NY 172: Another Large Normal (GAME OVER)

[Mister Rogers]

Wow. Well that's quite a forceful start.

[projectmatt]

What's your read on Yates?

[pisskop]

vote: Yates

oh boi.

[Mister Rogers]

@Matt: Well I was hoping you could help me because, he is hard to read.

[pisskop]

---

I want this looked at:

-On Yates

A VT claim DOESN'T mean that the person is auto magically vanilla OR town.You seem to be assuming this.Assuming this is bad.That's the point.

That's not what he said. ZD gave a list of restriction that resulted from his VT claim. Now, I didn't think it was his towniest moment, but
You jumped over that and started spewing about how it doesn't make them either alignment. <<< This is your scumgame as I understand it.

Is this correct?

yo.

[Nero Cain]

That's even more scumtastic.

Obfuscation is now added to the lack of sincerity.

overstating a tad here

post 20 logic's got an overexplainy vibe

hyperagressive scum? shrug, too early to tell.

vote: Mister Rogers

this is a good post. I also did not like him ignoring this.
+ the guy has like nearly 200 posts. This is scum cluttering things up.

I did not like Luca's naked vote on a serious bandwagon.

vote:Mr.Rodgers

[pisskop]

wha~? is there more?

[Nero Cain]

When I've read the other 20 pages there will be.

[Mister Rogers]

Welcome to the game. Glad you are finally here.

[Nero Cain]

I'm glad that I'm here to lynch you.

[Mister Rogers]

@nero: Excellent Luca read btw. Could you please comment on Mastin's Luca read? Thanks.

[Mister Rogers]

@Nero: Are you from the UK?

[RachMarie]

No he is from Tennessee

[Mister Rogers]

K, thanks.

What about Matt, do you know?

[RachMarie]

Not sure about Matt

BTW spelling should give away anyone who is from the UK. They use the Queen's English which has some definite differences from American English.

[Mister Rogers]

Oh. Ya good point thanks.

[Nero Cain]

@nero: Excellent Luca read btw. Could you please comment on Mastin's Luca read? Thanks.

die you scum fuck.

[Nero Cain]

Yo.

I have a proposal: larges these days have exploded in length. I am proposing we limit posts per person to be five a day, to see if we can get the shortest recent large game.

This is just...no. No. Stop it.

Mr. Rogers is a cutie pie thus far! (also seemingly town)

VOTE: mastin

Your posts annoy me. Please make them not, thx.

this could be scum.

Unlike others in this thread, you will not hear me chuck around certainties like "you're scum" - certainly not at this early point of the game.

*barf*

The BJC thing bores me. Yeah, I've seen scum claim scum..I've seen town claim scum. Its null and stupid though he's not for lynching today me thinks.

[Mister Rogers]

Ok, for all you people in TV land, the winner of the Grey promotion award is...

Projectmatt

!

Let's give him a round of applause for multiple townreads, exclusive focusing on lurkers, and asking others for scum case material on two separate occasions while having expressed none of his own! In general, posting like scum that is lost in the thread!

He obviously has enough game experience to generate scum reads on his own but has made excuses on at least two occasions, much like Taleh (except he didn't use multiball as the reason).

The final straw was his statement about making a big post after dinner which he failed to do.

I find his Yates vote to be quite terrible (it appears to be baseless; notice the difference with PK's vote which occurs at the same time) and overall there is no scum hunting with only lip-service paid to it.

I also see an amazingly unbelievable ott defense of BJC -- I mean it might just be a noise issue to harp on and maybe its just coincidental regarding the Yates vote but -- he has become the biggest BJC defender in this thread.

The major event that brought his ISO to my attention was of course his fake push over voting a lurker (in this case it was BJC) which simply read as town posturing (it may end up being more than that). On this note, he had expressed being hot and heavy on Aptil and also said he would provide case material there; haven't seen any of that and I suspect he took a look at that ISO and Aptil's most recent post and declined to even try.

So my updated short list:

Taleh, Matt, DG, Anx

[Mister Rogers]

@nero: Excellent Luca read btw. Could you please comment on Mastin's Luca read? Thanks.

die you scum fuck.

Pardon me but I'm serious. I am counting on experienced help here but if you are scum you WILL put down your read on Mastin for the record.

[Mister Rogers]

If you are town you will assist me by doing so.

[Mister Rogers]

Ok, maybe you have misunderstood and you think I am being sarcastic. Take a look at my long scum list LUCA is on there so I mean it when I say excellent read. I need to know your honest opinion of MASTIN'S read of Luca that he expressed in I believe his first post. Thanks.

[Nero Cain]

...............................................................................................

.............................................................................................................

Mastin has a town read on Luca, I don't. So what is there to comment on? Are you actually asking me if us having different opinions makes Mastin scum? No. Well not unless you are claiming that he's your scumbuddy. If you are asking me what my read on Mastin is but for some reason not using your words "What is your Mastin read?" Then well I think he's town.

but still...you're gonna die.

[Mister Rogers]

Ok so you have differing reads than Mastin -- you didn't find his read bizarre? It doesn't stick out to you as bad?

Furthermore ya, if I am wrong about Mastin I DO need guidance on that issue. Same thing rgardless of your alignment.

[Mister Rogers]

Those are two questions:

1) Didn't his read look bizarre to you? And his opening reads in general (the 3 I mentioned)?
2) What do I need to know about Mastin as to why he's town i.e. why you are reading him as town?