Regardless of if i am right or wrong, stating my reason to you being town will have you dead tonight, which is decidedly a bad thing.In post 418, PhDScar wrote:I also think now would be a good time to hear those reasons.
Pages 4-9. you still havnt answered nachos question, and instead of answering mine, all you did was offer a counter question, then backed away when I had answered it.In post 391, Jake from State Farm wrote:I probably won't get to it til tomorrow or the next day but so I can find it easier.
1. Hk, link me to where I supposedly dodged anyone cause that's false
2. HS , what questions did u ask me ? I don't remember seeing them.
Nope. I answered all his questions and never backed away. Why do you keep lying?In post 429, Hello Kitty Creampuff wrote:Pages 4-9. you still havnt answered nachos question, and instead of answering mine, all you did was offer a counter question, then backed away when I had answered it.In post 391, Jake from State Farm wrote:I probably won't get to it til tomorrow or the next day but so I can find it easier.
1. Hk, link me to where I supposedly dodged anyone cause that's false
2. HS , what questions did u ask me ? I don't remember seeing them.
So were you satisfied by BRO's response? You didn't really give any reaction to it.In post 393, catboi wrote:Nah. I think it's entirely within my right to question a naked vote even if it's on a wagon I'm on. I don't like when someone makes a vote like that without explaining it when it's on a fairly serious wagon. I don't like when that type of stuff goes by unquestioned
What makes you think they could be scum together?In post 400, BROseidon wrote:I'm gonna lol so hard if HKC and Jake are scum together.
How did you distinguish between fake hydra dissonance and real hydra dissonance? If it were real, would you perceive that as a town tell?In post 419, Jake from State Farm wrote:I think they are scum because
1. the "we are town" post gave me a bad vibe
2. the hydra dissonance seems fake and should be kept behind the scenes as much as possinle and their usless banter/posts makes them look like they are trolling and in my experience these kind of people don't get lynched, especially day 1.
3. no scum hunting from what I have seen
4. not doing anything that resembles pro-town behavior
That's the only thing you have to say about this entire game, other than SMP/walls?HighShroomish wrote:@Mac if something has already been said, why say it again(i.e. Why the votes on PhD)
That's probably because there's just one head talking at the minute.In post 409, Jake from State Farm wrote:Yet I'm not attacking both hydras so obviously not letting my hydra hate influence me...
The other hydra is playing like they should. They aren't creating confusion in the game thread.
The thing that bugs me here is that whilst Bert is a good mafia player, he's pretty laidback and I can't imagine him doing much planning as town, possibly not even as scum, although I can't quite back that statement up. Similarly, Mara is very emotional as a player and whilst I think they're a good enough combo as a hydra, I can't see them staging this dissonance. Like at all.Dr Scar wrote:For example this did make me think of HKC as town. It just seemed so genuine at the time, but thinking about what Jake is saying I understand how any moderately good Hydra could plan and stage this.
Dramatic. What made you turn? Because I'm starting to fall that way too. But I still don't particularly like Shroomish.
You have absolutely nothing to add over the last 3 pages?
I disagree. I think laying out thought process from both heads is a solid town tactic and shows they're not afraid of hiding their opinions at all. Being so blatantly dissonant, whilst it might not be your cup of tea, shows very little "behind the scenes" planning and I feel this is coming from a town mindset, rather than scum manipulation.In post 435, Jake from State Farm wrote:Real hydra dissonance with a town hydra IMO would do their best to hash it out behind the scenes in their QT and would include explanations for why they disagree with each other's reads
dont worry my loveIn post 432, PhDScar wrote:Well this dancing around the bush has already painted quite a target on my back so you might as well provide some evidence you aren't scum.
VOTE: HKC
Seems playstyle-dependent IMO. Unless there is past history of this hydra acting the way you think a town hydra should, I don't agree that town hydras automatically behave that way.In post 435, Jake from State Farm wrote:Real hydra dissonance with a town hydra IMO would do their best to hash it out behind the scenes in their QT and would include explanations for why they disagree with each other's reads
Tonally posts 407, 409and 412 felt sleazy and manipulative. There was other stuff earlier, but I could see it coming from town-Jake on one of his hobby-horses. But at that point he crossed over into the territory I associate with his scum game. He started playing to the crowd.In post 436, Mac wrote:Dramatic. What made you turn? Because I'm starting to fall that way too. But I still don't particularly like Shroomish.
Dodger has the most swag.In post 401, sangres wrote:your new avatar is disturbing.
Jake just came out of a game where scum-him and scum-dramonic cross-bussed each other for the entire game. AD was also in that game, so I want his opinion on whether he's getting the same feeling from the nature of Jake's push here as he did in that game.In post 434, Kdub wrote:What makes you think they could be scum together?
Yo, talk to me.In post 438, ActionDan wrote:Should've lynched scar when you guys had the chance.