Mini 1566: Lunar Silver Star Story Complete (Game Over)

[borkjerfkin]

Votecount 1.21

[6] HighShroomish (Kdub, SMP, Aegor, Jake From State Farm, PhDScar, Mac)
[3] PhDScar (ActionDan, ???, HighShroomish)
[3] SMP (BROseidon, sangres, Antihero)
[1] Antihero (Aj The Epic)
[1] Kdub (Hello Kitty Creampuff)

With 13 alive, it is 7 to lynch.

Let me know if you see any problems.

Deadline is in (expired on 2014-04-25 23:00:00)

[Aegor]

I am absolutely unwilling to move my vote from HS.

And sangres, your effort to derail the HS wagon is total shit and by far the scummiest thing that has happened in this game.

You explain why he shouldn't.

Because he has done nothing to merit continued existence in this game.

And you never addressed your conspicuous and inexplicable absence on the SMP wagon earlier.

Is there any wagon you DON'T like? I believe you've been fine with almost every wagon and have voted as such. Your vote hopping and willingness still is worrisome to say the least.

Right now? Any wagon that is not HS.

12 hours, and I'm fairly sure every question I have to ask is the following:

Why is Shroom getting lynched over SMP?
Why is Antihero lurking?

Why should SMP be lynched over shroom?

And I am expecting a really compelling reason as to why SMP is suddenly so scummy that he merits a deadline wagon, given the complete absence of any such suggestion in your posting history, which is below.

Spoiler:

So I want SMP dead, and then HS. Also catboi.

Why do you want SMP dead?

We really should be lynching hkc/smp/shroom guaranteed 2 scum in this pool

and your reasons for thinking smp and shroom could be part of a team are?

SMP is becoming a pretty distinct concern.

(such a big concern, I add, that he has not ever received a vote from sangres, including at any point during the SMP wagon).

SMP is a maybe, which could firm up tonight, but I doubt it.

His sitewide activity this week looks pretty sparse. His posts so far are troubling, though.

So forgive me for questioning the motivation and legitimacy of this deadline push.

[HighShroomish]

Holy shit don't give sangres town cred if/when I'm lynched. Aegor has a very good point.

UNVOTE

I don't know who to vote, but here are my reads. I probably won't be able to get back to this tonight.
In no particular order
Scum
sangres
PhD
Null-scum
Aegor(I didn't like your vote very much)
Jake
Null
SMP
Kdub
Mac
AJ
Null-town
HKC
BROseidon
Town
Anti
Bleh fine

VOTE: SANGRES

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

Please claim

/mobile

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

Dude, we have 5 hours, join one of the counter wagons, don't make any new ones

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

And, have you even read the past couple pages aegor? it's pretty clear why she wants smp over shroom

[HighShroomish]

I thought I'd already said VT. Apparently not.
And fine.

UNVOTE
VOTE: PhD

NOW I'm gone.

[sangres]

I am absolutely unwilling to move my vote from HS.

And sangres, your effort to derail the HS wagon is total shit and by far the scummiest thing that has happened in this game.

You explain why he shouldn't.

Because he has done nothing to merit continued existence in this game.

And you never addressed your conspicuous and inexplicable absence on the SMP wagon earlier.

Because we weren't scumreading him earlier. He's not our strongest scumread now, but he's a hell of a lot more scummy looking to us than Shroom is. And pushing our stronger scum reads has gone nowhere, but we're still pushing for our strongest scum read lynched in the middle of this compromise effort.

12 hours, and I'm fairly sure every question I have to ask is the following:

Why is Shroom getting lynched over SMP?
Why is Antihero lurking?

Why should SMP be lynched over shroom?

And I am expecting a really compelling reason as to why SMP is suddenly so scummy that he merits a deadline wagon, given the complete absence of any such suggestion in your posting history, which is below.

Spoiler:

So I want SMP dead, and then HS. Also catboi.

Why do you want SMP dead?

We really should be lynching hkc/smp/shroom guaranteed 2 scum in this pool

and your reasons for thinking smp and shroom could be part of a team are?

SMP is becoming a pretty distinct concern.

(such a big concern, I add, that he has not ever received a vote from sangres, including at any point during the SMP wagon).

SMP is a maybe, which could firm up tonight, but I doubt it.

His sitewide activity this week looks pretty sparse. His posts so far are troubling, though.

So forgive me for questioning the motivation and legitimacy of this deadline push.

