Mini 1566: Lunar Silver Star Story Complete (Game Over)

[Aegor]

Aegor, in light of Aj's replace-out, are you still reading that slot as scum? Why or why not?

Yes, although now obviously the replacement may lessen that read.

[Squirrel Girl]

Hellooooooooooooo!

So far I have read Page 59 (and 60 too, for what that one is worth). It will take me a while to finish reading the rest because I read slow and am distracted by shiny objects. A general question for starters; why is everyone sounding so glum and worn out? It's Day 3 and there has been a scum lynch...isn't that happy fun-times? Or at least "par-for-the-course" times? What's the doom and gloom about?

[Kdub]

VOTE: AJ

So you think AJ will flip town? Really?

Why should I vote HKC over AJ?

So yeah. Hkc will flip scum.

Why are you more confident in HKC than in AJ?

Cause AJ hasn't done anything scummy and hkc hasn't done anything townie

At this point in the game, I think it is fair to say that those who have not done anything town should be under suspicion. What has AJ done that is clearly town? What has HKC done that is clearly scum? You seem to have a level of conviction that is not merited by the evidence you have put forward.

These are the posts where you vote Aj and suggest that he is scum. No reason is given until 1402, where you seem to be saying that you suspect Aj because he hasn't done anything town. So now that we know he was inactive because of RL stuff, why do you still read that slot as scum?

[zMuffinMan]

i don't think activity is related to lack of town posting, though

i had a gut scum read on AJ slot for his post in the last day phase. 'twas very awkward

the fact he only posted once means nothing to me

[zMuffinMan]

i know i'm answering someone else's question, but since it's based on what i think is a misinterpretation anyway, those are my thoughts

[Squirrel Girl]

I finished Day 1, I will admit to a *lot* of skimming thus far, so I don't have a ton of opinions yet. I'd currently lean a Muffin, KDUB, or Kitty lynch. I will admit to a lot of mental doubt on the Kitty read. I think Sangres was the only one who was obv. towning that day in light of the flips and...well...duh. Isn't Squirrel clever? BRO also seems likely town with the way SMP interacted with him. I have a mild townread on Jake for the way he went after SMP and the way SMP felt placating back at him - felt more like a town/scum than a scum/scum interaction to me as opposed to how the Aegor one went.

The new posts on this page don't really change any of my thoughts much.

[Squirrel Girl]

Actually, maybe I lied, let's toss Aegor into the scumspicion pile and move Kdub to a place less suspect than that though more than Kitty. Though there may be some basic 'whelp, you're voting town' attitude from me there, or omgus if we want to make it official and go on a date over the read. But, y'know, that post feels like a decent one in relation to me knowing my own role PM, so I'll make that claim but don't want to debate it with anyone.

[Squirrel Girl]

Let's make Kdub the same as Kitty actually. I'm really awkward on that one. I'll shut up now.

[Jake from State Farm]

vote: mac

when smp was getting run up the first time, he had like 5 votes and mac was defensive of smp and trying to smear my name. He also was lightly defensive of SMP during the anti/smp claim thing but said smp is the only viable lynch. Given smp fliped a scum pr, this defense stands out to me.

The people most likely partners with SMP are in the group of mac/hkc/zmuffinman with mac/zmuffin the most likely pair.

Looking at the interactions between the 3, smp/mac/zmuffin REALLY make sense. Somebody check my work

[zMuffinMan]

your work sucks

[Jake from State Farm]

figures you would say that.

[zMuffinMan]

well to be fair, you could be right about mac, but other than that, your work sucks

[Jake from State Farm]

figures you would say that.

[Squirrel Girl]

Looking at the interactions between the 3, smp/mac/zmuffin REALLY make sense. Somebody check my work

Not sure if I buy into Mac.

Want to run up Muffin instead? I buy into Muffin.

[Squirrel Girl]

And looks like I'm not even voting and no one is voting Muffin.

Vote: Muffin

C'mon, I have a fluffy tail!

[zMuffinMan]

is this what your scum game looks like, squirrel girl

[Jake from State Farm]

the scar/smp/mac interactions are the most intriguing. Nothing you have done conributed to this decision at all other than you just trolling and shitting up the thread trying to distract people.

Look at the Scar wagon from d1 - [6] PhDScar (Aj The Epic,

catboi, ActionDan, BROseidon,

Aegor,

???

Aegor was on both scar and smp wagons early enough so he gets a slight town nod though his play has been kind of shit. This is a mostly town led wagon

Here is the 1st SMP wagon - [5] SMP (

???

, Aegor,

Jake From State Farm, BROseidon,

Hello Kitty Creampuff) This is all mostly town led wagon

Here is the day 2 wagon of smp - [6] SMP (

sangres

, Aegor,

Antihero, Jake From State Farm

, Kdub, Hello Kitty Creampuff) - mostly town led

that is why HKC is on the list cause bussing is possble, I guess I can also put kdub in there but i'm not sold on kdub


so actually scum is in the group of Mac/zmuffin/Kdub/HKC

[zMuffinMan]

right so you think AJ slot who showed up on my wagon but never on the scum wagon is town for magical reasons

yeah i'm so surprised nobody is listening to you

you're wise beyond belief

[Jake from State Farm]

I never said he was town, the bolded are town.

your reaction makes me think I am right. Instead of actually processing and doing your own work your reaction is to slander me.

mac/zmuffin are my only 2 lynch candidates and hkc and just go throw himself off a cliff

[Jake from State Farm]

townies will actually read and process even if someone is accusing them

scum will naturally try to deflect/discredit

[zMuffinMan]

so actually scum is in the group of Mac/zmuffin/Kdub/HKC

implies AJ was town, dipshit

[zMuffinMan]

like wow, you're a fucking genius and anyone who doesn't listen to you is mental

i'm going to continue listening to your words of wisdom all game!

even though i think you're very likely to be night killed tonight because you're incredibly smart and good at this game and leaving you alive will be bad for scum!

[Jake from State Farm]

it's also noteworthy that the only people trying to do stuff are people who are most likely town meanwhile zmuffin and mac are waiting to see where they can hop on and not be suspicious. Townies would be trying harder to find scum, especially when townies have the edge.

so go ahead and berate me, insult me, slander my name, or do whatever it is you think you can to distract town away from you but I guarantee if the other townies actually do their own work they will probably come to a similar conclusion.

[Jake from State Farm]

so actually scum is in the group of Mac/zmuffin/Kdub/HKC

implies AJ was town, dipshit

please don't call me another name or insult me again.

[Jake from State Farm]

and since the new girl already saw what I was seeing and is voting zmuffin

vote: zmuffin