Organic Chemistry [GAME OVER]

[Speedy Saki]

Like, I do see why you see mastin as scummy
And I see your reasoning for mtd as well


But could you compare them to each other and give us pointers on comparatively?

[Speedy Saki]

Ha I stole your page top

[MTD]

Dammit, Wicked, I was expecting to get speedlynched now, you can't just break the chain...

The question was actually: "Why would I vote Lying Cat if I didn't suspect them?" There's no scum motive that I can see - I honestly have no idea why scum would vote somebody that they don't suspect. But Vezok said that he doesn't believe Lying Cat was my top suspect even though I voted him and expressed suspicion of nobody else. Vezok's thought process doesn't make sense to me.

Uhm, what?
How

can

scum even "suspect" anyone when they know who is scum? Or do you mean pretend to suspect?

[Wickedestjr]

Wicked is good

He modded perpetual mylo

Hehe thanks. That was a great game

Why is Mastin being a bigger scum read than mtd?

I voted MTD because his vote felt poorly justified and opportunistic. It still does, but I am willing to attribute that to inexperience - MTD has only been here for half a year and I could imagine MTDtown making a mistake like this with that amount of experience. The vote still bothers me, but not as much as mastin's behavior has.

I actually think mastin slipped up. She posted a list of the active players which really really looks like it had an order to it. And I was at the very bottom, second to last in fact. However, remember the game I brought up: mastin as town very strongly accused me of being mafia for the entire game and I was town. So it doesn't make sense for mastin as town to have me as 2nd strongest suspect here when I'm playing the same. But I don't think scum mastin realized that until I brought it up, even though she claims that she had remembered and was considering it. Note that her read gradually changes from 2nd top suspect to neutral-leaningscum-butmaybenotleaningscum after I bring up the game as if she hadn't been considering it before though. She tries to cover this up now by saying I wasn't her 2nd top suspect even though the list she posted yesterday disagrees. Does that make sense?

[Wickedestjr]

MTD, I mean pretend.

[Speedy Saki]

I don't think I quite understand your scum read on mastin

You are reading him scum because he is reading you 2nd suspect, despite you playing exactly the same as before? Am I getting this right?

But that could easily be explained with mastin having a #1 scum read, which is scummier than you in this game :
Is that a plausible explanation?

[Snork]

plus wicked is moss and he gets points for that.

[Speedy Saki]

Anti hero must punish ^


Wicked is default town

[Snork]

he cannot punish me.

[Snork]

I AM NO ONE!!!!!!!!

[Wickedestjr]

Yeah I think I worded that poorly. I'll try again, explaining the situation step by step in the Adrian Monk black and white flashback style...


Here's what happened...

I post and pretty much everyone thinks I'm scum. = (There was no opposition to my bandwagon at this point).

Enter mastin at this time. He posts a list of the players that strongly implies I am his 2nd strongest suspect or at least one of his strongest suspects. He can have me as 2nd strongest with ease because of all the support my bandwagon had. = (I think I've adequately explained how the list has an order to it, let me know otherwise).

I reference a game where I was town, played similarly to here, and was strongly and incorrectly accused by mastintown. = (mastin was 100% certain that I was scum in that game).

mastinscum realizes that he's made a mistake. He should have been hesitant to suspect me, but his list demonstrates no such hesitance.
He realizes that he should have learned from his past experience.

mastinscum now starts to pretend that he remembered/considered the game, because he knows that he should have. = (He acknowledges the other game for the first time here.)

I am asleep / at school not posting or doing anything to change mastin's mind about me.

mastin readjusts his read on me to reflect the lesson he should have learned from the other game. = (He describes his read on me as wishy-washyneutral here, a subtle but noticeable change from his read here or here.)


The evidence that this is what actually happened;
mastin2 now claims that he never had me as his 2nd strongest suspect even though his previous posts suggest otherwise. He knows that, if he was town, he should have been considering the other game and his 2nd strongest suspect read doesn't make sense if he had been considering it. So he acts like he never took that stance in the first place, but I think it's clear that he did.

[Wickedestjr]

plus wicked is moss and he gets points for that.

Of course. Moss is a good guy. And he'd never hurt a fly, let alone... organic compounds.

[Wickedestjr]

There's a part of me that wants to vote you simply so I can have a rumor made about me.

[Snork]

There were rumors that there was a rumor, but that was just bullshit.

[Wickedestjr]

ok Douglas

Fing about Arsenal is, they always try an' walk it in

[Wickedestjr]

Did you see that ludicrous display last night?

[Speedy Saki]

This is day 1 there was no last night

[vezokpiraka]

My mind is going to explode if I see more people posting about mastins thoughts. You can't outpredict her. You are literally digging a hole for yourself and you won't be able to get out.

[Speedy Saki]

^

And that's why he's in the town block!

[Majiffy]

My mind is going to explode if I see more people posting about mastins thoughts. You can't outpredict her. You are literally digging a hole for yourself and you won't be able to get out.

You should probably vote her.

[MTD]

MTD, I mean pretend.

Ok, nvm that then.

[Speedy Saki]

What exactly did that clarification achieve?


Seems to me like scummy fluff

I think that my gut read on MTD is not relaxing

[Speedy Saki]

That is a bad sign

[ZZZX]

Updated VC cuz I needed one.

Heck Reaction

Bipolarchemist - 1 (PeregrineV)
Guilty Gunsmith - 1 (Titus)
Majiffy - 1 (mastin2)
mastin2 - 2 (Perpetual Nonsense, vezokpiraka)
MTD - 3 (Wickedestjr, Speedy Saki, GG)
Titus - 1 (pirate mollie)
Wickedestjr - 4 (Doduo, Lying Cat, Majiffy, MTD, ZZZX)

Not Voting: beastcharizard, Bipolarchemist, zabriel

9 to lynch. Deadline: (expired on 2014-06-09 12:00:54)

MTD and/or ZZZX look like the scum on wicked's wagon to me. PV's vote makes no sense. Titus' vote is meaningless. Mastin's vote is scummy. PN/vez's votes I get. Agree with where our vote is at the moment @AP. PM's vote is scummy.

K that's all. Back to work for me.

-snork

WHEN THE HELL DID I VOTE WICKED???

@mod Is this a mistake?

Time to iso myself LOLWAT

[ZZZX]

well-hung fruit

I may be a fruit, but Im not THAT well hung....

Speak for yourself AP

ISO'd ZZZX on request. He's scum.

Sthar

this is nothing like his town play from what I remember. There's no scum hunting. He's not even trying.

The rest I don't know. I haven't been following because life sucks at the moment.

AP you have control of the vote until I get caught up on ISOs.

-snork

Care to explain what makes me scum from ISO? It cant just be simply without a read.

Read my iso closely and it will be clear.