partly, it was because of what i perceived you "claimed" yesterday.In post 1317, Kdub wrote:Anti, you suspected me pretty heavily yesterday, and I believe more people suspected me than SMP, so why not block me instead?
like let us assume i am his scum buddy and he claims a result on me because i won't say it's wrong (even though i probably would because lololbus but whatever)kdub wrote:It guarantees his investigation result will be confirmed (even if it's a lie). If Anti had turned out to be a tracker or something and confirmed that SMP didn't actually target you, you are not implicated and say SMP just made a lucky guess.
was the cop claim serious? i assumed jokesangres wrote:If we hadn't had a strong town read on PhDScar we would have investigated you last night because lolparanoia.
I had planned to just crumb it, hence my first post. Nacho wanted to make it explicit.In post 1326, zMuffinMan wrote:was the cop claim serious? i assumed joke
You are always welcome to stop signing up for games I've /inned.In post 1327, Jake from State Farm wrote:why not kdub? you wanted him lynched and then you changed your read but neither was solid
bro was obv town imo
or for god sakes investigate HK or me or even aegor or AJ
so many better people than bro
guess I'm just going to have to burn you more, then!In post 1324, sangres wrote:Because BRO can play a very subtle and hard to spot scum game, and he hadn't done anything awesomely town on day 1. And if he's town his analysis should be more valuable than what at least half the player list will put into the thread.In post 1322, Jake from State Farm wrote:you still didn't explain why you wasted your investigation on bro
that literally makes no sense
Of all the players in the game we felt like he and muffin are the trickiest to read. Muffin did us the favor of replacing into a slot we already thought was town.
Bro's alignment is our gift to future game days.
so I question your investigation choice and you tell me i should not play with you anymore? seriously wtfIn post 1329, sangres wrote:You are always welcome to stop signing up for games I've /inned.
three, technically. Jake can learn who has actions if all PR's target him, but why not considering the pretty heavy limitation he has?In post 1326, zMuffinMan wrote:like let us assume i am his scum buddy and he claims a result on me because i won't say it's wrong (even though i probably would because lololbus but whatever)kdub wrote:It guarantees his investigation result will be confirmed (even if it's a lie). If Anti had turned out to be a tracker or something and confirmed that SMP didn't actually target you, you are not implicated and say SMP just made a lucky guess.
whether or not i confirm his result doesn't make him any more or less likely to be scum/town than he was beforehand
so essentially to think i'm scum with him would require him (a) knowing he was roleblocked, (b) thinking it was a good idea to claim a result anyway, and (c) thinking claiming a result on a scum buddy would somehow clear him or help me
i mean, not only that but it would severely limit my fake-claiming options (which is something i would bus the fuck out of him for purely out of spite if he did that to me) AND it assumes i replaced in that night phase and didn't talk him through all the possible options in case he'd have to claim today (which is something i would definitely do, because that is how i play scum)
sooooooooo yeah
was the cop claim serious? i assumed jokesangres wrote:If we hadn't had a strong town read on PhDScar we would have investigated you last night because lolparanoia.
i'd prob lynch SMP purely because i doubt town has two investigative PRs if your claim is actually serious
what about it?cream wrote:why not considering the pretty heavy limitation he has?
OK, fair enough.In post 1325, Antihero wrote:partly, it was because of what i perceived you "claimed" yesterday.In post 1317, Kdub wrote:Anti, you suspected me pretty heavily yesterday, and I believe more people suspected me than SMP, so why not block me instead?
also, the popular opinion swung pretty rapidly in your favor yesterday. i figured that even if you were scum, you would want to keep this new-found good standing and not risk blowing it to a tracker/watcher/roleblocker result.
I think having his result confirmed gives him some town credit, but I see your argument here.In post 1326, zMuffinMan wrote:like let us assume i am his scum buddy and he claims a result on me because i won't say it's wrong (even though i probably would because lololbus but whatever)
whether or not i confirm his result doesn't make him any more or less likely to be scum/town than he was beforehand
so essentially to think i'm scum with him would require him (a) knowing he was roleblocked, (b) thinking it was a good idea to claim a result anyway, and (c) thinking claiming a result on a scum buddy would somehow clear him or help me
i mean, not only that but it would severely limit my fake-claiming options (which is something i would bus the fuck out of him for purely out of spite if he did that to me) AND it assumes i replaced in that night phase and didn't talk him through all the possible options in case he'd have to claim today (which is something i would definitely do, because that is how i play scum)
sooooooooo yeah
What's the scum motivation for clearing BRO the way they did?In post 1336, Jake from State Farm wrote:because the real cop wouldn't out an inno day 2. I mean we tell newbies not to do that so why would an experience player do it?
I"ll Nall. My exact role is Odd-Night Rolecop and Reporter. Yes, you're correct. A PR would return the role name while a VT/goon would only return that they're Vanilla.In post 1317, Kdub wrote: SMP, can you claim your flavor name and confirm that your role is specifically called "odd-night role cop and reporter"? And to confirm exactly how your role works, if you were to investigate a PR (of either alignment), you would get their actual role (e.g. "cop", "doctor", "roleblocker", etc.), but if you investigate a VT/goon, you get "vanilla"?
not really!kdub wrote:I think having his result confirmed gives him some town credit
since I think almost everyone is scum and I am the lone townieIn post 1346, zMuffinMan wrote:is mac scum