Mini 1566: Lunar Silver Star Story Complete (Game Over)

[Mac]

Vote: Shroomish

I'm going back here. My lean-townread has been utterly obliterated over the course of this page.

Mac, did you get scum this game? This post is bad :/

You can explain why if you want, meanwhile here's why my townread was decimated. Shroomish agreed with sangres townread of me a few pages back, preceded to never mention me again until the vote and, despite two people asking,

is still yet to explain his vote.

This is a characteristic I'd associate with newish scum who forget how they faked their reads and I think it ties in here - since he hasn't given a direct read on me, he's forgotten that he agreed with sangres townread of me. The "shit, 24 hours" comment followed by starting a brand, shiny new wagon felt extremely fake and the lack of explanation & follow up to it has left me feeling rather uneasy with the whole thing.

Vote: Shroomish

[Mac]

FU, sangres. SMP was at 5 votes way earlier in the game. Where were you on that bandwagon then?

We have one day left. Please explain to us why HS should be kept alive.

You explain why he shouldn't.

His vote on Mac was bad, but it doesn't look scummy to us.

And why you are not willing to vote for him now.

We're generally not in favor of lynching townreads. I know, it's a radical idea, but it might just catch on.

I'm a bit mystified as to why you haven't called out Shroomish for the lack of following up to your request for an explanation to be honest.

I'm also curious as to how you see the vote as not scummy, because I'm seeing the total opposite here.

[sangres]

FU, sangres. SMP was at 5 votes way earlier in the game. Where were you on that bandwagon then?

We have one day left. Please explain to us why HS should be kept alive.

You explain why he shouldn't.

His vote on Mac was bad, but it doesn't look scummy to us.

And why you are not willing to vote for him now.

We're generally not in favor of lynching townreads. I know, it's a radical idea, but it might just catch on.

I'm a bit mystified as to why you haven't called out Shroomish for the lack of following up to your request for an explanation to be honest.

I'm also curious as to how you see the vote as not scummy, because I'm seeing the total opposite here.

I thought it was pretty obvious what the vote was about from his post to PhDScar.

Though an explicit explanation wouldn't go amiss, Shroom.

[Mac]

I'm incredibly surprised you buy it.

[sangres]

He's a relatively inexperienced player who hails from Cabd's homesite.

[Mac]

Does that mean gambits are frequent over yonder?

Regardless, had Scar included a reason, we'd be left with ".............." as a result. I don't buy it, I think it's a cheap excuse at trying to get out of jail free.

[sangres]

We still think he looks town, Mac.

My understanding is that gambits are pretty frequent. And from what I've seen in other games (this is my 2nd game with him, and I've also run into him once or twice via metaing players) he's a sponge, picking up ideas, techniques, philosophies from other players he's come into contact with. I saw some stuff from the game we played show up in another game shortly thereafter.

His play has a rough-edged aggressive feel to it that reminds me of newer players who have won a town game or two.

I suppose we could be misreading that. But, I don't want to lynch him today.

[ActionDan]

Scar is scum. That'll be my contribution to this game

[borkjerfkin]

Votecount 1.19

[6] HighShroomish (Kdub, SMP, Aegor, Jake From State Farm, PhDScar, Mac)
[3] PhDScar (ActionDan, ???, HighShroomish)
[2] SMP (BROseidon, sangres)
[1] Antihero (Aj The Epic)
[1] Aj The Epic (Antihero)
[1] Kdub (Hello Kitty Creampuff)

With 13 alive, it is 7 to lynch.

Let me know if you see any problems.

Deadline is in (expired on 2014-04-25 23:00:00)

[borkjerfkin]

Antihero was prodded.

[Jake from State Farm]

Shroom claim please

[Antihero]

prodded /bleh

no time right now

[BROseidon]

Vote: Shroomish

I'm going back here. My lean-townread has been utterly obliterated over the course of this page.

Mac, did you get scum this game? This post is bad :/

You can explain why if you want, meanwhile here's why my townread was decimated. Shroomish agreed with sangres townread of me a few pages back, preceded to never mention me again until the vote and, despite two people asking,

is still yet to explain his vote.

This is a characteristic I'd associate with newish scum who forget how they faked their reads and I think it ties in here - since he hasn't given a direct read on me, he's forgotten that he agreed with sangres townread of me. The "shit, 24 hours" comment followed by starting a brand, shiny new wagon felt extremely fake and the lack of explanation & follow up to it has left me feeling rather uneasy with the whole thing.

Vote: Shroomish

It's how strongly you stated the read was destroyed, despite the fact that it wasn't a strong read in the first place.

[sangres]

12 hours, and I'm fairly sure every question I have to ask is the following:

Why is Shroom getting lynched over SMP?
Why is Antihero lurking?

[sangres]

assume shroom is scum and jake's town. why would shroom ask for a counterclaim? he knew he wouldn't get one.

What? The whole point of scum-HS asking for a claim is to find out Jake's role. The "looking for a counterclaim" stuff I think he made up as an excuse. That's why I was asking him about what he would do if there were no counterclaim, and I don't think he's given a good answer.

My initial thought was also to ask for a claim so that Jake would be forced into claiming a specific role: I think town motivation behind asking for someone to expand upon a PR claim is pretty fucking obvious and not completely and totally scum motivated like you're pretending it must be.

I also think you know that, but have decided to take this line of attack because it sounds awkward and you think you have a decent line of attack as scum.

[Antihero]

because i had an overdose of this game when i replaced in and i had to get the hell away from it for a bit

[sangres]

Vote: Shroomish

I'm going back here. My lean-townread has been utterly obliterated over the course of this page.

Because it is inconsistent? Because it goes against his earlier read and is abrupt? Why do you think that scum-Shroomish attempts to start a new wagon right before deadline on someone that currently has no votes on him?

[sangres]

because i had an overdose of this game when i replaced in and i had to get the hell away from it for a bit

AJ isn't getting lynched. Vote SMP.

[Antihero]

VOTE: kdub

the shroom lynch is suboptimal

[Antihero]

because i had an overdose of this game when i replaced in and i had to get the hell away from it for a bit

AJ isn't getting lynched. Vote SMP.

smp...
what for?

[sangres]

HS where the fuck are you?

Watching.

Also, what's the motivation for this...?
It pretty clearly seems like shitty town gambit city here: I can't see scum drawing so much attention to themselves for absolutely no reason.

[sangres]

Like, absolutely no reason. He's not getting a mislynch. He's not buddying up to someone and sheeping their vote. He's not discrediting an attacker. He's just doing it.

[sangres]

because i had an overdose of this game when i replaced in and i had to get the hell away from it for a bit

AJ isn't getting lynched. Vote SMP.

smp...
what for?

Do you think he's town?

[sangres]

houston we have a problem here, I like a Shroom wagon but i don't like the people who are on it

That's because the wagon sucksand you probably shouldn't be on it.

[Antihero]

well, no. and i now remember how much i hated 822

VOTE: SMP