Mewbie 1506: Day 3

[Malakittens]

2.08

With Seven Alive.. It takes Four to Lynch

Voting:

*Jake From State Farm - Seraph, Nero Cain [2]
*The Bulge -
*Randomidget - The bulge, Jake From State Farm [2]
*HunterSeeker - Rachmarie, HunterSeeker [2]
*Seraph -
*RachMarie -
*Nero Cain - Randomidget [1]

Not Voting:

[0]

Mew Count Downs

Day 2 ends in.. (expired on 2014-06-26 22:53:00)

[Nero Cain]

being confident in my own reads

stop being an idiot.

Dude I told you to stop insulting me

mod please

stop running to the mod. If you can dish it you need to be able to take it.

[Jake from State Farm]

Except I haven't insulted you. If I insulted you I would be ok getting insulted back.

[Jake from State Farm]

You want me lynched, talk to everyone else EXCEPT me since I'm not going to self vote and you need their votes.

Continuing to bait me isn't pro-town and it's distracting me from my original scum read.

[Malakittens]

The Bulge replaces Tysker

[The Bulge]

Hey all. Catching up

[Malakittens]

Nero, Jake stop.

[Nero Cain]

Hey all. Catching up

hey is for horsies. Scum in Midget, Jake, Marie, eh?

[Jake from State Farm]

Take your time and read the entire thread and make your own opinions. Shame on the IC for trying to bias you

[The Bulge]

Opinions, reads etc might have to wait until morning. I don't want to just skim.

[The Bulge]

Just for housekeeping, I'll UNVOTE: Randommidget.

[Jake from State Farm]

Just noticed rach went on v/la. Sure would have been "helpful" of her to tell us about it.

[The Bulge]

Alright quick notes before bed. I have an exam tomorrow afternoon so I should crash soon.
These are mostly based on gut, I'll do a more thorough analysis in the morning but here are a couple (very) small observations.

Jake vs Nero strikes me, surprisingly enough, as Town vs Town. They are both experienced players, and no scum in their right mind would play so offensively.
I don't like the HunterSeeker self-vote one bit. Still no strong scum read though. We'll see after I look further into it.

I understand we're coming close to the deadline, so I'll hurry things up as best as I can. Cheers

[Seraph]

Welcome Bulge, look forward to your detailed reads.

VOTE: HunterSeeker

L-1 WARNING

[Nero Cain]

They are both experienced players, and no scum in their right mind would play so offensively

There's no absolutes in mafia. Yes,

most

players are less argumentative as scum but its not like all scum are scaredy cats like Rachscum. What do you think of his actual words?

HS, claim in your next post.

[RachMarie]

sorry all net issues the cable guy will be here on Tues which is why I went V/LA

[Jake from State Farm]

But you posted elsewhere on site yesterday but not in here...

In the MD thread about lurking a couple people seem to agree that scum lurk through key moments in the game. I feel like the arguments between myself and Nero and AP & hunter both getting to L-1 would qualify as key moments of this game. Making a big case on you also qualifies as a key moment Imo , so was Nero hopping off random and voting you.

Sure you did post right around that time but nothing of value.

I really hope you are scum rach, I really do.

[RachMarie]

Dude seriously, I work from home as well as play, so having to reset the router umpteen times a day is VERY frustrating for all 3 of us. NS and I both work from home, and his son is a heavy duty gamer dude. Tempers are high around our house atm. For example, his son broke a huge TV he had bought on payments, and his cell phone, plus put some holes in his bedroom walls which we will have to fix before we leave here.

[Jake from State Farm]

You realize every game I have ever played with you, you have a new excuse for why you are not posting regularly right? I can't recall a single game where I didn't accuse you of lurking.

I'm just not a big fan of teaching newbies bad habits. Lurking is already a huge problem on site.

I'm sorry you are having internet issues and a kid who wants to destroy shit but I'm playing a game here and I want to lynch scum and I can't read you cause you make yourself impossible to read. You always make yourself impossible to read. It's frustrating as hell

[Jake from State Farm]

mod, I don't believe that countdown in your VC is correct. You said we were getting 2 extra days right?

