Mini 1566: Lunar Silver Star Story Complete (Game Over)

[Jake from State Farm]

If I actually thought people would come around and vote them. I would.

Nobody seemed to notice they went into lurk mode when the heat came off them. But whatever. I'm here playing the game with townies who have no interest lynching actual scum.

[Squirrel Girl]

Well, I'm willing to shout at them with you now, I'm pretty scary. *rawr*

Also, your stance seems to be "oh, yeah, defs they are scum - but I don't feel like trying to push througha lynch" Which, c'mon man, that's just lazy! You have a cool red shirt, people will listen to you!

[Squirrel Girl]

It's just a pastry - we can take it!

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

If I actually thought people would come around and vote them. I would.

Nobody seemed to notice they went into lurk mode when the heat came off them. But whatever. I'm here playing the game with townies who have no interest lynching actual scum.

Don't even fucking try to pull this shit, regardless of your alignment. Just don't. I mean, you should check my activity site-wide first, before you do so, because it would be glaring obvious that I post in all my games at the same fucking time

[Aegor]

I think you're confusing a chainsaw defense on SMP with my scumread on HS.

I am asserting that your attack on HS is not actually because you scumread him but was at least in part a chainsaw.

At the time, you didn't call neither a chainsaw defense and it appears like you're using a scumflip to your advantage 'cause you've found a link between me and SMP.

Are you suggesting that I ignore the scumflip? If not, then I fail to see how it is inappropriate to use newly-acquired information to interpret prior events.

[Aegor]

VOTE: HKC

Other lynch candidates are {Mac, SG}. SG has done nothing to counter AJ's lurky scumminess.

Am not liking KDub based on gut -- does anyone have a townread on him?

[Jake from State Farm]

If I actually thought people would come around and vote them. I would.

Nobody seemed to notice they went into lurk mode when the heat came off them. But whatever. I'm here playing the game with townies who have no interest lynching actual scum.

Don't even fucking try to pull this shit, regardless of your alignment. Just don't. I mean, you should check my activity site-wide first, before you do so, because it would be glaring obvious that I post in all my games at the same fucking time

I just did.

vote: hkc

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

no

[Jake from State Farm]

I mean you said you were going to catch up when there wasn't anything to catch up on and then you didn't even catch up. Nor have you even attempted to do anything that remotely looks like trying to find scum. Obviously that means you aren't trying to find scum which means you are scum.

It's pretty simple really

[Jake from State Farm]

no

[Kdub]

I kinda just want to sheep confirmed town-BRO at this point, but he's not doing much either.

I looked at Aj/SG/Mac ISOs again, and didn't have any big revelations. I still thought Aj's D1 stuff felt town, and his lack of activity later seems understandable due to RL stuff. SG has been OK so far. The biggest issues I see are Mac accusing SG of misrepping his lack of activity in her summary of the neighborhood (which SG responded to and Mac hasn't countered yet), and Aj basically saying "I don't care about this game, my claim will save me anyway" and Mac just accepting that (which is weird, but I don't see obvious scum motivation either way). I'd probably pick SG as town between the two of them if it came down to it.

VOTE: HKC

Every time I start suspecting Aegor because he makes some bad posts, he says something that gives me a gut town feel. Then he makes more bad posts and I start suspecting him again. Hate his HKC vote here, just like I've hated a lot of his vote hops this game.

I'm thinking one scum in Aj/Mac, the other in HKC/Aegor, with an outside chance of Muffin-scum and a very very outside chance of Jake/Anti as scum.

VOTE: Aegor for now, at least until Mac gets here and he and SG figure out who's misrepping what.

[Antihero]

Am not liking KDub based on gut -- does anyone have a townread on him?

no

and the softclaim's not doing it for me any more.

[Squirrel Girl]

SG has done nothing to counter AJ's lurky scumminess.

AJ did actually replace out - that sort of makes his lurk probably honest regardless of if he was scum or town. Is there any scum case on him besides lurking? Because I don't think that's much of a case to throw at someone who replaced out.

The biggest issues I see are Mac accusing SG of misrepping his lack of activity in her summary of the neighborhood (which SG responded to and Mac hasn't countered yet)

He also hasn't posted since I said what I said. So, it's not like he's dodging per se', so why are you calling him out on it?

Also, with Aegor/HKC as one possible pair, what made you choose Aegor over HKC considering the current wagon activity?