You have zero credibility questioning anyone's vote changes in this game. You've repeatedly jumped from wagon to wagon with no explanation, and yet with the clear pattern of always moving a large wagon closer to lynch. I described it as a ratchet effect and that's what your votes have accomplished this day.

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

Now answer my question with a answer that actually makes fucking sense.

Why did you not try to lynch kdub if he was one of your top lynch candidates? And don't give me the bullshit about you only having 1 vote.

He was trying to lynch aj, who was another of his top scum reads.

[Aegor]

And, have you even read the past couple pages aegor? it's pretty clear why she wants smp over shroom

That is completely irrelevant to anything I was saying. It is also worth noting that said explanations occurred after the vote.

Because we weren't scumreading him earlier.

And why are you now? None of the reasons you posted involved anything that had changed between the momentum on SMP and now. You missed your chance, and it is surprising that you would not bother attempting to form a read when the wagon was viable in the first place.

He's not our strongest scumread now, but he's a hell of a lot more scummy looking to us than Shroom is.

What about shroom seems town to you?

You have zero credibility questioning anyone's vote changes in this game.

Which I never did, so there is no issue.

You've repeatedly jumped from wagon to wagon with no explanation, and yet with the clear pattern of always moving a large wagon closer to lynch.

Absolutely true.

I described it as a ratchet effect and that's what your votes have accomplished this day.

Well, feel free to lynch me tomorrow. Today, vote for HS.

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

I thought I'd already said VT. Apparently not.
And fine.

UNVOTE
VOTE: PhD

NOW I'm gone.

Actually, do me a solid and vote for kdub. Assuming youre still here.

[Antihero]

VOTE: kdub

come on, shroom, he's in your "nullscum"

[Jake from State Farm]

Now answer my question with a answer that actually makes fucking sense.

Why did you not try to lynch kdub if he was one of your top lynch candidates? And don't give me the bullshit about you only having 1 vote.

He was trying to lynch aj, who was another of his top scum reads.

Right so when shroom gets to L-1 he changes to kdub for 6 minutes and then votes smp AND THEN bitches about how we are letting kdub slide?

That makes no sense since. I could see him getting mad at people for AJ since that's where he had his serious vote but kdubs makes literally 0 sense

[Jake from State Farm]

And smh at my typos

[Antihero]

i changed to kdub since i thought sangres was still on him (that would have made it 3 votes to my ineffective one), but i moved again when i realized they moved over to SMP (that would make it 3 votes to my ineffective two on the kdub).

and i've been calling kdub scum since i replaced in so i'm not sure how it "makes literally 0 sense".

and i'm bitching that you're giving kdub the mislynch he's going for. the one

he's

pushing (that you are an accessory to)

i'm confused about why

you're

confused.

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

Fucking context

[Jake from State Farm]

Ok smp has logged on twice today. 11 this morning and 2 in the afternoon. F this fool

vote: smp

This is the only other wagon I'll consider. Pick 1

P.edit - if you can't understand why I'm confused you are either scum or [redacted]

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

I dunno if he is capable of connecting series of events to context

[Jake from State Farm]

and i've been calling kdub scum since i replaced in so i'm not sure how it "makes literally 0 sense".

Cause you never seriously voted him but you saying we are letting him slide implies you were trying hard to lynch him. You made no serious attempt so you scolding us or whatever was unwarranted.

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

Do you even listen to what you're saying, Jake?

[Jake from State Farm]

I do and I a making perfect sense.

[Aegor]

I probably will not be posting in this game anymore ever except to avoid prod dodges.

[Antihero]

that's 3 for SMP, i'd switch so effectively 4
2 on kdub, but we have sangres, so effectively 3

both are a pretty long way off.

phd, mac, actiondan. are you here?

[Antihero]

here's the post in question:

why is it "odd"? we've been talking about shroom for a while now so don't act like this shroom townread is something new

cause it feels desperate

that's because it is

we're watching scumbag kdub completely get away with a mislynch and it's maddening

i'm calling kdub scum
i'm calling shroom town

i'm trying to reason with you and bring you to my side, and i think it's frustrating because you're personally invested and i think it's clouding your judgement of shrooms and (consequently) kdub.

kdub wasn't (and still probably isn't) a viable wagon which is why i'm not voting him, but with what i thought was the most viable counter, SMP.
if you're wondering why i wasn't voting kdub before, it's because i was trying to push an aj lynch. this is now completely not viable.

if you think it's a personal attack
if you think i'm somehow way out of line by questioning you
if you're butthurt at this post

...take a reality and/or ego check

[ActionDan]

VOTE: Kdub

acceptable