[Jake from State Farm]

Btw it's soon freaking tempting to just hammer right now but I won't. Even if he deserves it, I still want to hear from the new guy

[Malakittens]

mod, I don't believe that countdown in your VC is correct. You said we were getting 2 extra days right?

I'm aware. I forgot I'm adding another 2 days and 12 hours when I get home.

[Nero Cain]

So you think Rach is bussing hunter?

[The Bulge]

They are both experienced players, and no scum in their right mind would play so offensively

There's no absolutes in mafia. Yes,

most

players are less argumentative as scum but its not like all scum are scaredy cats like Rachscum. What do you think of his actual words?

HS, claim in your next post.

Of course there's no absolutes, I know that. By offensively, I mean it in both sense. The first being actively scumhunting (ie offense), which of course scum will do. The second sense is offensive as in attacking people, offending them. Basically what I'm saying is,

in general

mafia won't play so aggressively. It's attention they don't need. And arguably the most attention right now is focused on the beef between Jake and Nero.

Obviously it's hard to point out specific posts where someone is acting "towny" as oppose to quoting scummy posts, but reading through their ISOs is only reinforcing my belief. Both seem town.

@Nero:

I don't quite understand your question.



Now for HunterSeeker.

There's too much to quote and analyze everything, but here are a few.

Now that I've found my first maf. It is time to read through to get our last maf XD.

I can't tell if this is joking or not. But it still rubs me the wrong way. Seems a little early for a confident statement like that. He provides no further read on Zawad which leads me to believe that this is more or less serious.

@Seraph: Nope no offense taken but I wish you'd take down your vote on me sooner than later because

...

And to answer your question - I didn't want to be too specific when answering fakespeare, lest this be used by the mafia this game or worse, by mafia against me. But if you really wanted to know, what has worked for me before, is to 'forget' you are mafia and 'forget' you have a partner while keeping an eye on opportunity to have town lynched . Playing mafia is really conflicting at times, on one hand you have to contribute and help town find mafia, the more genuine the efforts the better, but on the other hand you have to lynch people that you know are confirmed town to you.

Way too paranoid for town.

I think Hunter is more scum.

VOTE: Hunter

VOTE: Fake

Fake, let's discuss, if you see the Nero/Random cross as not a town cross, and are willing to lynch one or even two of them today and tomorrow I'd be happy to vote along for reasons I stated above. But if you insist on tunneling me, you leave me no choice but to omgus this.

So basically...
"I'm pretty confident I've found scum and if I had support behind me, I'd vote them, but in stead I'm going to OMGUS defend myself from one vote."

@HS

You said your vote on fake was OMGUS and that he is tunneling, so you must think he is town. What's your vote on fake gonna accomplish?
And just to clarify: Do you think fake is town?

Eh what? No. Why would I vote a town, thats blatant anti-town. I omgused because he is tunneling as opposed to scumhunting which is scummy and the fact he is tunneling me is interfaring with my reads. So there.

Aaaaand scrambling to defend the OMGUS, contradicting what was said in the above quote.

Oh and by the way, IF i'm scum I'd claim PR when being lynched to potentially fish out a CC as everyone seem to sheep the "claim role when getting lynched thing". But since I'm not scum theefore I'm not going to claim anything but vanilla town (no use withholding this info as I already soft claimed non-pr town).

Hunter pls.
Town doesn't PR fish like this. It just isn't logical.

I would instant vote/lynch anyone that is lying and saying something that other people did not say counts as lying.

Wait... but aren't we supposed to lynch scum? Silly hunterseeker.

All this plus the self-vote and just a string of bad logic and frantic self-defense (ie "QUOTE ME QUOTE ME QUOTAUOASFASOF") lead me to believe HunterSeeker is scum OR newb-town.

That being said, I would not be averse to a hammer.

[Nero Cain]

It's attention they don't need. And arguably the most attention right now is focused on the beef between Jake and Nero.

Like, I totes understand this but there are still players that are abrasive as scum. Does Jake do this as scum? idk yet. I'll prob meta him later. He may be just really bad town that's to headstrong to admit he's wrong but some of the stuff he's saying is just...I have a hard time seeing it coming from town. Calling me and Jake tvt 'cause we are arguing like an old married couple is fine but I wish you'd actually look at the arguments.