The Reckoning III (Math is Hard) Holy crap, perfect town win

[Untrod Tripod]

dude

you're obsessed with meta and it's weird that you're totally ignoring it in this case

[Cheery Dog]

Mollie's apparent townpost is the AtE? I'm not buying any of that.

reasons for ut scum: how about being obsessed with indies

While I believe this may relate to why I'm calling Nuwen scum, His level of mentioning that cult was included in the flavour name felt more town than Nuwen's "I was right about Triforce."

[A Simple Math Problem]

Prodding Fate

Vote Count 2.28

Your New Gay Overlords

(1) Eleven

Eleven

(0)

Iecerint

(0)

Cheery Dog

(4) Fate, Axxle, pirate mollie, Iecerint

Untrod Tripod

(2) Your New Gay Overlords, Nuwen

Gammagooey

(0)

InflatablePie

(1) Magua

Nuwen

(1) Sir Waffles Wafflington

Ythan

(0)

Axxle

(0)

Sir Waffles Wafflington

(0)

eaglekit

(0)

pirate mollie

(5)

eaglekit, Cheery Dog, Ythan, InflatablePie, Untrod Tripod

Magua

(0)

Fate

(0)

Not Voting

(1) Gammagooey

With 15 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.

Deadline: April 3rd @ 3PM Commune Time

[A Simple Math Problem]

Also prodding Eaglekit

[Eleven]

wow this game has been p bad in my absence. I WILL TRY TO FIX YOU

oh it's magua hey magua what's going on xoxoxo!

[Eleven]

gamma's new avatar sucks

vote: EAGLEKIT

FEAR ME.

[Eleven]

i mean we could lynch the people with obsessively fake tunnel vision instead of mollie who has some sort of weird complex or something but actually seeeems p town despite it all?

[Eleven]

hey waffles maybe SELL ME on nuwen or something instead of being the one vote wagon people.

you'll point out i'm the only vote on eaglekit. you're correct. FOR NOW.

[Eleven]

oh oh in my experience with cheerydog town he like, um, IDK he came across as kind of dumb and he doesn't hear but maybe it's cos he is trying hard this game but yeah that's the only thing that gives me pause his actual arguments which I'll pretend I've read don't seem that scummy, dunno.

UT is kinda town for meta mostly so don't get that? so yeah we could lynch eaglekit and stuff?

[Eleven]

Mollie's apparent townpost is the AtE? I'm not buying any of that.

although stuff like this (the language) seems kind of forced, admittedly?

[Gammagooey]

gamma's new avatar sucks

vote: EAGLEKIT

FEAR ME.

don't be hatin on Ether

eagle lynch and cheery lynch feel pretty similar to me, i skimmed over cheery again and think i'd prefer lynching him though? and mollie's response to me was fairly town so yeah

Vote: Cheery Dog

[Cheery Dog]

Mollie's apparent townpost is the AtE? I'm not buying any of that.

although stuff like this (the language) seems kind of forced, admittedly?

You'd get that from me as either alignment (i assume it does happen when I'm scum, I haven't played enough games to remember if people say that about me) it will happen when not enough other stuff is happening in the thread and I attempt to get people talking more.

[Lost Butterfly]

I would lynch cheery over mollie but like, let's lynch eagle? or at least FORCE THEM TO DO STUFF.

OMG I TOLD THEM MY PLAN IT'LL BE RUINED

and we'll lynch them

[Eleven]

I would lynch cheery over mollie but like, let's lynch eagle? or at least FORCE THEM TO DO STUFF.

OMG I TOLD THEM MY PLAN IT'LL BE RUINED

and we'll lynch them

[Untrod Tripod]

yeah, eagle ignoring the thread has diminished my townread on them almost completely

[Untrod Tripod]

hey I have an idea

eaglekit eaglekit eaglekit

[EagleKit]

yeah man, so scummy of us to start ignoring the thread as soon as our preferred lynch started gaining momentum. goddamn masterminds ITH

or we were just, like, busy, man.

[EagleKit]

yeah, eagle ignoring the thread has diminished my townread on them almost completely

oh no, ut is retracting the townread that didn't make sense in the first place

!!!

/yawn

[Untrod Tripod]

yeah it's almost like when people do things that are scummy you have to reevaluate your read on them. WOAH. I forgot that having monolithic reads is the most pro-est of town.

[Nuwen]

unvote vote Eaglekit

[Sir Waffles Wafflington]

UT is kinda town for meta mostly so don't get that?

Ooh, can I sheep you on this so I don't have to think too deeply about it? I was actually having doubts, just because Nuwen's assessment of him "fucking anything that moves" is pretty damn accurate. His play looks scummy barring some posts with actual sparks of life in them early D1-2.

That reminds me of something I meant to ask Iecerint earlier, but never got around to:

I don't at all understand how reading someone town could be an insult to them regardless of their alignment (that means you think they're doing well regardless of their alignment), but lynching Waffles before tomorrow at the very earliest is dumb, anyway.

Tammy already explained this--it's an insult to someone's scum play if I think he looks scummy but am calling him town because my meta experience with his scum play has been far scummier than this. But do you think this is even alignment-relevant in the slightest? I assume you're implying there's some scum motivation, if "BUT WE CAN'T LYNCH THEM UNTIL D3" is brought up as a point against it. Also, remind me to ask you something else tomorrow.

[Untrod Tripod]

so I reread AD's ISO, and the only slots he really interacted with were CDB and Gay Aliens.

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 9#p5716529
this exchange looks kinda like coaching but I don't really feel that strongly about that tell.

that's all I've really got from his ISO

[Untrod Tripod]

I think his play looks kinda like he was trying to set up a bus on CDB if a wagon ever came to bear on him

I'm not sure though. I don't want to give into the too scummy to be scum fallacy, but it's so fucking exaggerated and obvious distancing, I can't imagine why he'd make a point of saying "lynch CDB tomorrow!" after he died unless it was supposed to be distancing? this is a WIFOM rabbit hole though

anyone have fresh thoughts on the CDB/AD interactions?

[pirate mollie]

dude

you're obsessed with meta and it's weird that you're totally ignoring it in this case

in what case? you?

I already explained how I meta people and you were all like "I grok this" and then you turned around and voted me without really giving a reason.

@ mina

nuwen was not the first to point that out about ut, gay boiz were it is 1 of the reasons there was an attempt to wagon him.

anyways without further ado

VOTE: eaglekit

god if they flip scum I will feel so fucking vindicated

[Eleven]

Ooh, can I sheep you on this so I don't have to think too deeply about it? I was actually having doubts, just because Nuwen's assessment of him "fucking anything that moves" is pretty damn accurate. His play looks scummy barring some posts with actual sparks of life in them early D1-2.

well i'm slightly worried i'm underestimating his scum play admittedly so NOPE can't really sheep me on it. sry