced for *reasons* or forced because she's scum.

So...why the quill vote?

CDB, I'm not sure where your "too sure" vibe is coming from on Quill's Lia vote.

Zar, withholding townreads isn't a new thing. It's just a dumb thing that you'll come across once in a while. The idea is basically that if you town read someone on Day 1, you are locked into that read and won't ever change it so the scum will look over your posts because you are clearly the best scumhunter on the planet and they'll NK your obviously correct town read because at that point they are confirmed town. I may have exaggerated a bit, but that's pretty much the idea.

(I can't believe it. I know it's not a huge one, but I thought for sure I lost this post 12 hours ago when my laptop's battery died but this thing is so awesome it saved my post for me. This is awesome. Can you tell I've never had a laptop before? lol)

Quill, I don't think my town read on you last game was activity related at all. It was the content of your posts. I was reading what you were saying and going "yes, this guy has the right idea." I'm just not doing that here.

Antihero, what do you make of Kid A's L-1 vote on Protector, decision to suddenly change his play to not giving town reads, and not commenting on anything before I voted him?

Zar's 168 might be the post that shows town motivation more than any other post in this thread.

Not Mafia's reaction to votes from Kid A and Antihero reeks.

Random thought of the day. Mastin replacing Protector is funny to me because I had a theory that Protector was a Mastin alt.

Mastin, why CDB for an OMGUS?

And why use the L-3 vote count rather than the L-1 one? (Strikethrough tags because you answered this but backspacing it makes the rest feel like a pointless incomplete thought, but I'm still kind of curious). Also, I think there's a decent chance of two scum on the wagon on your slot. Oh and post 200 is extra funny with my original theory.

Uh, if anyone is wondering about my reads, look at AP's and flip most of them.

[AngryPidgeon]

If mastin and my reads are syncing, it's a

dang

good idea to trust us

[mastin2]

Titus.

Your posts are so boringly scum motivated.

^

Kid A is just...really, really obviously town.
VOTE: Earthquake.
Might as well be on the wagon since I support it.

If mastin and my reads are syncing, it's a

dang

good idea to trust us

Well, it's a good idea to trust that we're both town, at least. Not necessarily

right

, so not

necessarily

to sheep (trust reads), but trust alignment, sure, yeah. Only way AP'd be scum is if he was buddying my reads intentionally, but that's the paranoia 5% on his otherwise-95%-town record.

[Not_Mafia]

I was so sure this was a scum slot. But its not,

Why say this the moment you replace in?

[chamber]

Is egg normally incompetent?

[Egg]

Mastin/AP, can you elaborate on why Kid A is town and Earthquake is scum? Those are the reads I mostly have in mind because you are calling the player who I am voting obvtown and I don't see anything scummy about who you are voting.

[Kid A]

VOTE: channeldelibird

[Not_Mafia]

VOTE: KidA

[Antihero]

MASTIN

please talk to me about cbd

i'm having trouble reading the slot and it could help

DON'T
FUCKING
IGNORE
ME

[Antihero]

I was so sure this was a scum slot. But its not,

Why say this the moment you replace in?

here we go on the amished tell

pshaskl;jfdkl;sjekl;ajflk;jewa;l

[Not_Mafia]

Here we go on the wibbidy whaaa?

[Antihero]

amished tell: the idea that criticizing the former occupant of your slot means that you're scum

personally, i think it's a bunch of shit

[Not_Mafia]

Is that so?