He gave the reasoning that he wanted to see if anyone counter claimed. I think the intent is the same: PR claim is no risk for scum!Jake, forcing him to claim a specific role is added risk for scum!Jake. Do you seriously not see that?In post 988, Kdub wrote:That's a fine reason to ask Jake for a claim if you are town, butIn post 964, sangres wrote:My initial thought was also to ask for a claim so that Jake would be forced into claiming a specific role: I think town motivation behind asking for someone to expand upon a PR claim is pretty fucking obvious and not completely and totally scum motivated like you're pretending it must be.
I also think you know that, but have decided to take this line of attack because it sounds awkward and you think you have a decent line of attack as scum.that wasn't the reason HS gave. I'm not saying town motivation can't exist, I'm saying that the line of reasoning HS took was not town-motivated. Your argument here is irrelevant to what he actually posted, which you decided to ignore for some reason and instead ascribed some hypothetical town-motivated reasoning to his actions.
Which sangres head am I talking to BTW? Are you both in agreement about your reads on HS/SMP/me?
We are in agreement about our reads.