[Aegor]

AJ did actually replace out - that sort of makes his lurk probably honest regardless of if he was scum or town. Is there any scum case on him besides lurking? Because I don't think that's much of a case to throw at someone who replaced out.

1) This game started just over a month ago. At no point was AJ not lurking. His recent replace out does not address the several weeks of no content.
2) People who lurk produce little/no content, and therefore you question about whether there is any other scum case is impossible to answer, since other scum cases require content, of which AJ has deprived us.

[Kdub]

He also hasn't posted since I said what I said. So, it's not like he's dodging per se', so why are you calling him out on it?

Also, with Aegor/HKC as one possible pair, what made you choose Aegor over HKC considering the current wagon activity?

I'm not "calling him out"? I said he hasn't addressed it, which is true, so I'm interested to see his response. I'm not saying he's scum because of it.

I've consistently felt worse about Aegor than HKC all game, primarily because of his vote hopping and lack of justification for it.

[Aegor]

We need to start consolidating on a lynch.

[zMuffinMan]

i'm actually reading this game now!

how cool is that?

[zMuffinMan]

only taken me 2 weeks

[Mac]

This is pretty much it, AJ was missing most of night one, and the bolded is a total misrep of what the fuck went down really. That's a bit worrying.

Really? That's silly. If you wanted to share more thoughts your posting could have been "here are my thoughts - what are yours?". You didn't share much Night 1 - you shared nothing. I'll admit to not checking the time stamps, but I'm pretty sure there was a gap between AJ's reply and question and the end of Night. Why does me saying this worry you?

I wanted AJ's thoughts first. I had a reasonable townread on him from d1 reachouts but during night one I wanted to see how his reads were looking. Obviously I couldn't reply (the gap you are referring to between AJ's was the wee hours of the night here) but I opened my posting on n2 in the neighbourhood with my reads as well.

It worries me cus it looked like you were trying to spin me out to be delibrately not posting, or at fault for the lack of posts, when in fact it was AJ's - evidently, he couldn't help it though.

[Mac]

"Who knows"...well the point is that you are in a position to know more, and you didn't care enough to. If my neighbor says to me, "I'm busy, I don't care, and my claim will save me if it comes to it," you can bet I'm going to have some follow-up questions. TBH I find both you and Aj's behavior regarding that exchange to be strange. I'm trying to decide whether strange == scummy.

Last sentence is fair since I haven't been too into this game, but LOL considering the source.

What should my line of questioning have been here then, superman? "wat iz ur role" does not qualify as a question.

Nice discredit in the last line. Here's how your questioning went:

Mac: Me and AJ are in a neighbourhood
KDub: So you and Muffin are in a neighbourhood?
Someone else: No, him and AJ
Kdub: Okay, so you and AJ are in a neighbourhood?

SG: *paraphrases everything that happened in the neighbourhood*
Kdub: Did you two claim in the neighbourhood?

Both of those were entirely pointless questions just covered, and it looks like you're just asking things in an effort to look like you're doing something.

Vote: Kdub

[borkjerfkin]

Votecount 3.6

[3] Hello Kitty Creampuff (Squirrel Girl, Aegor, Jake From State Farm)
[1] Aegor (Kdub)
[1] Jake From State Farm (Hello Kitty Creampuff)
[1] Kdub (Mac)
[1] Mac (Antihero)
[1] Squirrel Girl (zMuffinMan)

[1] Not Voting (BROseidon)

With 9 alive, it is 5 to lynch.

Let me know if you see any problems.

Deadline is in (expired on 2014-05-16 17:00:00)

[borkjerfkin]

BROseidon was prodded.

[Kdub]

What should my line of questioning have been here then, superman? "wat iz ur role" does not qualify as a question.

"Why are you being deliberately antitown?" might have been a nice start, or "explain yourself" or something along those lines. Definitely not just ignoring it altogether.

Nice discredit in the last line.

Both of those were entirely pointless questions just covered, and it looks like you're just asking things in an effort to look like you're doing something.

My discredit is accurate. Last quote is hypocritical since you cherry-picking quotes to paint me as scummy is pretty much exactly the thing you are accusing me of.

[Jake from State Farm]

kdub, the aegor wagon isn't likely to happen. time to join the HKC wagon

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

im burned out and this game does not interest me one bit

why is this so boring, and jake stop tunneling