Organic Chemistry [GAME OVER]

[Guilty Gunsmith]

Well like I said, I can understand why she thinks that. I just know it's wrong.

- Snork

[Titus]

PN, why didn't you investigate this sooner? You know, when I made the claim.

Now that I'm considering *gasp* working with GG this comes up.

[Guilty Gunsmith]

There are two factions in this game. An organic town (13 players) and an inorganic mafia (4 players).

[Lying Cat]

p-edit: Hi Sthar I want to chat with you.

Go for it. Be aware that I haven't read anything in the last 20 pages.

[Perpetual Nonsense]

PN, why didn't you investigate this sooner? You know, when I made the claim.

Now that I'm considering *gasp* working with GG this comes up.

Yup. Scum. Let's lynch this now.

[Guilty Gunsmith]

p-edit: Hi Sthar I want to chat with you.

Go for it. Be aware that I haven't read anything in the last 20 pages.

Understood. Where are you wrt reads at this moment?

- snork

[Guilty Gunsmith]

PN, why didn't you investigate this sooner? You know, when I made the claim.

Now that I'm considering *gasp* working with GG this comes up.

Yup. Scum. Let's lynch this now.

You need to explain how you get to these kinds of conclusions. Why is this post scummy, as opposed to our "slip"?

- Snork

[PeregrineV]

There are 4 townies and 13 scummies. Its a p simple game afaict.

This.

Titus believes it's a slip because "4 good guys". To us, it's obviously not. She believes this can only come from scum. Fact is that we're town, so obviously not, and that is false. Our flip can and will confirm that. End of story.

- Snork

Well, if you had given some numbers that seemed non-standard for a game this size, I might give that more credit. But since 16 is usually 12-4, I think this one is probably 13-4. And I get that you said 4 townies and 13 scum, but figured that was your humor shining through.

Short version: Not a slip

Off topic:
9 scum, 4 town (A fun time was had by most)
9 scum, 4 town (Didn't go near as well as I wanted/planned)

[Guilty Gunsmith]

There are two factions in this game. An organic town (13 players) and an inorganic mafia (4 players).

[PeregrineV]

PV - it was more about the way they felt compared to NY 172. Very similar kind of "idgaf I'm having fun" tone. Not a solid town read by any stretch, and totally a snork read as I haven't discussed BPC specifically with AP yet.

- Snork

p-edit: Hi Sthar I want to chat with you.

Ah, not BiPolar, I was talking about Duoduo

[PeregrineV]

There are two factions in this game. An organic town (13 players) and an inorganic mafia (4 players).

I know this is a polite way of saying read the OP....

[PeregrineV]

Cross-talk

[Guilty Gunsmith]

The Doduo read is an AP read. I'm in the "kill them with fire for being annoying" camp, but not so much lately. I admit they are probably town for it.

- Snork

AP GO TO QT PRTY PLS

[vezokpiraka]

Ok.
I will explain my read.

The reasons I didn't say why I find you scummy was because I decided something with PN, but I think it's better if i explain my reads.

Will come back after LoL game finishes.

[MTD]

V/LA tomorrow through Monday

/inb4 50 more pages.

[Guilty Gunsmith]

V/LA tomorrow through Monday

/inb4 50 more pages.

Can you give an update on your reads before you disappear?????

- Snork

[MTD]

V/LA tomorrow through Monday

/inb4 50 more pages.

Can you give an update on your reads before you disappear?????

- Snork

Aye.
I think there is scum in {BPC,BC,LC,Titus}, one of Jiffy/mastin

may

be scum, although I still lean towards town/town there.

Other townreads are PN, vezok, GG, mollie.
Also Wicked probtown, though that's not strong since there was little from there recently.
I liked PVs posts.

[Guilty Gunsmith]

What do you think of Doduo, ZZZX, and Saki?

[MTD]

Doduo pretty null, that's why I didn't list them.
SS and ZZZX slightly town for their exchange with each other, but for not much else.
Like, for at least Doduo and ZZZX there were people saying "Woah they so obvscum" which I just couldn't agree with, but they didn't look extraordinarily town either.

[mastin2]

Oh, geez, this won't be fun. By the time I get back, I'll have over ten pages.

I don't think it's possible to be more non-committal.

True, but I scumhunt better that way anyway.

Anyway, just popping in briefly to say that this message here is where I am.
And that I'm V/LA for all of today (day-day, not game-day) meaning that I'm gone, like...well basically right now since the message has been communicated.
Apologies for any inconveniences it'll cause.

[vezokpiraka]

YOU asked me why I am not voting charazard?

Yes I did.

Snd instead of giving me insight into what you are doing with your vote (nothing)

you gave me some really throwaway reasons for not voting Charizard: "Well BC -could- be scum, but Im usually wrong when I think this"

Typically your opinion on the gamestate as a whole should also impact whether or not you want to vote Charizard. The singlemindedness of the response could just be a personality thing, but it also doesn't feel like something a townie who was genuinely unsure what to do with their vote would say.

bold is contraction

italic is pure bs

The bold is me agreeing with you (that I DID ask you about your lack of BC vote specifically) and then me summarizing your provided reasons for not voting BC. Your English teacher may give you A's, but Im giving you a B for "Better up your scumgame next time" cause there is no contradiction there and its pretty clear you are making no effort to understand my post at all before painting it scummy.

The italics part of my quote is me explaining why I didn't like your response. I guess I don't have a good answer as to WHY its not BS since that is mostly what I feel -I- would do in your situation as town if I were asked to explain my vote.

!Snork

This post irks me the wrong way. The way you give a non-committal scum read on ZZZX feels just off. It seem to come from scum that want to be open about which wagons they could pursue, instead of town actually believing what they wrote.

[Guilty Gunsmith]

But vez, we've been scumreading ZZZX since page 9... that read has not changed.

- Snork

[Guilty Gunsmith]

He's our strongest scum read right now.

[vezokpiraka]

ffs that was AP. And I don't understand what you are confused about. He asked for solid reasoning and you gave fluffy reasons, if I am reading this right. He's not saying you're scum for answering his question. He's saying you're scum for answering his question badly.

If you're not scum, you're an idiot with reading comprehension problems. You're arguing (bad) semantics and making distractions. This makes you very likely scum and I agree with AP about it.

- Snork

This comes from a mindset that knows what's up behind the scenes. The second paragraph basically says that if ZZZX is town he is doing a bad job and is scum. Read it again. That is exactly what it says.

I don't think town can get conf bias that quickly. I think everything you wrote is staged.

[Guilty Gunsmith]

The missing information from the second paragraph is that I don't believe he is bad town, though I thought that idea was fairly clear.

Explain how it "comes from a mindset that knows whats up behind the scenes" when we dont? I mean it's really that simple. We don't.

- Snork