NY 172: Another Large Normal (GAME OVER)

[Snork]

I just don't understand why we had TWO shooting deaths. It fucking bothers me. SK shouldn't be shooting. SK should be knifing or something. Garroting. Strangling. Something. Not shooting.

And if kill flavor is not allowed to be differential, than I can detect any killing role, and thus am more powerful than a cop. I find that hard to believe.

IF the SK has a gun - which is fucking stupid imo - then I could see AP and penguin being one of each mafia and SK. If this is true, I think it's more likely that AP is the SK and penguin is the mafia, knowing that I am a threat and attempting to eliminate me. Using AP to do it is just a means to [my] end for her. At any rate, penguin is not "obvtown" and neither was I. That is a silly statement.

p-edit: Ohh I see. Weird. And if that's so, why would mod then make SK have a gun? That seems incongruent with his style

[AngryPidgeon]

Guys 6 is the Serial Killer. Guess I can tell ya'll that much.

[AngryPidgeon]

But I mean really its pretty obvious even without my additional info.

[Egg]

Why can't SK shoot? I think you're reading too much into it.

[AngryPidgeon]

This is why Gunsmith needs to be more standardized for normals.

But 6 is confirmed SK, trust me on this one.

[SiX]

Lmao AP. So desperate.

[Egg]

[quote="In post 2754trust me[/quote]

Why?

[Egg]

/tagfail

[Snork]

Egg, because it doesn't make sense and I have to figure it out or I'm going to go nuts.

p-edit: Why are you saying this, AP? Just trying to introduce WIFOM, get another townie killed? Nothing you say is reliable. Go away.

[AngryPidgeon]

Lmao AP. So desperate.

No, Im just benefiting my team by getting the SK outted on my way down.

I guess everyone will have to accept that I dont want to spill more than I have to, but ya hes guilty and probably BP.

[Egg]

Snork, You're overthinking...

[Egg]

AP, was Six the intended kill N1?

[AngryPidgeon]

No, we killed Zdenek. Hes lying about his role though.

[Snork]

And aptil/SiX being a standard vig is a thought that has also crossed my mind several times. If I were a vig, I might also claim 1-shot in hopes the mafia would leave me alone. The JOAT claim on top of it is dumb though and I don't know what to think about that, especially given RM's JOAT claim plus her conf status. Makes SiX's JOAT claim less likely in a Normal.

SiX - if this is the case, and you ARE a standard vig -

stop fucking shooting please

.

p-edit: How does outing the SK benefit your team, other than possibly sparing yourselves night death? SK is in the same boat as town as far as reads are concerned, and are just as likely to NOT hit your partners as a town vig is. If anything, his presence in the game is a BONUS as it increases the number of possible town deaths each night.

And if you suspected him of being SK why didn't you kill him last night?

[AngryPidgeon]

Because the SK is a good lynch for literally everyone that isnt the SK??????

This really isnt rocket science.

[SiX]

I haven't shot anyone. Aptil wasted my bullet before I even had the chance -.-

[Snork]

AP, the fact that you aren't trolling us to death tells me your partners are in majority town lists and don't have a reason to be worried....

[Egg]

I dunno, the odds of a new player thinking to claim two-shot JOAT as SK in a game where Rach is also a confirmed two-shot JOAT who had yet to claim when Six did are pretty low in my opinion. I'm kinda thinking Six pretty much has to be telling the truth here.

AP, what are you saying? He was rolecopped and didn't come up JOAT?

Preview edit: Snork, stop overthinking.

[Snork]

Egg: Stop underthinking. Go read some of APs games and get back to me.

[AngryPidgeon]

@Egg: Im not going to claim HOW we know, but we do.

[AngryPidgeon]

AP, the fact that you aren't trolling us to death tells me your partners are in majority town lists and don't have a reason to be worried....

You should read Antihero Mafia.

I fakeda guilty on Thor665 and was confirmed scum the next Day when he flipped town. That was my finest hour.

[Egg]

Snork, I've played with AP. Two possibilities. He knows Six to be SK and wants us to lynch him or he wants Six lynched regardless because he's not mafia. That or he's hard-distancing I guess. Either way, you shouldn't read too much into what scum say on their way down because right now AP knows that we know he is scum.

[Snork]

That's the one I'm thinking of.

p-edit: I know.

[AngryPidgeon]

Snork, I've played with AP. Two possibilities. He knows Six to be SK and wants us to lynch him or he wants Six lynched regardless because he's not mafia. That or he's hard-distancing I guess. Either way, you shouldn't read too much into what scum say on their way down because right now AP knows that we know he is scum.

Glad to know I have a reputation for being unpredictable

But I mean seriously. I could make a case but Im just feeling lazy right now. His claim progression looks fake because it is though >.>

[AngryPidgeon]

It was my idea to look into him last night.